Comparison of greater occipital nerve and supra orbital nerve blocks methods in the treatment of acute migraine attack: A randomized double-blind controlled trial

被引:11
作者
Hokenek, Nihat M. [1 ]
Ozer, Duygu [2 ]
Yilmaz, Erdal [1 ]
Baskaya, Nurhayat [1 ]
Hokenek, Ummahan Dalkilinc [3 ]
Ak, Rohat [1 ]
Guven, Ramazan [4 ]
Erdogan, Mehmet O. [5 ]
Mepham, Lewis Aaron [6 ]
机构
[1] Univ Hlth Sci, Kartal Dr Lutfi Kirdar City Hosp, Dept Emergency Med, Istanbul, Turkey
[2] Univ Hlth Sci, Kartal Dr Lutfi Kirdar City Hosp, Dept Neurol, Istanbul, Turkey
[3] Univ Hlth Sci, Kartal Dr Lutfi Kirdar City Hosp, Dept Anesthesiol & Reanimat, Istanbul, Turkey
[4] Basaksehir Cam & Sakura Hosp, Dept Emergency Med, Istanbul, Turkey
[5] Univ Hlth Sci, Bakirkoy Dr Sadi Konuk Training & Res Hosp, Dept Emergency Med, Istanbul, Turkey
[6] Univ Bahcesehir, Sch Med, Istanbul, Turkey
关键词
Headache; Migraine; Nerve blockade; Pain management; Emergency medicine; EMERGENCY-DEPARTMENT; HEADACHE; PLACEBO; PAIN;
D O I
10.1016/j.clineuro.2021.106821
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective: The main goal of this investigation is to compare the Greater Occipital Nerve (GON) and Supra Orbital Nerve (SON) block methods used in the treatment of migraine attacks in the ED with each other, in combination, and with a placebo. Methods: This study was planned as a single center, prospective, double-blind, randomized control study. The patients were divided into 4 groups: GON, SON, Combined, and Placebo. Groups were named according to the nerve areas that were blocked. Therefore1% lidocaine for nerve blockade and 0.9% NaCl for placebo effect was used. Along with the time of admission, baseline pain scale values, as well as recordings at 30 and 60 min in addition to the Visual Analog Scale (VAS) at the 120th min. and Likert-Type (LT) Verbal scale at the 120th min. were measured. The primary outcome of this study was a change in the VAS and LT values at the 0-120th minute after treatment Results: In this study, 128 patients in 4 groups were included in the analysis. In the GON group, SON group, and Combined group, the change observed at the 120th minute scores compared to baseline VAS scores was higher than Placebo group [OR (95% CI) =-17.4 (-24.8,-9.9), 32.1 (23.8, 40.3), 49.5 (41.9, 57), respectively]. In inter-group comparison, it was found that the VAS and LT scores of the Combined group and the GON group improved at a higher rate than the SON group Conclusions: SON blockade, GON blockade, and a combination of these two blockades are effective treatment methods in acute migraine attack. Performing a GON or Combined blockade for migraine attack causes greater pain reduction than SON blockade.
引用
收藏
页数:8
相关论文
共 28 条
[1]   Greater Occipital Nerve Block for Acute Treatment of Migraine Headache: A Large Retrospective Cohort Study [J].
Allen, Sorcha M. ;
Mookadam, Farouk ;
Cha, Stephen S. ;
Freeman, John A. ;
Starling, Amaal J. ;
Mookadam, Martina .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN BOARD OF FAMILY MEDICINE, 2018, 31 (02) :211-218
[2]   The effects of greater occipital nerve block and trigger point injection on brush allodynia and pain in migraine [J].
Ashkenazi, A ;
Young, WB .
HEADACHE, 2005, 45 (04) :350-354
[3]   Intranasal Lidocaine in Acute Treatment of Migraine: A Randomized Controlled Trial [J].
Avcu, Nazire ;
Dogan, Nurettin Ozgur ;
Pekdemir, Murat ;
Yaka, Elif ;
Yilmaz, Serkan ;
Alyesil, Cansu ;
Akalin, Latif Erdem .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2017, 69 (06) :743-751
[4]   Expert Consensus Recommendations for the Performance of Peripheral Nerve Blocks for Headaches - A Narrative Review [J].
Blumenfeld, Andrew ;
Ashkenazi, Avi ;
Napchan, Uri ;
Bender, Steven D. ;
Klein, Brad C. ;
Berliner, Randall ;
Ailani, Jessica ;
Schim, Jack ;
Friedman, Deborah I. ;
Charleston, Larry ;
Young, William B. ;
Robertson, Carrie E. ;
Dodick, David W. ;
Silberstein, Stephen D. ;
Robbins, Matthew S. .
HEADACHE, 2013, 53 (03) :437-446
[5]   Patterns of Use of Peripheral Nerve Blocks and Trigger Point Injections Among Headache Practitioners in the USA: Results of the American Headache Society Interventional Procedure Survey (AHS-IPS) [J].
Blumenfeld, Andrew ;
Ashkenazi, Avi ;
Grosberg, Brian ;
Napchan, Uri ;
Narouze, Samer ;
Nett, Bob ;
DePalma, Traci ;
Rosenthal, Barbara ;
Tepper, Stewart ;
Lipton, Richard B. .
HEADACHE, 2010, 50 (06) :937-942
[6]   Therapeutic blockade of greater occipital and supraorbital nerves in migraine patients [J].
Caputi, CA ;
Firetto, V .
HEADACHE, 1997, 37 (03) :174-179
[7]   ASSESSMENT OF CHRONIC PAIN .1. ASPECTS OF THE RELIABILITY AND VALIDITY OF THE VISUAL ANALOG SCALE [J].
CARLSSON, AM .
PAIN, 1983, 16 (01) :87-101
[8]   Guidelines of the International Headache Society for controlled trials of acute treatment of migraine attacks in adults: Fourth edition [J].
Diener, Hans-Christoph ;
Tassorelli, Cristina ;
Dodick, David W. ;
Silberstein, Stephen D. ;
Lipton, Richard B. ;
Ashina, Messoud ;
Becker, Werner J. ;
Ferrari, Michel D. ;
Goadsby, Peter J. ;
Pozo-Rosich, Patricia ;
Wang, Shuu-Jiun ;
Mandrekar, Jay .
CEPHALALGIA, 2019, 39 (06) :687-710
[9]   Headaches in the emergency department -a survey of patients' characteristics, facts and needs [J].
Doretti, Alberto ;
Shestaritc, Irina ;
Ungaro, Daniela ;
Lee, John-Ih ;
Lymperopoulos, Loukas ;
Kokoti, Lili ;
Guglielmetti, Martina ;
Mitsikostas, Dimos Dimitrios ;
Lampl, Christian .
JOURNAL OF HEADACHE AND PAIN, 2019, 20 (01)
[10]   Headache in the Emergency Department [J].
Evans, Randolph W. ;
Friedman, Benjamin W. .
HEADACHE, 2011, 51 (08) :1276-1278