Assessing future sustainability and resilience of farming systems with a participatory method: A case study on extensive sheep farming in Huesca, Spain

被引:22
作者
Paas, Wim [1 ,2 ]
San Martin, Carolina [3 ]
Soriano, Barbara [3 ]
van Ittersum, Martin K. [1 ]
Meuwissen, Miranda P. M. [2 ]
Reidsma, Pytrik [1 ]
机构
[1] Wageningen Univ & Res, Plant Prod Syst, POB 430, NL-6700 AK Wageningen, Netherlands
[2] Wageningen Univ & Res, Business Econ, Wageningen, Netherlands
[3] Univ Politecn Madrid, Res Ctr Management Agr & Environm Risks CEIGRAM, Madrid, Spain
基金
欧盟地平线“2020”;
关键词
Critical thresholds; Robustness; Adaptability; Resilience attributes; LAND-USE; ECOSYSTEM SERVICES; IMPACT ASSESSMENT; CONSERVATION; ABANDONMENT; EVOLUTION; FRAMEWORK; DYNAMICS; METAPHOR; PASTURES;
D O I
10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.108236
中图分类号
X176 [生物多样性保护];
学科分类号
090705 ;
摘要
Finding pathways to more sustainability and resilience of farming systems requires the avoidance of exceeding critical thresholds and the timely identification of viable alternative system configurations. To serve this purpose, the objective of this paper is to present a participatory, integrated and indicator-based methodology that leads researchers and farming system actors in six steps to a multi-dimensional understanding of sustainability and resilience of farming systems in the future. The methodology includes an assessment of current performance (Step 1), identification of critical thresholds whose exceedance can lead to large and permanent system change (Step 2), impact assessment when critical thresholds are exceeded (Step 3), identification of desired alternative systems and their expected improved performance of sustainability and resilience (Step 4), identification of strategies to realize those alternative systems (Step 5), and an assessment on the compatibility of alternative systems with the developments of exogenous factors as projected in different future scenarios (Step 6). The method is applied in 11 EU farming systems, and the application to extensive sheep production in Huesca, Spain, is presented here, as its problematic situation provides insights for other farming systems. Participants in the participatory workshop indicated that their farming system is very close to a decline or even a collapse. Approaching and exceeding critical thresholds in the social, economic and environmental domain are currently causing a vicious circle that includes low economic returns, low attractiveness of the farming system and abandonment of pasture lands. More sustainable and resilient alternative systems to counteract the current negative system dynamics were proposed by participants: a semi-intensive system primarily aimed at improving production and a high-tech extensive system primarily aimed at providing public goods. Both alternatives place a strong emphasis on the role of technology, but differ in their approach towards grazing, which is reflected in the different strategies that are foreseen to realize those alternatives. Although the high-tech extensive system seems most compatible with a future in which sustainable food production is very important, the semi-intensive system seems a less risky bet as it has on average the best compatibility with multiple future scenarios. Overall, the methodology can be regarded as relatively quick, interactive and interdisciplinary, providing ample information on critical thresholds, current system dynamics and future possibilities. As such, the method enables stakeholders to think and talk about the future of their system, paving the way for improved sustainability and resilience.
引用
收藏
页数:18
相关论文
共 91 条
[1]  
Allison HE, 2004, ECOL SOC, V9
[2]   Aligning Key Concepts for Global Change Policy: Robustness, Resilience, and Sustainability [J].
Anderies, John M. ;
Folke, Carl ;
Walker, Brian ;
Ostrom, Elinor .
ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY, 2013, 18 (02)
[3]   Farm management indicators and farm typologies as a basis for assessments in a changing policy environment [J].
Andersen, Erling ;
Elbersen, Berien ;
Godeschalk, Frans ;
Verhoog, David .
JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2007, 82 (03) :353-362
[4]  
[Anonymous], 2010, ASSESSING RESILIENCE
[5]  
Ayuda MI, 2002, ARAGON AGER, V2, P101
[6]  
Becking J., 2019, D52 PARTICIPATORY IM
[7]   An integrated approach to studying the role of grazing livestock systems in the conservation of rangelands in a protected natural park (Sierra de Guara, Spain) [J].
Bernués, A ;
Riedel, JL ;
Asensio, MA ;
Blanco, M ;
Sanz, A ;
Revilla, R ;
Casasús, I .
LIVESTOCK PRODUCTION SCIENCE, 2005, 96 (01) :75-85
[8]   Sustainability of pasture-based livestock farming systems in the European Mediterranean context: Synergies and trade-offs [J].
Bernues, A. ;
Ruiz, R. ;
Olaizola, A. ;
Villalba, D. ;
Casasus, I. .
LIVESTOCK SCIENCE, 2011, 139 (1-2) :44-57
[9]  
Bernues A., 2006, V119, P73
[10]  
Bernues A., 2012, Los Pirineos: Geografia, Turismo, Agricultura, Cooperacion Transfronteriza y Derecho, P29