Effect of spawning day and temperature on salmon emergence: interpretations of a growth model for Methow River chinook

A mechanistic temperature-dependent model for preemergent growth coupled with spawning and river temperature data is used to evaluate early life history strategies for chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the Methow River, Washington, U.S.A. Since the model provides a predictable coupling between time of spawning and fry emergence, it helps explain the spatial and temporal patterns observed for the sympatric stocks. The model suggests that progeny of August-spawning chinook in upper river habitats emerge at button-up (no visible yolk sac) over a wide range of days in the early spring. The eggs grow efficiently, which maximizes fry mass. The progeny of October-spawning downstream chinook can exploit a wide range of habitats in the river because their emergence mass is not sensitive to location in the river, but the adults must spawn later in the season to avoid summer high temperatures. Late spawning forces fry to emerge prior to button-up to avoid scouring flows but synchronizes their emergence times. The trade-offs between the spawning strategies of these two salmon runs are complex and the seasonal and spatial distribution of temperatures plays a critical role in these trade-offs.