Do we need blood culture stewardship programs? A quality control study and survey to assess the appropriateness of blood culture collection and the knowledge and attitudes among physicians in Swiss hospitals

Background: Guidance for blood culture (BC) collection is limited. Inappropriate BC collection may be associated with potentially harmful consequences for the patient such as unnecessary laboratory testing, treatment and additional costs. The aim of the study was to assess the appropriateness of BC collection and related knowledge and attitude of precribers. Materials: We conducted a single-center quality control study to assess the appropriateness of BC collection according to the local guidelines in a Swiss university hospital in 2020 by combining three different approaches: point prevalence, patient-individual longitudinal and diseases-related analysis. Second, we conducted a survey regarding BC collection practices and knowledge among physicians in two non-university and one university hospital using an 18-item electronic questionnaire. Results: We analyzed 1114 BC collected in 344 patients. Approximately 40% of the BCs were collected inappropriately, in particular in diseases with low pretest probability of bacteremia such as non-severe community acquired pneumonia (CAP). Follow-up blood culture (FUBC) collection was inappropriate in 60%. Growth of a relevant pathogen was more frequently observed in appropriately than in inappropriately collected BCs (18% vs. 3%, p < 0.001). In the survey, uncertainty concerning the need of index BC collection was high in non-severe CAP and uncomplicated cellulitis. Conclusions: Almost half of the BCs was not collected according to the guidelines, especially in non-severe CAP and in case of FUBCs. Substantial uncertainty among physicians regarding BC ordering practices was identified. The implementation of diagnostic stewardship programs may improve BC collection practices, increase adherence to local guidelines, and may help reducing unnecessary diagnostics and treatment.