Ontogenetic differentiation between Mediterranean and Eurasian pines (sect. Pinus) at the seedling stage

Heteroblastic development in pine seedlings includes extreme morphological changes with still unclear adaptive and evolutionary significance. In particular, Mediterranean and Eurasian pines (section Pinus) living in the Mediterranean basin seem to follow quite distinct developmental trajectories at the seedling stage. Aiming to confirm this ontogenetic differentiation we performed a nursery experiment with seedlings of five Mediterranean pines (Pinus pinaster, P. brutia, P. halepensis, P. pinea and P. canariensis) and three Eurasian pines (P. sylvestris, P. uncinata, and P. nigra subsp. salzmannii), also including P. radiata as an outgroup. After destructive analyses at two harvest times (9 and 32 weeks), we found sharp differentiation between Mediterranean and Eurasian pines in a combination of traits linked to shoot heteroblasty. In particular, Mediterranean pines showed a marked delay in the proportion of adult needles to total needles in the shoot compared to Eurasian species, especially at the second harvest. However, two Mediterranean pines, P. pinaster and P. brutia showed a slightly higher proportion of secondary needles, and a higher rate of budset at a more advanced stage (68 weeks) compared to the other three Mediterranean species. Meaningfully, the outgroup P. radiata was the only species combining a high proportion of adult foliage since the first harvest with a delayed formation of the first terminal bud. We discussed the adaptive significance of these findings at the light of species' climatic niches and life histories.