Effects of animal versus vegetal rennet on milk coagulation traits in Mediterranean buffalo bulk milk

Given consumer interest in Mozzarella di latte di Bufala and other cheeses, and the growing interest of the cheese industry in offering products adequate for lactovegetarian consumers, this study aimed to compare clotting capacity of vegetal and animal rennet in buffalo milk. Milk coagulation properties of 1,261 buffalo bulk milk samples collected during milk quality testing were assessed by lactodynamography using commercial animal (75% chymosin and 25% bovine pepsin) and vegetal (Cynara cardunculus) rennets. Chemical composition of milk samples was predicted by MilkoScan (Foss Analytics, Hillerod, Denmark) calibrated with specific buffalo standards. Rennet effect (animal versus vegetal) was statistically analyzed with a paired t-test. Fat, protein, and lactose contents of milk samples were 7.94%, 4.52%, and 4.80%, respectively. A similar variability of milk coagulation properties was observed with both rennets, with the exception of greater variability of curd firmness at 30 min after the addition of vegetal rennet compared with animal rennet (73 and 26%, respectively). On average, when using plant rennet, milk started to coagulate and reached the 20-mm coagulum 12 +/- 0.22 min and 1.9 +/- 0.20 min, respectively, later than with animal rennet. Thirty minutes after rennet addition, curds were almost twice as firm in animal as in vegetal rennet (difference of 23.92 +/- 0.66 mm). However, curd firmness at 60 min was only 1.21 +/- 0.39 mm thicker with vegetal than with animal rennet. Moreover, when using animal rennet, 99.52% of samples started coagulating within the first 30 min of analysis, whereas only 70.42% did so when using vegetal rennet. We conclude that vegetal rennet has the capacity to coagulate buffalo milk, achieving a similar curd firmness to that of animal rennet at 60 min. Further studies are needed to evaluate the sensory characteristics and consumer acceptability of Mozzarella di latte di Bufala processed with vegetal rennet.