MUST I ACCEPT PROSECUTION FOR CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE?

被引:3
|
作者
Weltman, Daniel [1 ]
机构
[1] Ashoka Univ, Sonipat, India
关键词
civil disobedience; political obligation; punishment; answerability;
D O I
10.1093/pq/pqz028
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Piero Moraro argues that people who engage in civil disobedience do not have a pro tanto reason to accept punishment for breaking the law, although they do have a duty to undergo prosecution. This is because they have a duty to answer for their actions, and the state serves as an agent of the people by calling the lawbreaker to answer via prosecution. I argue that Moraro does not go far enough. Someone who engages in civil disobedience does not even have to show up for the trial, provided that they answer for their actions adequately via some other means. This is because sometimes states are not agents of the people who can call lawbreakers to account, and even those states which are agents cannot demand that lawbreakers answer for their crimes in the form of a trial.
引用
收藏
页码:410 / 418
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] ON (NOT) ACCEPTING THE PUNISHMENT FOR CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE
    Moraro, Piero
    PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2018, 68 (272) : 503 - 520
  • [2] In Defense of Penalizing (but not Punishing) Civil Disobedience
    David Lefkowitz
    Res Publica, 2018, 24 : 273 - 289
  • [3] In Defense of Penalizing (but not Punishing) Civil Disobedience
    Lefkowitz, David
    RES PUBLICA-A JOURNAL OF MORAL LEGAL AND POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY, 2018, 24 (03): : 273 - 289
  • [4] Samaritanism and Civil Disobedience
    Delmas C.
    Res Publica, 2014, 20 (3) : 295 - 313
  • [5] Civil disobedience
    Real Lopez, Manuel de Jesus
    Navarrete Luque, Corina Elena
    Cedeno Leon, Guillermo
    DILEMAS CONTEMPORANEOS-EDUCACION POLITICA Y VALORES, 2018, 6
  • [6] Civil Disobedience and Civil Culture
    Szabo, Mate
    CIVIL SZEMLE, 2019, 16 (03): : 37 - +
  • [7] Civil Disobedience and Civil Culture
    Szabo, Mate
    CIVIL SZEMLE, 2009, 6 (03): : 7 - +
  • [8] Features of a Paradigm Case of Civil Disobedience
    Kimberley Brownlee
    Res Publica, 2004, 10 (4) : 337 - 351
  • [9] IMPUNITY (OR NOT) FOR CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE
    Vojnovic, Sava
    PRAVNI ZAPISI, 2023, 14 (01): : 148 - 178
  • [10] Democratizing civil disobedience
    Celikates, Robin
    PHILOSOPHY & SOCIAL CRITICISM, 2016, 42 (10) : 982 - 994