A Comparison of Data-Driven Approaches to Build Low-Dimensional Ocean Models

被引:12
作者
Agarwal, Niraj [1 ]
Kondrashov, D. [2 ,3 ]
Dueben, P. [4 ]
Ryzhov, E. [1 ,5 ]
Berloff, P. [1 ,6 ]
机构
[1] Imperial Coll London, Dept Math, London, England
[2] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Dept Atmospher & Ocean Sci, Los Angeles, CA USA
[3] Russian Acad Sci, Inst Appl Phys, Nizhnii Novgorod, Russia
[4] ECMWF, Reading, Berks, England
[5] Pacific Oceanol Inst, Vladivostok, Russia
[6] Russian Acad Sci, Inst Numer Math, Moscow, Russia
基金
美国国家科学基金会; 欧盟地平线“2020”; 俄罗斯科学基金会;
关键词
data-driven modeling; reduced order modeling; ocean models; machine learning; STOCHASTIC PRIMITIVE EQUATIONS; PREDICTION; ATMOSPHERE; NOISE; NONLINEARITY; REDUCTION; PARADIGM; DYNAMICS; WEATHER;
D O I
10.1029/2021MS002537
中图分类号
P4 [大气科学(气象学)];
学科分类号
0706 ; 070601 ;
摘要
We present a comprehensive inter-comparison of linear regression (LR), stochastic, and deep-learning approaches for reduced-order statistical emulation of ocean circulation. The reference data set is provided by an idealized, eddy-resolving, double-gyre ocean circulation model. Our goal is to conduct a systematic and comprehensive assessment and comparison of skill, cost, and complexity of statistical models from the three methodological classes. The model based on LR is considered as a baseline. Additionally, we investigate its additive white noise augmentation and a multi-level stochastic approach, deep-learning methods, hybrid frameworks (LR plus deep-learning), and simple stochastic extensions of deep-learning and hybrid methods. The assessment metrics considered are: root mean squared error, anomaly cross-correlation, climatology, variance, frequency map, forecast horizon, and computational cost. We found that the multi-level linear stochastic approach performs the best for both short- and long-timescale forecasts. The deep-learning hybrid models augmented by additive state-dependent white noise came second, while their deterministic counterparts failed to reproduce the characteristic frequencies in climate-range forecasts. Pure deep learning implementations performed worse than LR and its simple white noise augmentation. Skills of LR and its white noise extension were similar on short timescales, but the latter performed better on long timescales, while LR-only outputs decay to zero for long simulations. Overall, our analysis promotes multi-level LR stochastic models with memory effects, and hybrid models with linear dynamical core augmented by additive stochastic terms learned via deep learning, as a more practical, accurate, and cost-effective option for ocean emulation than pure deep-learning solutions.
引用
收藏
页数:25
相关论文
共 104 条
[1]   Correlation-based flow decomposition and statistical analysis of the eddy forcing [J].
Agarwal, N. ;
Ryzhov, E. A. ;
Kondrashov, D. ;
Berloff, P. .
JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS, 2021, 924 (924)
[2]   Long short-term memory [J].
Hochreiter, S ;
Schmidhuber, J .
NEURAL COMPUTATION, 1997, 9 (08) :1735-1780
[3]   Ocean eddy dynamics in a coupled ocean - Atmosphere model [J].
Berloff, P. ;
Dewar, W. ;
Kravtsov, S. ;
McWilliams, J. .
JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL OCEANOGRAPHY, 2007, 37 (05) :1103-1121
[4]   On dynamically unresolved oceanic mesoscale motions [J].
Berloff, Pavel ;
Ryzhov, Evgeny ;
Shevchenko, Igor .
JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS, 2021, 920
[5]   Dynamically consistent parameterization of mesoscale eddies. Part I: Simple model [J].
Berloff, Pavel .
OCEAN MODELLING, 2015, 87 :1-19
[6]   Random-forcing model of the mesoscale oceanic eddies [J].
Berloff, PS .
JOURNAL OF FLUID MECHANICS, 2005, 529 :71-95
[7]  
Berloff PS, 2003, J PHYS OCEANOGR, V33, P1416, DOI 10.1175/1520-0485(2003)033<1416:MTIOGP>2.0.CO
[8]  
2
[9]   STOCHASTIC PARAMETERIZATION Toward a New View of Weather and Climate Models [J].
Berner, Judith ;
Achatz, Ulrich ;
Batte, Lauriane ;
Bengtsson, Lisa ;
de la Camara, Alvaro ;
Christensen, Hannah M. ;
Colangeli, Matteo ;
Coleman, Danielle R. B. ;
Crommelin, Daaaan ;
Dolaptchiev, Stamen I. ;
Franzke, Christian L. E. ;
Friederichs, Petra ;
Imkeller, Peter ;
Jarvinen, Heikki ;
Juricke, Stephan ;
Kitsios, Vassili ;
Lott, Francois ;
Lucarini, Valerio ;
Mahajan, Salil ;
Palmer, Timothy N. ;
Penland, Cecile ;
Sakradzija, Mirjana ;
von Storch, Jin-Song ;
Weisheimer, Antje ;
Weniger, Michael ;
Williams, Paul D. ;
Yano, Jun-Ichi .
BULLETIN OF THE AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL SOCIETY, 2017, 98 (03) :565-587
[10]   Applications of Deep Learning to Ocean Data Inference and Subgrid Parameterization [J].
Bolton, Thomas ;
Zanna, Laure .
JOURNAL OF ADVANCES IN MODELING EARTH SYSTEMS, 2019, 11 (01) :376-399