Analysis of one-way layout of count data in the presence of over or under dispersion

This article develops test statistics for the homogeneity of the means of several treatment groups of count data in the presence of over-dispersion or under-dispersion when there is no likelihood available. The C(alpha) or score type tests based on the models that are specified by only the first two moments of the counts are obtained using quasi-likelihood, extended quasi-likelihood, and double extended quasi-likelihood. Monte Carlo simulations are then used to study the comparative behavior of these C(alpha) statistics compared to the C(alpha) statistic based on a parametric model, namely, the negative binomial model, in terms of the following: size; power; robustness for departures from the data distribution as well as dispersion homogeneity. These simulations demonstrate that the C(alpha) statistic based on the double extended quasi-likelihood holds the nominal size at the 5% level well in all data situations, and it shows some edge in power over the other statistics, and, in particular, it performs much better than the commonly used statistic based on the quasi-likelihood. This C(alpha) statistic also shows robustness for moderate heterogeneity due to dispersion. Finally, applications to ecological, toxicological and biological data are given. (C) 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.