The danger of naturalizing water policy concepts: Water productivity and efficiency discourses from field irrigation to virtual water trade

被引:121
作者
Boelens, Rutgerd [1 ]
Vos, Jeroen [1 ]
机构
[1] Wageningen Univ, Environm Sci Grp, NL-6708 PB Wageningen, Netherlands
关键词
Water use efficiency; Productivity; Water policy; Water rights; Water allocation; Irrigation projects; PERFORMANCE; POLITICS; MARKETS; GENDER; IMPACT; POWER; FOOD;
D O I
10.1016/j.agwat.2011.06.013
中图分类号
S3 [农学(农艺学)];
学科分类号
0901 ;
摘要
Naturalization and universal application of concepts such as 'efficiency' and 'productivity' by policy makers and water experts in the water sector leads water managers and water users to internalize these norms. As we show in this exploratory paper, the effects could be threefold: first, evidence suggests that 'efficiency' discourses may justify policies and projects that deprive smallholders of water use rights; second, expert-driven water policy and project notions of efficiency tend to interfere with existing local water management practices and may harm livelihood and production strategies, and third, water users may come to blame themselves for underachieving according to the norms that are established in the dominant power-knowledge structures. This article deals with three mutually connected water policy arenas where maximization of water productivity and efficiency is fiercely promoted: technical water use efficiency (the engineer's realm), allocation efficiency (the economist's realm) at national levels, and the arena of international trade, where allocation efficiency is sought through virtual water flows embedded in agricultural commodities trade. (C) 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:16 / 26
页数:11
相关论文
共 99 条
[1]  
Accion Ecologica, 2000, FLOR MAL FLOR CREC A
[2]  
Achterhuis H, 2010, OUT OF THE MAINSTREAM: WATER RIGHTS, POLITICS AND IDENTITY, P27
[3]   ECOLOGY, LAND USE AND COLONISATION, THE CANAL COLONIES OF PUNJAB [J].
AGNIHOTRI, I .
INDIAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL HISTORY REVIEW, 1996, 33 (01) :37-58
[4]  
Agrawal A., 1997, Dying Wisdom: Rise Fall And Potential Of Indias Traditional Water Harvesting Systems
[5]   Virtual water - the water, food, and trade nexus useful concept or misleading metaphor? [J].
Allan, JA .
WATER INTERNATIONAL, 2003, 28 (01) :106-113
[6]   Virtual water: A strategic resource global solutions to regional deficits [J].
Allan, JA .
GROUND WATER, 1998, 36 (04) :545-546
[7]  
ALLAN JA., 2001, MIDDLE E WATER QUEST, DOI 10.5040/9780755611942
[8]  
[Anonymous], POVERTY IRRIGATED AG
[9]  
[Anonymous], 2007, Water for Food, Water for Life: A Comprehensive Assessment of Water Management in Agriculture, DOI DOI 10.4324/9781849773799
[10]  
[Anonymous], 2011, MULT NEW GLOB EC GLO