Accuracy of Visual Estimation of LASIK Flap Thickness

PURPOSE: To assess the accuracy of surgeons' visual estimation of LASIK flap thickness when created by a femtosecond laser by comparing it to ultrasound measurements. METHODS: Surgeons were asked to visually estimate the thickness of a femtosecond flap during the procedure. Total corneal thickness was measured by ultrasound pachymetry prior to the procedure and the stromal bed was similarly measured after flap lifting. The estimates from three experienced surgeons (cornea fellowship trained and more than 5 years in practice) were compared to those of three cornea fellows, with each surgeon evaluating 20 eyes (120 total). Surgeons were not told the thickness of the flaps unless required for safety reasons. RESULTS: The average difference between visual and ultrasonic estimation of LASIK flap thickness was 15.20 mu m. The flap was 10 mu m thicker than estimated in 37% of eyes, 20 mu m thicker in 17% of eyes, and 30 mu m thicker in 10% of eyes. The largest deviation was 53 mu m. There was no statistically significant difference between the accuracy of experienced surgeons and fellows (P = .51). CONCLUSIONS: There are significant differences between surgeons' visual estimates and ultrasonic measurements of LASIK flap thickness. Relying on these visual estimates may lead to deeper excimer laser ablation than intended. This could lead to thinner residual stromal beds and higher percent tissue altered than planned. The authors recommend that surgeons measure flaps intraoperatively to maximize accuracy and safety.