Atmospheric deposition is a primary pathway by which mercury (Hg) enters terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems; however, the chemical and meteorological processes that Hg undergoes from emission to deposition are not well understood. Hg stable isotope geochemistry is a growing field used to better understand Hg biogeochemical cycling. To examine the atmospheric Hg isotopic composition in the Great Lakes, precipitation and ambient vapor-phase Hg samples were collected in Chicago, IL, Holland, MI, and Dexter, MI, between April 2007 and September 2009. Precipitation samples were characterized by negative mass-dependent fractionation (MDF) (delta(202)Hg = -0.79 parts per thousand to 0.18 parts per thousand), while most vapor-phase samples displayed positive MDF (delta(202)Hg = -0.59 parts per thousand to 0.43 parts per thousand). Positive mass-independent fractionation (MIF) (Delta(199)Hg = 0.04 parts per thousand to 0.52 parts per thousand) was observed in precipitation, whereas MIF was slightly negative in vapor-phase samples (Delta(199)Hg = -0.21 parts per thousand to 0.06 parts per thousand). Significant positive MIF of (200)Hg up to 0.25 parts per thousand was also measured in precipitation. Such MIF of an even-mass Hg isotope has not been previously reported in natural samples. These results contrast with recent predictions of the isotopic composition of atmospheric Hg and suggest that, in addition to aqueous photoreduction, other atmospheric redox reactions and source-related processes may contribute to isotopic fractionation of atmospheric Hg.