A systematic review on exercise and training-based interventions for freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease

被引:62
作者
Gilat, Moran [1 ]
Ginis, Pieter [1 ]
Zoetewei, Demi [1 ]
De Vleeschhauwer, Joni [1 ]
Hulzinga, Femke [1 ]
D'Cruz, Nicholas [1 ]
Nieuwboer, Alice [1 ]
机构
[1] Katholieke Univ Leuven, Dept Rehabil Sci, Neurorehabil Res Grp eNRGy, Leuven, Belgium
关键词
FALLS PREVENTION; PEOPLE; THERAPY; PROGRAM; BALANCE; MOTOR; PERFORMANCE; DANCE; TRIAL; AUTOMATICITY;
D O I
10.1038/s41531-021-00224-4
中图分类号
Q189 [神经科学];
学科分类号
071006 ;
摘要
Freezing of gait (FOG) in Parkinson's disease (PD) causes severe patient burden despite pharmacological management. Exercise and training are therefore advocated as important adjunct therapies. In this meta-analysis, we assess the existing evidence for such interventions to reduce FOG, and further examine which type of training helps the restoration of gait function in particular. The primary meta-analysis across 41 studies and 1838 patients revealed a favorable moderate effect size (ES = -0.37) of various training modalities for reducing subjective FOG-severity (p < 0.00001), though several interventions were not directly aimed at FOG and some included non-freezers. However, exercise and training also proved beneficial in a secondary analysis on freezers only (ES = -0.32, p = 0.007). We further revealed that dedicated training aimed at reducing FOG episodes (ES = -0.24) or ameliorating the underlying correlates of FOG (ES = -0.40) was moderately effective (p < 0.01), while generic exercises were not (ES = -0.14, p = 0.12). Relevantly, no retention effects were seen after cessation of training (ES = -0.08, p = 0.36). This review thereby supports the implementation of targeted training as a treatment for FOG with the need for long-term engagement.
引用
收藏
页数:18
相关论文
共 114 条
[1]   Brain plasticity in Parkinson's disease with freezing of gait induced by action observation training [J].
Agosta, Federica ;
Gatti, Roberto ;
Sarasso, Elisabetta ;
Volonte, Maria Antonietta ;
Canu, Elisa ;
Meani, Alessandro ;
Sarro, Lidia ;
Copetti, Massimiliano ;
Cattrysse, Erik ;
Kerckhofs, Eric ;
Comi, Giancarlo ;
Falini, Andrea ;
Filippi, Massimo .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY, 2017, 264 (01) :88-101
[2]   Predictors of Adherence to a Falls Prevention Exercise Program for People with Parkinson's Disease [J].
Allen, Natalie E. ;
Song, Jooeun ;
Paul, Serene S. ;
Sherrington, Catherine ;
Murray, Susan M. ;
O'Rourke, Sandra D. ;
Lord, Stephen R. ;
Fung, Victor S. C. ;
Close, Jacqueline C. T. ;
Howard, Kirsten ;
Canning, Colleen G. .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2015, 2 (04) :395-401
[3]   The Effects of an Exercise Program on Fall Risk Factors in People with Parkinson's Disease: A Randomized Controlled Trial [J].
Allen, Natalie E. ;
Canning, Colleen G. ;
Sherrington, Catherine ;
Lord, Stephen R. ;
Latt, Mark D. ;
Close, Jacqueline C. T. ;
O'Rourke, Sandra D. ;
Murray, Susan M. ;
Fung, Victor S. C. .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2010, 25 (09) :1217-1225
[4]   Freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease: a perceptual cause for a motor impairment? [J].
Almeida, Q. J. ;
Lebold, C. A. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2010, 81 (05) :513-518
[5]   Randomized, Controlled Trial of Exercise on Objective and Subjective Sleep in Parkinson's Disease [J].
Amara, Amy W. ;
Wood, Kimberly H. ;
Joop, Allen ;
Memon, Raima A. ;
Pilkington, Jennifer ;
Tuggle, S. Craig ;
Reams, John ;
Barrett, Matthew J. ;
Edwards, David A. ;
Weltman, Arthur L. ;
Hurt, Christopher P. ;
Cutter, Gary ;
Bamman, Marcas M. .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2020, 35 (06) :947-958
[6]   Exercise- and strategy-based physiotherapy-delivered intervention for preventing repeat falls in people with Parkinson's: the PDSAFE RCT [J].
Ashburn, Ann ;
Pickering, Ruth ;
McIntosh, Emma ;
Hulbert, Sophia ;
Rochester, Lynn ;
Roberts, Helen C. ;
Nieuwboer, Alice ;
Kunkel, Dorit ;
Goodwin, Victoria A. ;
Lamb, Sarah E. ;
Ballinger, Claire ;
Seymour, Kim Chivers .
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, 2019, 23 (36) :VII-+
[7]   Deep Brain Stimulation for Freezing of Gait in Parkinson's Disease With Early Motor Complications [J].
Barbe, Michael T. ;
Tonder, Lisa ;
Krack, Paul ;
Debu, Bettina ;
Schupbach, Michael ;
Paschen, Steffen ;
Dembek, Till A. ;
Kuehn, Andrea A. ;
Fraix, Valerie ;
Brefel-Courbon, Christine ;
Wojtecki, Lars ;
Maltete, David ;
Damier, Phillippe ;
Sixel-Doering, Friederike ;
Weiss, Daniel ;
Pinsker, Marcus ;
Witjas, Tatiana ;
Thobois, Stephane ;
Schade-Brittinger, Carmen ;
Rau, Joern ;
Houeto, Jean-Luc ;
Hartmann, Andreas ;
Timmermann, Lars ;
Schnitzler, Alfons ;
Stoker, Valerie ;
Vidailhet, Marie ;
Deuschl, Guenther ;
Knudsen, K. ;
Volkmann, J. ;
Falk, D. ;
Mehdorn, M. ;
Haelbig, T. D. ;
Hesekamp, H. ;
Navarro, S. M. ;
Meier, N. ;
Agid, Y. ;
Seigneuret, E. ;
Kistner, A. ;
Chaynes, P. ;
Ory-Magne, F. ;
Bataille, B. ;
Raoul, S. ;
Regis, J. -M. ;
Mertens, P. ;
Helwig, D. ;
Oertel, W. H. ;
Maarouf, M. ;
Fink, G. R. ;
Kupsch, A. ;
Gruber, D. .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2020, 35 (01) :82-90
[8]   The laser shoes: A new ambulatory device to alleviate freezing of gait in Parkinson disease [J].
Barthel, Claudia ;
Nonnekes, Jorik ;
van Helvert, Milou ;
Haan, Renee ;
Janssen, Arno ;
Delval, Arnaud ;
Weerdesteyn, Vivian ;
Debu, Bettina ;
van Wezel, Richard ;
Bloem, Bastiaan R. ;
Ferraye, Murielle U. .
NEUROLOGY, 2018, 90 (02) :E164-E171
[9]   Do Patients With Parkinson's Disease With Freezing of Gait Respond Differently Than Those Without to Treadmill Training Augmented by Virtual Reality? [J].
Bekkers, Esther M. J. ;
Mirelman, Anat ;
Alcock, Lisa ;
Rochester, Lynn ;
Nieuwhof, Freek ;
Bloem, Bastiaan R. ;
Pelosin, Elisa ;
Avanzino, Laura ;
Cereatti, Andrea ;
Della Croce, Ugo ;
Hausdorff, Jeffrey M. ;
Nieuwboer, Alice .
NEUROREHABILITATION AND NEURAL REPAIR, 2020, 34 (05) :440-449
[10]   Measurement instruments to assess posture, gait, and balance in Parkinson's disease: Critique and recommendations [J].
Bloem, Bastiaan R. ;
Marinus, Johan ;
Almeida, Quincy ;
Dibble, Lee ;
Nieuwboer, Alice ;
Post, Bart ;
Ruzicka, Evzen ;
Goetz, Christopher ;
Stebbins, Glenn ;
Martinez-Martin, Pablo ;
Schrag, Anette .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2016, 31 (09) :1342-1355