Management of invasive intralabyrinthine cholesteatoma: Can one realistically preserve hearing when disease is medial to the otic capsule?

Purpose: To report our long-term results in surgical management of invasive intralabyrinthine cholesteatoma. Material and methods: The study is a case series in a tertiary referral center. Retrospective chart review of all mastoid operations performed for chronic ear disease between 1994 and 2019 at University Health Network, Toronto. The type of surgery, intraoperative findings, hearing outcome, recurrence of disease and the need for revision surgery were evaluated. Results: 10 cases of extensive petrous bone cholesteatoma medial to the otic capsule were identified in 616 mastoid surgeries. All but one patient with extensive petrous bone cholesteatoma who underwent an exteriorizing procedure to preserve cochlear function failed the first surgery. A second procedure was needed in all cases due to complications which included facial palsy, recurrent cholesteatoma or internal auditory canal (IAC) abscess. Hearing was not preserved in any patient. In contrast, 57 ears with cholesteatomatous labyrinthine fistula lateral to the otic capsule had matrix exteriorized and had very good long-term results. Conclusion: We were rarely able to preserve hearing in massive petrous bone cholesteatoma. There should be no hesitation to remove the otic capsule to exteriorize diseases even under circumstances where residual cochlear and vestibular function is present if required to provide a safe ear.