Gain of 1q is associated with adverse outcome in favorable histology Wilms' tumors

Although several genes/genetic loci involved in the etiology of Wilms' tumor have been identified, little is known of the molecular changes associated with relapse. We therefore undertook an analysis by comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) of 58 tumor samples of favorable histology Wilms' tumor taken at initial diagnosis and/or relapse. Tumors with anaplastic histology were excluded as this is known to be associated with p53 mutation and a poor prognosis. A control group of 21 Wilms' tumors that did not relapse was also analyzed. The overall frequency of gains or losses of genetic material detected by CGH was similar in both groups (77% in relapsing tumors and 70% in the nonrelapse group) as was the median number of changes per tumor (relapse group: n = 4, range, 1 to 19; nonrelapse group: n = 3, range, 1 to 8). However, gain of 1q was significantly more frequent in the relapse series [27 of 46 (59%) versus 5 of 21 (24%), P = 0.019]. In 12 matched tumor pairs, the CGH profiles, including 1q gain, were similar at diagnosis and relapse, with little evidence for further copy number changes being involved in clonal evolution. The results suggest that 1q gain at diagnosis could be used to identify patients with favorable histology Wilms' tumor at increased risk of relapse who might benefit from early treatment intensification.