The Role of Suboptimal Concentrations of Nebulized Tobramycin in Driving Antimicrobial Resistance in Pseudomonas aeruginosa Isolates in Cystic Fibrosis

BACKGROUND: Antimicrobial resistance in Pseudomonas aeruginosa may be driven by exposure to suboptimal concentrations of tobramycin antibiotic delivered by less efficient nebulizers. METHODS: P. aeruginosa isolates (no. 5 114; 32 first + 82 chronic) were challenged in vitro employing extrapolated peak and trough concentrations of tobramycin inhalation solution (TIS), corresponding to 3 nebulizers: Pari LC Plus, Sidestream12NEB400, and MistyNeb2035G. Bacterial persistence and antibiotic susceptibility to tobramycin was determined following 4 TIS cycles: (i) 28 d ON, (ii) 28 d ON + 28 d OFF, (iii) 2 3 28 d ON, and (iv) 28 d ON + 28 d ON + 28 d OFF. RESULTS: All first isolates were eradicated at peak and trough concentrations except for the trough concentration corresponding to Sidestream 12NEB400 (bactericidal activity 87%). For chronic isolates, peak concentrations eradicated 88%, 90%, and 92%, and trough concentrations eradicated 43%, 62%, and 85%, with the Sidestream12NEB400, MistyNeb2035G, and Pari LC Plus nebulizers, respectively. A statistically significant increase in antibiotic resistance with sensitive, intermediate, and resistant P. aeruginosa was noted following cycles (i) through (iv) at trough concentrations with the Sidestream 12NEB400 and MistyNeb2035G nebulizers. There was a significant reduction in tobramycin resistance following a 28-d OFF cycle, and no difference was noted following 1 3 28 d ON versus 2 3 28 d ON cycles. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that suboptimal concentrations of tobramycin drove increased antibiotic resistance, emulating standard cycles of ON/OFF inhaled therapy. This was evident at extrapolated tobramycin concentrations at trough levels corresponding to less efficient nebulizers by initially allowing for the survival of intermediate and resistant organisms, because nebulizer performance did not achieve critical antibiotic concentrations sufficient to eradicate the organism, and by allowing the development of resistance in those cells that were able to survive the initial tobramycin challenge. Transferred to clinical practice, for people with cystic fibrosis on TIS treatment, it is important that clinicians employ an efficient nebulizer that helps mitigate an upward drift in antibiotic resistance, thereby protecting the clinical value of TIS within treatment for cystic fibrosis.