Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for schizophrenia patients treated with clozapine

被引:16
作者
Wagner, Elias [1 ]
Honer, William G. [2 ]
Sommer, Iris E. [3 ]
Koops, Sanne [4 ]
Blumberger, Daniel M. [5 ,6 ,7 ]
Daskalakis, Zafiris J. [5 ,6 ,7 ]
Dlabac-De Lange, Jozarni J. [8 ,9 ]
Bais, Leonie [8 ]
Knegtering, Henderikus [8 ,9 ]
Aleman, Andre [8 ,9 ]
Novak, Tomas [10 ]
Klirova, Monika [10 ]
Slotema, Christina [11 ]
Brunelin, Jerome [12 ]
Poulet, Emmanuel [12 ]
Kujovic, Milenko [13 ]
Cordes, Joachim [13 ]
Wobrock, Thomas [14 ,15 ]
Siskind, Dan [16 ,17 ]
Falkai, Peter [1 ]
Schneider-Axmann, Thomas [1 ]
Hasan, Alkomiet [1 ,18 ]
机构
[1] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Univ Hosp, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Munich, Germany
[2] Univ British Columbia, Dept Psychiat, Vancouver, BC, Canada
[3] Univ Med Ctr Groningen, Sect Cognit Neuropsychol, Dept Biomed Sci Cells & Syst, Groningen, Netherlands
[4] Univ Med Ctr Utrecht, Dept Psychiat, Utrecht, Netherlands
[5] Ctr Addict & Mental Hlth, Temerty Ctr Therapeut Brain Intervent, Toronto, ON, Canada
[6] Ctr Addict & Mental Hlth, Campbell Family Res Inst, Toronto, ON, Canada
[7] Univ Toronto, Dept Psychiat, Toronto, ON, Canada
[8] Lentis Psychiat Inst, Groningen, Netherlands
[9] Univ Groningen, Univ Med Ctr Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands
[10] Charles Univ Prague, Natl Inst Mental Hlth, Klecany & Third Fac Med, Prague, Czech Republic
[11] Parnassia Psychiat Inst, Dept Personal Disorders, The Hague, Netherlands
[12] Ctr Hosp Le Vinatier, CNRS, INSERM U1028, CRNL,UMR 5292, Bron, France
[13] Heinrich Heine Univ Hosp, Med Fac, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Dusseldorf, Germany
[14] Georg August Univ, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Gottingen, Germany
[15] Cty Hosp Darmstadt Dieburg, Ctr Mental Hlth, Gross Umstadt, Germany
[16] Univ Queensland, Sch Med, Brisbane, Qld, Australia
[17] Metro South Addict & Mental Hlth Serv, Brisbane, Qld, Australia
[18] Univ Augsburg, Bezirkskrankenhaus Augsburg, Dept Psychiat Psychotherapy & Psychosomat, Augsburg, Germany
基金
加拿大健康研究院;
关键词
Schizophrenia; meta-analysis; response; rTMS; clozapine; TREATMENT-RESISTANT SCHIZOPHRENIA; NONINVASIVE BRAIN-STIMULATION; AUDITORY HALLUCINATIONS; DOUBLE-BLIND; ELECTROCONVULSIVE-THERAPY; NEGATIVE SYMPTOMS; REFRACTORY SCHIZOPHRENIA; AUGMENTATION; EFFICACY; NEUROPLASTICITY;
D O I
10.1080/15622975.2020.1733080
中图分类号
R749 [精神病学];
学科分类号
100205 ;
摘要
Objectives: Biological strategies to improve treatment efficacy in clozapine-treated patients are urgently needed. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) merits consideration as intervention for patients with persistent auditory hallucinations (AH) or negative symptoms (NS) not responding sufficiently to clozapine treatment. Methods: Data from 10 international RCTs of rTMS for patients being treated with clozapine were pooled. Two levels of symptomatic response were defined: improvement of >= 20% and >= 50% on study-specific primary endpoint scales. Changes in the positive and negative syndrome scale (PANSS) from baseline to endpoint assessment were also analysed. Results: Analyses of 131 patients did not reveal a significant difference for >= 20% and >= 50% response thresholds for improvement of AH, negative or total symptoms between active and sham rTMS groups. The number needed to treat (NNT) for an improvement in persistent AH was nine following active rTMS. PANSS scores did not improve significantly from baseline to endpoint between active and sham groups in studies investigating NS and AH. Conclusions: rTMS as a treatment for persistent symptoms in clozapine-treated patients did not show a beneficial effect of active compared to sham treatment. For AH, the size of the NNTs indicates a possible beneficial effect of rTMS.
引用
收藏
页码:14 / 26
页数:13
相关论文
共 43 条
[1]   Moderate effects of noninvasive brain stimulation of the frontal cortex for improving negative symptoms in schizophrenia: Meta-analysis of controlled trials [J].
Aleman, Andre ;
Enriquez-Geppert, Stefanie ;
Knegtering, Henderikus ;
Dlabac-de Lange, Jozarni J. .
NEUROSCIENCE AND BIOBEHAVIORAL REVIEWS, 2018, 89 :111-118
[2]   Efficacy and safety of combining clozapine with electrical or magnetic brain stimulation in treatment-refractory schizophrenia [J].
Arumugham, Shyam Sundar ;
Thirthalli, Jagadisha ;
Andrade, Chittaranjan .
EXPERT REVIEW OF CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY, 2016, 9 (09) :1245-1252
[3]   Short and Long Term Effects of Left and Bilateral Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Schizophrenia Patients with Auditory Verbal Hallucinations: A Randomized Controlled Trial [J].
Bais, Leonie ;
Vercammen, Ans ;
Stewart, Roy ;
van Es, Frank ;
Visser, Bert ;
Aleman, Andre ;
Knegtering, Henderikus .
PLOS ONE, 2014, 9 (10)
[4]   MRI-targeted repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of Heschl's gyrus for refractory auditory hallucinations [J].
Blumberger, Daniel M. ;
Christensen, Bruce K. ;
Zipursky, Robert B. ;
Moller, Bertram ;
Chen, Robert ;
Fitzgerald, Paul B. ;
Daskalakis, Zafiris J. .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2012, 5 (04) :577-585
[5]   Effects of 10 Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) on clinical global impression in chronic schizophrenia [J].
Cordes, Joachim ;
Thuenker, Johanna ;
Agelink, Marcus W. ;
Arends, Mareke ;
Mobascher, Arian ;
Wobrock, Thomas ;
Schneider-Axmann, Thomas ;
Brinkmeyer, Juergen ;
Mittrach, Margarethe ;
Regenbrecht, Gunnar ;
Woelwer, Wolfgang ;
Winterer, Georg ;
Gaebel, Wolfgang .
PSYCHIATRY RESEARCH, 2010, 177 (1-2) :32-36
[6]   Increased cortical inhibition in persons with schizophrenia treated with clozapine [J].
Daskalakis, Zafiris J. ;
Christensen, Bruce K. ;
Fitzgerald, Paul B. ;
Moller, Bertram ;
Fountain, Sarah I. ;
Chen, Robert .
JOURNAL OF PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY, 2008, 22 (02) :203-209
[7]   A pilot double-blind sham-controlled trial of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for patients with refractory schizophrenia treated with clozapine [J].
de Jesus, Danilo Rocha ;
Gil, Alexei ;
Barbosa, Leonardo ;
Lobato, Maria Ines ;
da Silva Magalhaes, Pedro Vieira ;
de Souza Favalli, Gabriela Pereira ;
Marcolin, Marco Antonio ;
Daskalakis, Zafiris Jeffrey ;
Belmonte-de-Abreu, Paulo da Silva .
PSYCHIATRY RESEARCH, 2011, 188 (02) :203-207
[8]   Efficacy of bilateral repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for negative symptoms of schizophrenia: results of a multicenter double-blind randomized controlled trial [J].
Dlabac-de Lange, J. J. ;
Bais, L. ;
van Es, F. D. ;
Visser, B. G. J. ;
Reinink, E. ;
Bakker, B. ;
van den Heuvel, E. R. ;
Aleman, A. ;
Knegtering, H. .
PSYCHOLOGICAL MEDICINE, 2015, 45 (06) :1263-1275
[9]   Treatment-Resistant Schizophrenia: Treatment Response and Resistance in Psychosis (TRRIP) Working Group Consensus Guidelines on Diagnosis and Terminology [J].
Howes, Oliver D. ;
McCutcheon, Rob ;
Agid, Ofer ;
de Bartolomeis, Andrea ;
van Beveren, Nico J. M. ;
Birnbaum, Michael L. ;
Bloomfield, Michael A. P. ;
Bressan, Rodrigo A. ;
Buchanan, Robert W. ;
Carpenter, William T. ;
Castle, David J. ;
Citrome, Leslie ;
Daskalakis, Zafiris J. ;
Davidson, Michael ;
Drake, Richard J. ;
Dursun, Serdar ;
Ebdrup, Bjorn H. ;
Elkis, Helio ;
Falkai, Peter ;
Fleischacker, W. Wolfgang ;
Gadelha, Ary ;
Gaughran, Fiona ;
Glenthoj, Birte Y. ;
Graff-Guerrero, Ariel ;
Hallak, Jaime E. C. ;
Honer, William G. ;
Kennedy, James ;
Kinon, Bruce J. ;
Lawrie, Stephen M. ;
Lee, Jimmy ;
Leweke, F. Markus ;
MacCabe, James H. ;
McNabb, Carolyn B. ;
Meltzer, Herbert ;
Moeller, Hans-Juergen ;
Nakajima, Shinchiro ;
Pantelis, Christos ;
Marques, Tiago Reis ;
Remington, Gary ;
Rossell, Susan L. ;
Russell, Bruce R. ;
Siu, Cynthia O. ;
Suzuki, Takefumi ;
Sommer, Iris E. ;
Taylor, David ;
Thomas, Neil ;
Ucok, Alp ;
Umbricht, Daniel ;
Walters, James T. R. ;
Kane, John .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2017, 174 (03) :216-229
[10]   Adherence to treatment guidelines in clinical practice: study of antipsychotic treatment prior to clozapine initiation [J].
Howes, Oliver D. ;
Vergunst, Francis ;
Gee, Siobhan ;
McGuire, Philip ;
Kapur, Shitij ;
Taylor, David .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2012, 201 (06) :481-485