Diagnostic Accuracy of Rapid Antigen Tests for COVID-19 Detection: A Systematic Review With Meta-analysis

被引:28
作者
Arshadi, Maniya [1 ,2 ]
Fardsanei, Fatemeh [3 ]
Deihim, Behnaz [4 ]
Farshadzadeh, Zahra [1 ,2 ]
Nikkhahi, Farhad [3 ]
Khalili, Farima [5 ]
Sotgiu, Giovanni [6 ]
Bonjar, Amir Hashem Shahidi [7 ]
Centis, Rosella [8 ]
Migliori, Giovanni Battista [8 ]
Nasiri, Mohammad Javad [5 ]
Mirsaeidi, Mehdi [9 ]
机构
[1] Ahvaz Jundishapur Univ Med Sci, Infect & Trop Dis Res Ctr, Hlth Res Inst, Ahvaz, Iran
[2] Ahvaz Jundishapur Univ Med Sci, Sch Med, Dept Microbiol, Ahvaz, Iran
[3] Qazvin Univ Med Sci, Med Microbiol Res Ctr, Qazvin, Iran
[4] Dezful Univ Med Sci, Sch Med, Dept Bacteriol & Virol, Dezful, Iran
[5] Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci, Sch Med, Dept Microbiol, Tehran, Iran
[6] Ist Clin Sci Maugeri IRCCS, Tradate, Italy
[7] Shahid Beheshti Univ Med Sci, Sch Dent, Dent Mat & Restorat Dent, Tehran, Iran
[8] Univ Sassari, Dept Med Surg & Expt Sci, Clin Epidemiol & Med Stat Unit, Sassari, Italy
[9] Univ Florida, Coll Med Jacksonville, Div Pulm & Crit Care, Gainesville, FL 32611 USA
关键词
COVID-19; SARS-CoV-2; rapid antigen test; specificity; sensitivity; meta-analysis; POLYMERASE-CHAIN-REACTION; SARS-COV-2 NUCLEOCAPSID PROTEIN; NASOPHARYNGEAL SWABS; RT-PCR; PERFORMANCE; INFECTION; COMMUNITY; IMMUNOASSAY; ASSAY; SIZE;
D O I
10.3389/fmed.2022.870738
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Introduction:& nbsp;Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to detect SARS-CoV-2 is time-consuming and sometimes not feasible in developing nations. Rapid antigen test (RAT) could decrease the load of diagnosis. However, the efficacy of RAT is yet to be investigated comprehensively. Thus, the current systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of RAT against RT-PCR methods as the reference standard.& nbsp;Methods:& nbsp;We searched the MEDLINE/Pubmed and Embase databases for the relevant records. The QUADAS-2 tool was used to assess the quality of the studies. Diagnostic accuracy measures [i.e., sensitivity, specificity, diagnostic odds ratio (DOR), positive likelihood ratios (PLR), negative likelihood ratios (NLR), and the area under the curve (AUC)] were pooled with a random-effects model. All statistical analyses were performed with Meta-DiSc (Version 1.4, Cochrane Colloquium, Barcelona, Spain).& nbsp;Results:& nbsp;After reviewing retrieved records, we identified 60 studies that met the inclusion criteria. The pooled sensitivity and specificity of the rapid antigen tests against the reference test (the real-time PCR) were 69% (95% CI: 68-70) and 99% (95% CI: 99-99). The PLR, NLR, DOR and the AUC estimates were found to be 72 (95% CI: 44-119), 0.30 (95% CI: 0.26-0.36), 316 (95% CI: 167-590) and 97%, respectively.& nbsp;Conclusion:& nbsp;The present study indicated that using RAT kits is primarily recommended for the early detection of patients suspected of having COVID-19, particularly in countries with limited resources and laboratory equipment. However, the negative RAT samples may need to be confirmed using molecular tests, mainly when the symptoms of COVID-19 are present.
引用
收藏
页数:13
相关论文
共 92 条
[1]   Molecular diagnostic technologies for COVID-19: Limitations and challenges [J].
Afzal, Adeel .
JOURNAL OF ADVANCED RESEARCH, 2020, 26 :149-159
[2]   Field performance evaluation of the PanBio rapid SARS-CoV-2 antigen assay in an epidemic driven by the B.1.351 variant in the Eastern Cape, South Africa [J].
Akingba, Oluwakemi Laguda ;
Sprong, Kaitlin ;
Marais, Gert ;
Hardie, Diana Ruth .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY PLUS, 2021, 1 (1-2)
[3]   Field evaluation of a rapid antigen test (Panbio™ COVID-19 Ag Rapid Test Device) for COVID-19 diagnosis in primary healthcare centres [J].
Albert, Eliseo ;
Torres, Ignacio ;
Bueno, Felipe ;
Huntley, Dixie ;
Molla, Estefania ;
Angel Fernandez-Fuentes, Miguel ;
Martinez, Mireia ;
Poujois, Sandrine ;
Forque, Lorena ;
Valdivia, Arantxa ;
Solano de la Asuncion, Carlos ;
Ferrer, Josep ;
Colomina, Javier ;
Navarro, David .
CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2021, 27 (03) :472.e7-472.e10
[4]   Analytical and clinical performance of the panbio COVID-19 antigen-detecting rapid diagnostic test [J].
Alemany, Andrea ;
Baro, Barbara ;
Ouchi, Dan ;
Rodo, Pau ;
Ubals, Maria ;
Corbacho-Monne, Marc ;
Vergara-Alert, Julia ;
Rodon, Jordi ;
Segales, Joaquim ;
Esteban, Cristina ;
Fernandez, Gema ;
Ruiz, Lidia ;
Bassat, Quique ;
Clotet, Bonaventura ;
Ara, Jordi ;
Vall-Mayans, Marti ;
G-Beiras, Camila ;
Blanco, Ignacio ;
Mitja, Oriol .
JOURNAL OF INFECTION, 2021, 82 (05) :188-191
[5]  
[Anonymous], 2018, homepage
[6]   Performance characteristics of five antigen-detecting rapid diagnostic test (Ag-RDT) for SARS-CoV-2 asymptomatic infection: a head-to-head benchmark comparison [J].
Baro, Barbara ;
Rodo, Pau ;
Ouchi, Dan ;
Bordoy, Antoni E. ;
Saya Amaro, Emilio N. ;
Salsench, Sergi, V ;
Molinos, Sonia ;
Alemany, Andrea ;
Ubals, Maria ;
Corbacho-Monne, Marc ;
Millat-Martinez, Pere ;
Marks, Michael ;
Clotet, Bonaventura ;
Prat, Nuria ;
Estrada, Oriol ;
Vilar, Marc ;
Ara, Jordi ;
Vall-Mayans, Marti ;
G-Beiras, Camila ;
Bassat, Quique ;
Blanco, Ignacio ;
Mitja, Oriol .
JOURNAL OF INFECTION, 2021, 82 (06) :269-275
[7]   Diagnostic accuracy of two commercial SARS-CoV-2 antigen-detecting rapid tests at the point of care in community-based testing centers [J].
Berger, Alice ;
Nsoga, Marie Therese Ngo ;
Perez-Rodriguez, Francisco Javier ;
Aad, Yasmine Abi ;
Sattonnet-Roche, Pascale ;
Gayet-Ageron, Angele ;
Jaksic, Cyril ;
Torriani, Giulia ;
Boehm, Erik ;
Kronig, Ilona ;
Sacks, Jilian A. ;
de Vos, Margaretha ;
Bausch, Frederique Jacquerioz ;
Chappuis, Francois ;
Renzoni, Adriana ;
Kaiser, Laurent ;
Schibler, Manuel ;
Eckerle, Isabella .
PLOS ONE, 2021, 16 (03)
[8]   Implementation of rapid SARS-CoV-2 antigenic testing in a laboratory without access to molecular methods: Experiences of a general hospital [J].
Blairon, Laurent ;
Wilmet, Alain ;
Beukinga, Ingrid ;
Tre-Hardy, Marie .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2020, 129
[9]   Rapid diagnosis of COVID-19 in the first year of the pandemic: A systematic review [J].
Borges, Lysandro Pinto ;
Martins, Aline Fagundes ;
Silva, Breno de Mello ;
Dias, Bruna de Paula ;
Goncalves, Ricardo Lemes ;
Souza, Daniela Raguer Valadao de ;
Oliveira, Makson Gleydson Brito de ;
Jesus, Pamela Chaves de ;
Serafini, Mairim Russo ;
Quintans, Jullyana Souza Siqueira ;
Coutinho, Henrique Douglas Melo ;
Martins, Natalia ;
Quintans Junior, Lucindo Jose .
INTERNATIONAL IMMUNOPHARMACOLOGY, 2021, 101
[10]   Analytical performances of the point-of-care SIENNATM COVID-19 Antigen Rapid Test for the detection of SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein in nasopharyngeal swabs: A prospective evaluation during the COVID-19 second wave in France [J].
Bouassa, Ralph-Sydney Mboumba ;
Veyer, David ;
Pere, Helene ;
Belec, Laurent .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2021, 106 :8-12