T1ρ and T2 Mapping of the Intervertebral Disk: Comparison of Different Methods of Segmentation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Intervertebral disk biochemical composition could be accessed in vivo by T1 rho and T2 relaxometry. We found no studies in the literature comparing different segmentation methods for data extraction using these techniques. Our aim was to compare different manual segmentation methods used to extract T1 rho and T2 relaxation times of intervertebral disks from MR imaging. Seven different methods of partial-disk segmentation techniques were compared with whole-disk segmentation as the reference standard. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sagittal T1 rho and T2 maps were generated by using a 1.5T MR imaging scanner in 57 asymptomatic volunteers 20-40 years of age. Two hundred eighty-five lumbar disks were separated into 2 groups: nondegenerated disk (Pfirrmann I and II) and degenerated disk (Pfirrmann III and IV). In whole-disk segmentation, the disk was segmented in its entirety on all sections. Partial-disk segmentation methods included segmentation of the disk into 6, 5, 4, 3, and 1 sagittal sections. Circular ROIs positioned in the nucleus pulposus and annulus fibrosus were also used to extract T1 rho and T2, and data were compared with whole-disk segmentation RESULTS: In the nondegenerated group, segmentation of >= 5 sagittal sections showed no statistical difference with whole-disk segmentation. All the remaining partial-disk segmentation methods and circular ROIs showed different results from whole-disk segmentation (P < .001). In the degenerated disk group, all methods were statistically similar to whole-disk segmentation. All partial-segmentation methods, including circular ROIs, showed strong linear correlation with whole-disk segmentation in both the degenerated and nondegenerated disk groups. CONCLUSIONS: Manual segmentation showed strong reproducibility for T1 rho and T2 and strong linear correlation between partial- and whole-disk segmentation. Absolute T1 rho and T2 values extracted from different segmentation techniques were statistically different in disks with Pfirrmann grades I and II.