Neurodevelopment in Normocephalic Children Exposed to Zika Virus in Utero with No Observable Defects at Birth: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

被引:22
作者
Marban-Castro, Elena [1 ]
Vazquez Guillamet, Laia J. [1 ]
Pantoja, Percy Efrain [2 ]
Casellas, Aina [1 ]
Maxwell, Lauren [3 ]
Mulkey, Sarah B. [4 ,5 ,6 ]
Menendez, Clara [1 ,7 ,8 ]
Bardaji, Azucena [1 ,7 ,8 ]
机构
[1] Univ Barcelona, Hosp Clin, ISGlobal, 132 Rossello St, Barcelona 08036, Spain
[2] Vall dHebron Hosp Univ, Vall dHebron Barcelona Hosp Campus, Vall dHebron Inst Recerca VHIR, Hlth Serv Res Grp, Passeig Vall dHebron 119-129, Barcelona 08035, Spain
[3] Heidelberg Univ, Heidelberg Inst Global Hlth, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany
[4] Childrens Natl Hosp, Washington, DC 20010 USA
[5] George Washington Univ, Sch Med & Hlth Sci, Dept Neurol, Washington, DC 20037 USA
[6] George Washington Univ, Sch Med & Hlth Sci, Dept Pediat, Washington, DC 20037 USA
[7] Consorcio Invest Biomed Red Epidemiol & Salud Pub, Madrid 28029, Spain
[8] Ctr Invest Saude Manhica CISM, Rua 12,Cambeve CP 1929, Maputo 1929, Mozambique
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
Zika; neurodevelopment; language; cognitive; motor; delay; normocephalic; INFECTION; TOOLS;
D O I
10.3390/ijerph19127319
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Zika virus (ZIKV) infection during pregnancy is a cause of pregnancy loss and multiple clinical and neurological anomalies in children. This systematic review aimed to assess the effect of ZIKV exposure in utero on the long-term neurodevelopment of normocephalic children born to women with ZIKV infection in pregnancy. This review was conducted according to the PRISMA guidelines for systematic reviews and meta-analyses. We performed a random effects meta-analysis to estimate the cross-study prevalence of neurodevelopmental delays in children using the Bayley Scales for Infant and Toddler Development (BSID-III). The risk of bias was assessed using Cochrane's Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach. Full-text reviews were performed for 566 articles, and data were extracted from 22 articles corresponding to 20 studies. Nine articles including data from 476 children found 6.5% (95% CI: 4.1-9.3) of infants and children to have any type of non-language cognitive delay; 29.7% (95% CI: 21.7-38.2) to have language delay; and 11.5% (95% CI: 4.8-20.1) to have any type of motor delay. The pooled estimates had a high level of heterogeneity; thus, results should be interpreted with caution. Larger prospective studies that include a non-exposed control group are needed to confirm whether ZIKV exposure in utero is associated with adverse child neurodevelopmental outcomes.
引用
收藏
页数:24
相关论文
共 44 条
[1]   Neurological Findings in Children without Congenital Microcephaly Exposed to Zika Virus in Utero: A Case Series Study [J].
Abtibol-Bernardino, Marilia Rosa ;
Albuquerque de Almeida Peixoto, Luciola de Fatima ;
de Oliveira, Geruza Alfaia ;
de Almeida, Tatiane Freitas ;
Rodrigues, Gabriela Ribeiro Ivo ;
Otani, Rodrigo Haruo ;
Soares Chaves, Beatriz Caroline ;
de Souza Rodrigues, Cristina ;
de Andrade, Anny Beatriz Costa Antony ;
de Fatima Redivo, Elijane ;
Fernandes, Salete Sara ;
da Costa Castilho, Marcia ;
Gomes Benzecry, Silvana ;
Botto-Menezes, Camila ;
Martinez-Espinosa, Flor Ernestina ;
Costa Alecrim, Maria das Gracas .
VIRUSES-BASEL, 2020, 12 (11)
[2]   Congenital microcephaly: A diagnostic challenge during Zika epidemics [J].
Alvarado-Socarras, Jorge L. ;
Idrovo, Alvaro J. ;
Contreras-Garcia, Gustavo A. ;
Rodriguez-Morales, Alfonso J. ;
Audcent, Tobey A. ;
Mogollon-Mendoza, Adriana C. ;
Paniz-Mondolfi, Alberto .
TRAVEL MEDICINE AND INFECTIOUS DISEASE, 2018, 23 :14-20
[3]  
[Anonymous], GRADEpro GDT Computer program
[4]   Nonmicrocephalic Infants with Congenital Zika Syndrome Suspected Only after Neuroimaging Evaluation Compared with Those with Microcephaly at Birth and Postnatally: How Large Is the Zika Virus "Iceberg"? [J].
Aragao, M. F. V. V. ;
Holanda, A. C. ;
Brainer-Lima, A. M. ;
Petribu, N. C. L. ;
Castillo, M. ;
van der Linden, V. ;
Serpa, S. C. ;
Tenorio, A. G. ;
Travassos, P. T. C. ;
Cordeiro, M. T. ;
Sarteschi, C. ;
Valenca, M. M. ;
Costello, A. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF NEURORADIOLOGY, 2017, 38 (07) :1427-1434
[5]   Rating early child development outcome measurement tools for routine health programme use [J].
Boggs, Dorothy ;
Milner, Kate M. ;
Chandna, Jaya ;
Black, Maureen ;
Cavallera, Vanessa ;
Dua, Tarun ;
Fink, Guenther ;
Ashish, K. C. ;
Grantham-McGregor, Sally ;
Hamadani, Jena ;
Hughes, Rob ;
Manji, Karim ;
Mccoy, Dana Charles ;
Tann, Cally ;
Lawn, Joy E. .
ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD, 2019, 104 :S22-S33
[6]   Receptive language skills among young children in rural Guatemala: The relationship between the Test de Vocabulario en Imagenes Peabody and a translated and adapted version of the Mullen Scales of Early Learning [J].
Connery, Amy K. ;
Colbert, Alison M. ;
Lamb, Molly M. ;
Hernandez, Sara ;
Martinez, Maria Alejandra ;
Bauer, Desiree ;
Arroyave, Paola ;
El Sahly, Hana M. ;
Paniagua-Avila, Alejandra ;
Calvimontes, Mirella ;
Bolanos, Guillermo Antonio ;
Olson, Daniel ;
Asturias, Edwin J. ;
Munoz, Flor M. .
CHILD CARE HEALTH AND DEVELOPMENT, 2019, 45 (05) :702-708
[7]   Early maternal Zika infection predicts severe neonatal neurological damage: results from the prospective Natural History of Zika Virus Infection in Gestation cohort study [J].
Coutinho, C. M. ;
Negrini, S. F. B. M. ;
Araujo, D. C. A. ;
Teixeira, S. R. ;
Amaral, F. R. ;
Moro, M. C. R. ;
Fernandes, J. D. C. P. ;
da Motta, M. S. F. ;
Negrini, B. V. M. ;
Caldas, C. A. C. T. ;
Anastasio, A. R. T. ;
Furtado, J. M. ;
Barbaro, A. A. T. ;
Yamamoto, A. Y. ;
Duarte, G. ;
Mussi-Pinhata, M. M. .
BJOG-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNAECOLOGY, 2021, 128 (02) :317-326
[8]   Association Between Antenatal Exposure to Zika Virus and Anatomical and Neurodevelopmental Abnormalities in Children [J].
Cranston, Jessica S. ;
Tiene, Sophia Finn ;
Nielsen-Saines, Karin ;
Vasconcelos, Zilton ;
Pone, Marcos V. ;
Pone, Sheila ;
Zin, Andrea ;
Salles, Tania Saad ;
Pereira, Jose Paulo, Jr. ;
Orofino, Dulce ;
Brasil, Patricia ;
Kerin, Tara ;
Adachi, Kristina ;
Soares, Fernanda Mendes ;
Dunshee de Abranches, Andrea ;
da Costa, Ana Carolina C. ;
Lopes Moreira, Maria Elisabeth .
JAMA NETWORK OPEN, 2020, 3 (07)
[9]   Speech-language disorders in children with congenital Zika virus syndrome: A systematic review [J].
da Silva Rosa, Barbara Cristina ;
Hernandez Alves Ribeiro Cesar, Carla Patricia ;
Paranhos, Luiz Renato ;
Guedes-Granzotti, Raphaela Barroso ;
Lewis, Doris Ruthy .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PEDIATRIC OTORHINOLARYNGOLOGY, 2020, 138
[10]   Children Born to Mothers with Rash During Zika Virus Epidemic in Brazil: First 18 Months of Life [J].
de Oliveira Vianna, Renata Artimos ;
Lovero, Kathryn Lynn ;
de Oliveira, Solange Artimos ;
Fernandes, Alexandre Ribeiro ;
Sarmet dos Santos, Teresa Cristina ;
Santos de Souza Lima, Luiz Claudio ;
Carvalho, Fabiana Rabe ;
Salgado Quintans, Maria Dolores ;
Bueno, Arnaldo Costa ;
Malheiros Torbey, Ana Flavia ;
Azevedo Grippa de Souza, Aurea Lucia Alves ;
Pache de Farias, Armanda de Oliveira ;
Bastos Camacho, Luiz Antonio ;
Riley, Lee Woodland ;
Araujo Cardoso, Claudete Aparecida .
JOURNAL OF TROPICAL PEDIATRICS, 2019, 65 (06) :592-602