Conventional IVF revisited: Is ICSI better for non-male factor infertility? Randomized controlled double blind study

被引:27
作者
Isikoglu, M. [1 ]
Avci, A. [1 ]
Ceviren, A. Kendirci [1 ]
Aydinuraz, B. [1 ]
Ata, B. [2 ]
机构
[1] GELECEK IVF Ctr, Antalya, Turkey
[2] Koc Univ, Dept Obstet & Gynecol, Sch Med, Istanbul, Turkey
关键词
IVF; ICSI; Implantation rate; Clinical pregnancy rate; INTRACYTOPLASMIC SPERM INJECTION; ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNIQUES; IN-VITRO FERTILIZATION; REINSEMINATION; OUTCOMES; AUTISM; WOMEN;
D O I
10.1016/j.jogoh.2020.101990
中图分类号
R71 [妇产科学];
学科分类号
100211 ;
摘要
Study question: Is ICSI better than conventional IVF for non-male factor infertility? Summary answer: IVF should be the choice of assisted reproductive technique in non-male factor infertility cases. What is already known: Although total fertilization failure is a major concern for patients and professionals, the overall risk/benefit analysis favors conventional IVF in non-male factor infertility cases. However, according to the ESHRE EIM database pertaining to 1997-2012, the use of IVF has been continuously decreasing in favor of ICSI. Study design, size, duration: Randomized controlled double-blind study involving 138 women undergoing ART in a private Center. Participants/materials, setting, methods: All couples with a female partner <= 42 years of age and without severe male factor (total progressive motile sperm with normal morphology >10.000) were included in the study. Exclusion criteria were: history of total fertilization failure, less than 6 cumulus oocyte complexes (COC) available for fertilization, prenatal genetic testing (PGT) cycles, unwillingness to participate and couples undergoing total cryopreservation for any indication. On the day of oocyte pick up, sibling COCs were randomly allocated to fertilization with IVF or denudation followed by ICSI to MII oocytes. The decision to transfer IVF or ICSI embryo(s) depended on embryo quality. Women receiving two embryos were given only IVF or ICSI embryos. Neither the clinician performing the transfer nor the patients were aware of the fertilization method used to generate the embryos transferred. Main outcome parameters were fertilization, clinical pregnancy, implantation and miscarriage rates. Main results and the role of chance: Demographic variables, ovarian reserve and infertility etiology, duration of stimulation, total gonadotropin consumption, peak estradiol levels were similar for IVF-ET and ICSI-ET groups. Mean number of COCs (18.95 vs 19.24), number of embryos transferred (1,81 vs 1,81), the ratio of good quality embryos/total embryos (56.89 % and 55.97 %), clinical pregnancy rates (63 % vs 49 %), implantation rates (31 % vs 28 %), and abortion rates (12,5 % vs 8,1 %) were also similar. A total of 1306 COCs were allocated for IVF while 1331 COCs were denuded for ICSI. Fertilization rate per inseminated oocyte was significantly higher in ICSI group (56,20 % vs 63,78 %). There were ten cases of total fertilization failure, all in the IVF group. Although overall fertilization rate was higher for ICSI, it was similar in both groups when cases with total fertilization failure were excluded. Limitations, reasons for caution: The non-availability of live birth rates is a limitation. Randomization of sibling oocytes, not patients requires careful interpretation of pregnancy and implantation rates. Wider implications of the findings: Lower cost, ease of application and similar clinical outcome makes IVF the choice of fertilization method in non-male factor infertility cases. (C) 2020 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   A RANDOMIZED STUDY OF INTRACYTOPLASMIC SPERM INJECTION (ICSI) VERSUS SUBZONAL INSEMINATION (SUZI) FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF SEVERE MALE-FACTOR INFERTILITY [J].
LEVRAN, D ;
BIDER, D ;
YONESH, M ;
YEMINI, Z ;
SEIDMAN, DS ;
MASHIACH, S ;
DOR, J .
JOURNAL OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTION AND GENETICS, 1995, 12 (05) :319-321
[42]   Intracytoplasmic sperm injection versus conventional in-vitro fertilisation for couples with infertility with non-severe male factor: a multicentre, open-label, randomised controlled trial [J].
Wang, Yuanyuan ;
Li, Rong ;
Yang, Rui ;
Zheng, Danni ;
Zeng, Lin ;
Lian, Ying ;
Zhu, Yimin ;
Zhao, Junli ;
Liang, Xiaoyan ;
Li, Wen ;
Liu, Jianqiao ;
Tang, Li ;
Cao, Yunxia ;
Hao, Guimin ;
Wang, Huichun ;
Zhang, Hua ;
Wang, Rui ;
Mol, Ben W. ;
Huang, Hefeng ;
Qiao, Jie .
LANCET, 2024, 403 (10430) :924-934
[43]   The impact of intracytoplasmic sperm injection versus conventional in vitro fertilization on the reproductive outcomes of couples with non-male factor infertility and frozen-thawed embryo transfer cycles [J].
Zhang, Yuchao ;
Zhang, Wen ;
Liu, Yanli ;
Ren, Bingnan ;
Guan, Yichun .
SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2024, 14 (01)
[44]   Intracytoplasmic sperm injection increased fertilization and good-quality embryo formation in patients with non-male factor indications for in vitro fertilization: a prospective randomized study [J].
Khamsi, F ;
Yavas, Y ;
Roberge, S ;
Wong, JC ;
Lacanna, IC ;
Endman, M .
FERTILITY AND STERILITY, 2001, 75 (02) :342-347
[45]   GnRH agonist protocol administration in the luteal phase in ICSI-ET cycles stimulated with the long GnRH agonistprotocol: a randomized, controlled double blind study [J].
Ata, B. ;
Yakin, K. ;
Balaban, B. ;
Urman, B. .
HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2008, 23 (03) :668-673
[46]   Effect of advanced paternal age on reproductive outcomes in IVF cycles of non-male-factor infertility: a retrospective cohort study [J].
Lu, Xin-Mei ;
Liu, Yu-Bing ;
Zhang, Dou-Dou ;
Cao, Xiang ;
Zhang, Tian-Cheng ;
Liu, Miao ;
Shi, Hui-Juan ;
Dong, Xi ;
Liu, Su-Ying .
ASIAN JOURNAL OF ANDROLOGY, 2023, 25 (02) :245-+
[47]   In-vitro maturation of oocytes versus conventional IVF in women with infertility and a high antral follicle count: a randomized non-inferiority controlled trial [J].
Vuong, Lan N. ;
Ho, Vu N. A. ;
Ho, Tuong M. ;
Dang, Vinh Q. ;
Phung, Tuan H. ;
Giang, Nhu H. ;
Le, Anh H. ;
Pham, Toan D. ;
Wang, Rui ;
Smitz, Johan ;
Gilchrist, Robert B. ;
Norman, Robert J. ;
Mol, Ben W. .
HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2020, 35 (11) :2537-2547
[48]   Personalizing the first dose of FSH for IVF/ICSI patients through machine learning: a non-inferiority study protocol for a multi-center randomized controlled trial [J].
Correa, Nuria ;
Cerquides, Jesus ;
Arcos, Josep Lluis ;
Vassena, Rita ;
Popovic, Mina .
TRIALS, 2024, 25 (01)
[49]   Low-dose aspirin in non-tubal IVF patients with previous failed conception: a prospective randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial [J].
Lambers, Marieke J. ;
Hoozemans, Diederik A. ;
Schats, Roel ;
Homburg, Roy ;
Lambalk, Cornelis B. ;
Hompes, Peter G. A. .
FERTILITY AND STERILITY, 2009, 92 (03) :923-929
[50]   The non-ergot derived dopamine agonist quinagolide in prevention of early ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome in IVF patients: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial† [J].
Busso, Cristiano ;
Fernandez-Sanchez, Manuel ;
Antonio Garcia-Velasco, Juan ;
Landeras, Jose ;
Ballesteros, Augustin ;
Munoz, Elkin ;
Gonzalez, Sandra ;
Simon, Carlos ;
Arce, Joan-Carles ;
Pellicer, Antonio .
HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2010, 25 (04) :995-1004