Aim: Comparison of tapentadol prolonged release (PR) with other oral WHO-III PR opioid analgesics (morphine, oxycodone +/- naloxone, hydromorphone) in routine medical care of chronic low back pain. Patients & methods: Noninterventional, retrospective 12-week study using anonymized clinical practice data from the German Pain eRegistry. Six effectiveness, tolerability, and safety criteria were aggregated in a primary composite end point (treatment responder). Propensity scoring matched 2331 datasets per treatment cohort. Results: All six single criteria showed significantly better outcomes for tapentadol PR (all parameters p < 0.001). There were significantly more treatment responders under tapentadol PR (65.7 vs 14.2%; p < 0.001). Conclusion: Tapentadol PR showed significantly better effectiveness and tolerability in severe chronic low back pain unsuccessfully treated with WHO-I/II analgesics compared with the other oral WHO-III PR opioids investigated. Lay abstract: Chronic low back pain is a common condition often resulting in impaired functioning in daily life and reduced quality of life and well-being of the patient. In case treatment with less potent pain medications is unsuccessful, opioid treatment might be required. Our study compared the effectiveness and tolerability of the prolonged release formulation of the atypical opioid tapentadol with other strong opioids commonly used for chronic pain treatment in Germany (morphine, hydromorphone, oxycodone +/- naloxone). Anonymized patient data from German clinical practices collected in a pain registry were used (2331 comparable patients per treatment group). Patients receiving 12 weeks of tapentadol treatment experienced significantly greater pain relief, greater improvements in daily living activities, sleep, and quality of life compared with those receiving the other strong opioids investigated. Neuropathic pain components (pain features resembling nerve pain, often described as shooting, burning or stabbing pain) were reduced to a greater extent in the tapentadol treatment group. Tapentadol was also significantly better tolerated. This study showed that tapentadol is effective and well tolerated in chronic low back pain treatment in routine medical practice in patients still in considerable pain despite treatment with less potent pain medications.