Adjustment for energy intake in nutritional research: a causal inference perspective

被引:90
作者
Tomova, Georgia D. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Arnold, Kellyn F. [1 ,4 ]
Gilthorpe, Mark S. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Tennant, Peter W. G. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Leeds, Leeds Inst Data Analyt, Leeds, W Yorkshire, England
[2] Univ Leeds, Fac Med & Hlth, Leeds, W Yorkshire, England
[3] Alan Turing Inst, London, England
[4] Univ Leeds, Fac Environm, Leeds, W Yorkshire, England
关键词
nutritional epidemiology; estimand; causal inference; compositional data; directed acyclic graphs; MODELS; ADULTS;
D O I
10.1093/ajcn/nqab266
中图分类号
R15 [营养卫生、食品卫生]; TS201 [基础科学];
学科分类号
100403 ;
摘要
Background: Four models are commonly used to adjust for energy intake when estimating the causal effect of a dietary component on an outcome: 1) the "standard model" adjusts for total energy intake, 2) the "energy partition model" adjusts for remaining energy intake, 3) the "nutrient density model" rescales the exposure as a proportion of total energy, and 4) the "residual model" indirectly adjusts for total energy by using a residual. It remains underappreciated that each approach evaluates a different estimand and only partially accounts for confounding by common dietary causes. Objectives: We aimed to clarify the implied causal estimand and interpretation of each model and evaluate their performance in reducing dietary confounding. Methods: Semiparametric directed acyclic graphs and Monte Carlo simulations were used to identify the estimands and interpretations implied by each model and explore their performance in the absence or presence of dietary confounding. Results: The "standard model" and the mathematically identical "residual model" estimate the average relative causal effect (i.e., a "substitution" effect) but provide biased estimates even in the absence of confounding. The "energy partition model" estimates the total causal effect but only provides unbiased estimates in the absence of confounding or when all other nutrients have equal effects on the outcome. The "nutrient density model" has an obscure interpretation but attempts to estimate the average relative causal effect rescaled as a proportion of total energy. Accurate estimates of both the total and average relative causal effects may instead be derived by simultaneously adjusting for all dietary components, an approach we term the "all-components model." Conclusions: Lack of awareness of the estimand differences and accuracy of the 4 modeling approaches may explain some of the apparent heterogeneity among existing nutritional studies. This raises serious questions regarding the validity of meta-analyses where different estimands have been inappropriately pooled.
引用
收藏
页码:189 / 198
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Research, application, and challenges of causal inference in industrial fault diagnosis: A survey [J].
Li, Bo ;
Li, Qiang ;
Du, Tingfeng ;
Liu, Dong ;
Yang, Qiang ;
Chen, Tianxiang ;
Xiong, Jing ;
Peng, Bo ;
Ren, Junxiao ;
Zhao, Ji .
ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2025, 158
[42]   A research note on Mendelian randomization and causal inference in criminology: promises and considerations [J].
Brian B. Boutwell ;
Charleen D. Adams .
Journal of Experimental Criminology, 2022, 18 :171-182
[43]   Application of Causal Inference to the Analysis of Occupant Thermal State and Energy Behavioral Intentions in Immersive Virtual Environments [J].
Rentala, Girish ;
Zhu, Yimin ;
Mukhopadhyay, Supratik .
FRONTIERS IN SUSTAINABLE CITIES, 2021, 3
[44]   The effects of international research collaboration on the policy impact of research: A causal inference drawing on the journal Lancet [J].
Xu, Chuer ;
Zong, Qianjin .
JOURNAL OF INFORMATION SCIENCE, 2023,
[45]   A Causal Inference Perspective for Estimating the Influence of the Romanian Competitiveness Operational Programme on Researchers' Performance [J].
Matei, Monica Mihaela Maer ;
Zamfir, Ana-Maria .
ECONOMIC COMPUTATION AND ECONOMIC CYBERNETICS STUDIES AND RESEARCH, 2025, 59 (02) :159-169
[46]   Effect of measurement error on energy-adjustment models in nutritional epidemiology [J].
Kipnis, V ;
Freedman, LS ;
Brown, CC ;
Hartman, AM ;
Schatzkin, A ;
Wacholder, S .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1997, 146 (10) :842-855
[47]   Energy adjustment does not control for differential recall bias in nutritional epidemiology [J].
Bellach, B ;
Kohlmeier, L .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1998, 51 (05) :393-398
[48]   Causal inference in perioperative medicine observational research: part 1, a graphical introduction [J].
Krishnamoorthy, Vijay ;
Wong, Danny J. N. ;
Wilson, Matt ;
Raghunathan, Karthik ;
Ohnuma, Tetsu ;
McLean, Duncan ;
Moonesinghe, S. Ramani ;
Harris, Steve K. .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 2020, 125 (03) :393-397
[49]   Causal inference in perioperative medicine observational research: part 2, advanced methods [J].
Krishnamoorthy, Vijay ;
McLean, Duncan ;
Ohnuma, Tetsu ;
Harris, Steve K. ;
Wong, Danny J. N. ;
Wilson, Matt ;
Moonesinghe, Ramani ;
Raghunathan, Karthik .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 2020, 125 (03) :398-405
[50]   Research Advance of Causal Inference in Clinical Medicine: A Bibliometrics Analysis via Citespace [J].
Qin, Guoqiang ;
Wei, Jianxiang ;
Sun, Yuehong ;
Du, Wenwen .
JOURNAL OF MULTIDISCIPLINARY HEALTHCARE, 2025, 18 :2603-2627