Reply to comment by A. Revil and N. Linde on 'Streaming potential dependence on water-content in Fontainebleau sand'

被引:12
作者
Allegre, V. [1 ]
Jouniaux, L. [1 ]
Lehmann, F. [2 ]
Sailhac, P. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Strasbourg, Inst Phys Globe Strasbourg, UdS CNRS, UMR 7516, F-67084 Strasbourg, France
[2] Univ Strasbourg, Lab Hydrol & Geochim Strasbourg, UdS CNRS, UMR 7517, F-67000 Strasbourg, France
关键词
Electrical properties; Hydrogeophysics; Hydrology; Permeability and porosity; Fracture and flow; INVERSION; ANOMALIES; SURFACE; FLOW;
D O I
10.1111/j.1365-246X.2011.05038.x
中图分类号
P3 [地球物理学]; P59 [地球化学];
学科分类号
0708 ; 070902 ;
摘要
Revil and Linde recently commented our paper concerning streaming potential (SP) measurements in unsaturated sand during drainage experiments. This comment suggests that the approach used to infer SP coefficients was inappropriate for unsaturated conditions, and therefore yielded wrong conclusions and 'unphysical' results regarding the behaviour of the relative SP coefficient. This reply argues that even if in Allegre et al. we neglected some secondary electrokinetic sources, the resulting conclusions are still representative of the behaviour of the true SP coefficient, and that the remarks of Revil & Linde arose from a misunderstanding of the drainage experiment conditions. We also find support for our results from a comparison between our observations and previous experimental studies.
引用
收藏
页码:115 / 117
页数:3
相关论文
共 17 条
[1]   Streaming potential dependence on water-content in Fontainebleau sand [J].
Allegre, V. ;
Jouniaux, L. ;
Lehmann, F. ;
Sailhac, P. .
GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL, 2010, 182 (03) :1248-1266
[2]   SURFACE IONIZATION AND COMPLEXATION AT OXIDE-WATER INTERFACE .1. COMPUTATION OF ELECTRICAL DOUBLE-LAYER PROPERTIES IN SIMPLE ELECTROLYTES [J].
DAVIS, JA ;
JAMES, RO ;
LECKIE, JO .
JOURNAL OF COLLOID AND INTERFACE SCIENCE, 1978, 63 (03) :480-499
[3]   Comment on "Self-potential signals associated with preferential groundwater flow pathways in sinkholes'' by A. Jardani, J. P. Dupont, and A. Revil [J].
Gibert, Dominique ;
Sailhac, Pascal .
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH, 2008, 113 (B3)
[4]   Permeability prediction from MICP and NMR data using an electrokinetic approach - Reply to the discussion [J].
Glover, P. W. J. .
GEOPHYSICS, 2007, 72 (04) :X4-X5
[5]   Multiphase electrokinetic coupling: Insights into the impact of fluid and charge distribution at the pore scale from a bundle of capillary tubes model [J].
Jackson, Matthew D. .
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH, 2010, 115
[6]   Reply to comment by Revil on "Rapid fluid disruption: A source for self-potential anomalies'' by M. J. S. Johnston, J. D. Byerlee, and D. Lockner [J].
Johnston, MJS ;
Lockner, D ;
Byerlee, JD .
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH, 2002, 107 (B8)
[7]   Reply to the comment by A. Revil on "Review of Self-potential methods in Hydrogeophysics" by L. Jouniaux et al. [C. R. Geoscience 341 (2009) 928-936] [J].
Jouniaux, Laurence ;
Maineult, Alexis ;
Naudet, Veronique ;
Pessel, Marc ;
Sailhac, Pascal .
COMPTES RENDUS GEOSCIENCE, 2010, 342 (10) :810-813
[8]   Reply to comment by A. Revil on "Effect of the flow state on streaming current'' [J].
Kuwano, Osamu ;
Nakatani, Masao ;
Yoshida, Shingo .
GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, 2007, 34 (09)
[9]   Streaming current generation in two-phase flow conditions [J].
Linde, N. ;
Jougnot, D. ;
Revil, A. ;
Matthaei, S. K. ;
Arora, T. ;
Renard, D. ;
Doussan, C. .
GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, 2007, 34 (03)
[10]   Reply to comment on "Electrical tomography of La Soufriere of Guadeloupe Volcano: Field experiments, 1D inversion and qualitative interpretation" by N. Linde and A. Revil [J].
Nicollin, Florence ;
Gibert, Dominique ;
Beauducel, Francois ;
Boudon, Georges ;
Komorowski, Jean-Christophe .
EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCE LETTERS, 2007, 258 (3-4) :623-626