Hydrodynamical similarities between bubble column and bubbly pipe flow

The hydrodynamical similarities between the bubbly flow in a bubble column and in a pipe with vertical upward liquid flow are investigated. The system concerns air/water bubbly flow in a vertical cylinder of 14.9 cm inner diameter. Measurements of the radial distribution of the liquid velocity, gas fraction and the bubble velocity and size are performed using laser Doppler anemometry for the liquid velocity and a four-point optical fibre probe for the gas fraction bubble velocity and size. The averaged gas fraction was 5.2% for the bubble column (with a superficial liquid velocity of zero) and 5.5% for the bubbly pipe flow at a superficial liquid velocity of 0.175 m s(-1) From a hydrodynamical point of view, the two modes of operation are very similar. It is found that in many respects the bubbly pipe flow is the superposition of the flow in the bubble column mode and single-phase flow at the same superficial liquid velocity. The radial gas fraction profiles are the same and the velocity profiles differ only by a constant offset: the superficial liquid velocity. This means that the well-known large-scale liquid circulation tin a time-averaged sense) of the bubble column is also present in the bubbly pipe flow. For the turbulence intensities it is found that the bubbly pipe flow is like the superposition of the bubble column and the single-phase flow at the superficial liquid velocity of the pipe flow, the former being at least an order of magnitude higher than the latter. The large vortical structures that have been found in the bubble columns are also present in the bubbly pipe flow case, partly explaining the much higher 'turbulence' levels observed.