Eye health indicators for universal health coverage: results of a global expert prioritisation process

被引:13
作者
McCormick, Ian [1 ]
Mactaggart, Islay [1 ]
Resnikoff, Serge [2 ,3 ]
Muirhead, Debbie [4 ]
Murthy, G., V [1 ,5 ]
Silva, Juan Carlos [6 ]
Bastawrous, Andrew [1 ]
Stern, Jude [7 ]
Blanchet, Karl [8 ]
Wang, Ningli [9 ]
Yusufu, Mayinuer [9 ]
Cooper, Andrew [10 ]
Gichangi, Michael [11 ]
Burton, Matthew J. [1 ,12 ]
Ramke, Jacqueline [1 ,13 ]
机构
[1] London Sch Hyg & Trop Med, Int Ctr Eye Hlth, London WC1E 7HT, England
[2] Brien Holden Vis Inst, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[3] Univ New South Wales, Sch Optometry & Vis Sci, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[4] Fred Hollows Fdn Melbourne, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
[5] Indian Inst Publ Hlth, Hyderabad, India
[6] Pan Amer Hlth Org, Bogota, Colombia
[7] Int Agcy Prevent Blindness, London, England
[8] Univ Geneva, Fac Med, Geneva, Switzerland
[9] Capital Med Univ, Beijing Tongren Hosp, Beijing Tongren Eye Ctr, Beijing Inst Ophthalmol, Beijing, Peoples R China
[10] Vis Catalyst Fund, London, England
[11] Kenya Minist Hlth, Ophthalm Serv Unit, Nairobi, Kenya
[12] Moorfields Eye Hosp, London, England
[13] Univ Auckland, Sch Optometry & Vis Sci, Auckland, New Zealand
基金
英国惠康基金;
关键词
public health;
D O I
10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-318481
中图分类号
R77 [眼科学];
学科分类号
100212 ;
摘要
Introduction In its recent World Report on Vision, the WHO called for an updated approach to monitor eye health as part of universal health coverage (UHC). This project sought to develop a consensus among eye health experts from all world regions to produce a menu of indicators for countries to monitor eye health within UHC. Methods We reviewed the literature to create a long-list of indicators aligned to the conceptual framework for monitoring outlined in WHO's World Report on Vision. We recruited a panel of 72 global eye health experts (40% women) to participate in a two-round, online prioritisation exercise. Two-hundred indicators were presented in Round 1 and participants prioritised each on a 4-point Likert scale. The highest-ranked 95 were presented in Round 2 and were (1) scored against four criteria (feasible, actionable, reliable and internationally comparable) and (2) ranked according to their suitability as a 'core' indicator for collection by all countries. The top 30 indicators ranked by these two parameters were then used as the basis for the steering group to develop a final menu. Results The menu consists of 22 indicators, including 7 core indicators, that represent important concepts in eye health for 2020 and beyond, and are considered feasible, actionable, reliable and internationally comparable. Conclusion We believe this list can inform the development of new national eye health monitoring frameworks, monitor progress on key challenges to eye health and be considered in broader UHC monitoring indices at national and international levels.
引用
收藏
页码:893 / 901
页数:9
相关论文
共 25 条
[1]  
Adelson JD, 2020, Lancet Global Health
[2]   Universal Health Coverage: Assessing Service Coverage and Financial Protection for All [J].
Ataguba, John E. ;
Ingabire, Marie-Gloriose .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2016, 106 (10) :1780-1781
[3]   The Lancet Global Health Commission on Global Eye Health: vision beyond 2020 [J].
Burton, Matthew J. ;
Ramke, Jacqueline ;
Marques, Ana Patricia ;
Bourne, Rupert R. A. ;
Congdon, Nathan ;
Jones, Iain ;
Tong, Brandon A. M. Ah ;
Arunga, Simon ;
Bachani, Damodar ;
Bascaran, Covadonga ;
Bastawrous, Andrew ;
Blanchet, Karl ;
Braithwaite, Tasanee ;
Buchan, John C. ;
Cairns, John ;
Cama, Anasaini ;
Chagunda, Margarida ;
Chuluunkhuu, Chimgee ;
Cooper, Andrew ;
Crofts-Lawrence, Jessica ;
Dean, William H. ;
Denniston, Alastair K. ;
Ehrlich, Joshua R. ;
Emerson, Paul M. ;
Evans, Jennifer R. ;
Frick, Kevin D. ;
Friedman, David S. ;
Furtado, Joao M. ;
Gichangi, Michael M. ;
Gichuhi, Stephen ;
Gilbert, Suzanne S. ;
Gurung, Reeta ;
Habtamu, Esmael ;
Holland, Peter ;
Jonas, Jost B. ;
Keane, Pearse A. ;
Keay, Lisa ;
Khanna, Rohit C. ;
Khaw, Peng Tee ;
Kuper, Hannah ;
Kyari, Fatima ;
Lansingh, Van C. ;
Mactaggart, Islay ;
Mafwiri, Milka M. ;
Mathenge, Wanjiku ;
McCormick, Ian ;
Morjaria, Priya ;
Mowatt, Lizette ;
Muirhead, Debbie ;
Murthy, Gudlavalleti V. S. .
LANCET GLOBAL HEALTH, 2021, 9 (04) :E489-E551
[4]   Proposing standardised geographical indicators of physical access to emergency obstetric and newborn care in low-income and middle-income countries [J].
Ebener, Steeve ;
Stenberg, Karin ;
Brun, Michel ;
Monet, Jean-Pierre ;
Ray, Nicolas ;
Lawrence Sobel, Howard ;
Roos, Nathalie ;
Gault, Patrick ;
Conlon, Claudia Morrissey ;
Bailey, Patsy ;
Moran, Allisyn C. ;
Ouedraogo, Leopold ;
Kitong, Jacqueline F. ;
Ko, Eunyoung ;
Sanon, Djenaba ;
Jega, Farouk M. ;
Azogu, Olajumoke ;
Ouedraogo, Boureima ;
Osakwe, Chidude ;
Chanza, Harriet Chimwemwe ;
Steffen, Mona ;
Ben Hamadi, Imed ;
Tib, Hayat ;
Asaad, Ahmed Haj ;
Torres, Tessa Tan .
BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH, 2019, 4
[5]   Field Testing Project to Pilot World Health Organization Eye Health Indicators in Latin America [J].
Eckert, Kristen A. ;
Lansingh, Van C. ;
McLeod-Omawale, Joan ;
Furtado, Joao M. ;
Martinez-Castro, Francisco ;
Carter, Marissa J. .
OPHTHALMIC EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2018, 25 (02) :91-104
[6]  
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, 2020, GLOB BURD DIS GBD GD
[7]   Measuring universal health coverage based on an index of effective coverage of health services in 204 countries and territories, 1990-2019: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2019 [J].
Lozano, Rafael ;
Fullman, Nancy ;
Mumford, John Everett ;
Knight, Megan ;
Barthelemy, Celine M. ;
Abbafati, Cristiana ;
Abbastabar, Hedayat ;
Abd-Allah, Foad ;
Abdollahi, Mohammad ;
Abedi, Aidin ;
Abolhassani, Hassan ;
Abosetugn, Akine Eshete ;
Abreu, Lucas Guimaraes ;
Abrigo, Michael R. M. ;
Abu Haimed, Abdulaziz Khalid ;
Abushouk, Abdelrahman I. ;
Adabi, Maryam ;
Adebayo, Oladimeji M. ;
Adekanmbi, Victor ;
Adelson, Jaimie D. ;
Adetokunboh, Olatunji O. ;
Adham, Davoud ;
Advani, Shailesh M. ;
Afshin, Ashkan ;
Agarwal, Gina ;
Agasthi, Pradyumna ;
Aghamir, Seyed Mohammad Kazem ;
Agrawal, Anurag ;
Ahmad, Tauseef ;
Akinyemi, Rufus Olusola ;
Alahdab, Fares ;
Al-Aly, Ziyad ;
Alam, Khurshid ;
Albertson, Samuel B. ;
Alemu, Yihun Mulugeta ;
Alhassan, Robert Kaba ;
Ali, Muhammad ;
Ali, Saqib ;
Alipour, Vahid ;
Aljunid, Syed Mohamed ;
Alla, Francois ;
Almadi, Majid Abdulrahman Hamad ;
Almasi, Ali ;
Almasi-Hashiani, Amir ;
Almasri, Nihad A. ;
Al-Mekhlafi, Hesham M. ;
Almulhim, Abdulaziz M. ;
Alonso, Jordi ;
Al-Raddadi, Rajaa M. ;
Altirkawi, Khalid A. .
LANCET, 2020, 396 (10258) :1250-1284
[8]  
Mactaggart I, 2018, B WORLD HEALTH ORGAN, V96, P726, DOI [10.2471/blt.18.217794, 10.2471/BLT.18.217794]
[9]   Generating statistics from health facility data: the state of routine health information systems in Eastern and Southern Africa [J].
Maiga, Abdoulaye ;
Jiwani, Safia S. ;
Mutua, Martin Kavao ;
Porth, Tyler Andrew ;
Taylor, Chelsea Maria ;
Asiki, Gershim ;
Melesse, Dessalegn Y. ;
Day, Candy ;
Strong, Kathleen L. ;
Faye, Cheikh Mbacke ;
Viswanathan, Kavitha ;
O'Neill, Kathryn Patricia ;
Amouzou, Agbessi ;
Pond, Bob S. ;
Boerma, Ties ;
Molefi, Mooketsi M. ;
Letebele, Judith ;
Sitibi, Balekane ;
Ntibazomumpa, Jean Marie ;
Nibogora, Joel ;
Niyongabo, Prosper ;
Kifle, Amanuel ;
Mamba, Sibusiso Charles ;
Ayele, Wubegzier Mekonnen ;
Malembaka, Espoir Bwenge ;
Banywesize, Robert ;
Khasakhala, Anne ;
Ngugi, Anthony ;
Kiarie, Helen ;
Makory, Valeria ;
Cosmas, Leonard ;
Rantsatsi, Lebohang ;
Yosefe, Simeon ;
Chanansi, Golden ;
Chavula, Kondwani ;
Malata, Monica Patricia ;
Augusto, Gerito ;
Tivane, Cesarino ;
Barrula, Catarina ;
Muianga, Claudio ;
Kambongi, Ezekiel Muyenga ;
Mukashema, Pacifique ;
Emmanuel, Ntawuyirusha ;
Maposa, Innocent ;
Carol, Mamothena ;
Mayai, Augustino Ting ;
Misaka, Victor ;
Ladu, Edward ;
Shabani, Josephine ;
Mongi, Dhamira .
BMJ GLOBAL HEALTH, 2019, 4 (05)
[10]   Effective refractive error coverage: an eye health indicator to measure progress towards universal health coverage [J].
McCormick, Ian ;
Mactaggart, Islay ;
Bastawrous, Andrew ;
Burton, Matthew J. ;
Ramke, Jacqueline .
OPHTHALMIC AND PHYSIOLOGICAL OPTICS, 2020, 40 (01) :1-5