Assessing the implementation of machine learning models for thermal treatments design

被引:4
作者
Eres-Castellanos, Adriana [1 ]
De-Castro, David [1 ]
Capdevila, Carlos [1 ]
Garcia-Mateo, Carlos [1 ]
Caballero, Francisca G. [1 ]
机构
[1] Natl Ctr Met Res CENIM CSIC, Dept Phys Met, Gregorio del Amo 8, Madrid 28040, Spain
关键词
Machine learning; martensite start temperature; predictions; MARTENSITE START TEMPERATURE; EMPIRICAL FORMULAS; ALLOYING ELEMENTS; STEEL; PREDICTION; REPRESENTATIONS; NUCLEATION; KINETICS;
D O I
10.1080/02670836.2021.2001731
中图分类号
T [工业技术];
学科分类号
08 ;
摘要
The latest progress in machine learning (ML) algorithms enabled to predict some steel physical properties previously modelled by linear regression (LR), such as the Ms temperature. Authors claimed that the performance given by ML models could improve the one of previous LR models, although they did not include fair comparisons. In this work, a large database was used to train different ML algorithms, whose Ms temperature predictions were compared to the ones of previous literature empirical models. ML methods were proved to require longer computational times and wider knowledge, while leading to similar results. Therefore, we recommend that ML methods are not always considered as the first option when trying to solve easy problems that can be modelled by LR techniques.
引用
收藏
页码:1302 / 1310
页数:9
相关论文
共 51 条
  • [11] Analysis of effect of alloying elements on martensite start temperature of steels
    Capdevila, C
    Caballero, FG
    de Andrés, CG
    [J]. MATERIALS SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, 2003, 19 (05) : 581 - 586
  • [12] Determination of Ms temperature in steels:: A Bayesian neural network model
    Capdevila, C
    Caballero, FG
    De Andrés, CG
    [J]. ISIJ INTERNATIONAL, 2002, 42 (08) : 894 - 902
  • [13] Carapella, 1944, MET PROG, V46
  • [14] Exploring the microstructure manifold: Image texture representations applied to ultrahigh carbon steel microstructures
    DeCost, Brian L.
    Francis, Toby
    Holm, Elizabeth A.
    [J]. ACTA MATERIALIA, 2017, 133 : 30 - 40
  • [15] Drucker H, 1997, 14 INT C MACH LEARN, V1997, P107
  • [16] Eldis G. T., 1977, HARDENABILITY CONCEP, P397
  • [17] A decision-theoretic generalization of on-line learning and an application to boosting
    Freund, Y
    Schapire, RE
    [J]. JOURNAL OF COMPUTER AND SYSTEM SCIENCES, 1997, 55 (01) : 119 - 139
  • [18] Artificial neural network modeling for the prediction of critical transformation temperatures in steels
    Garcia-Mateo, Carlos
    Capdevila, Carlos
    Garcia Caballero, Francisca
    Garcia de Andres, Carlos
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MATERIALS SCIENCE, 2007, 42 (14) : 5391 - 5397
  • [19] KINETICS OF FCC-]BCC HETEROGENEOUS MARTENSITIC NUCLEATION .1. THE CRITICAL DRIVING-FORCE FOR ATHERMAL NUCLEATION
    GHOSH, G
    OLSON, GB
    [J]. ACTA METALLURGICA ET MATERIALIA, 1994, 42 (10): : 3361 - 3370
  • [20] KINETICS OF FCC-]BCC HETEROGENEOUS MARTENSITIC NUCLEATION .2. THERMAL-ACTIVATION
    GHOSH, G
    OLSON, GB
    [J]. ACTA METALLURGICA ET MATERIALIA, 1994, 42 (10): : 3371 - 3379