An Assessment of the Impact of Just Culture on Quality and Safety in US Hospitals

In pursuit of high reliability, numerous organizations have promoted Just Culture, but its impact has never been assessed. This report combines data from a longitudinal survey-based study of clinical peer review practices in a cohort of 457 acute care hospitals with 43 measures from the Hospital Compare database and interprets them in relation to the long-term trends of Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) data on the Hospital Survey of Patient Safety Culture. In all, 211 of 270 respondents (79%) indicated that their hospital has adopted Just Culture. More than half believe that it has had a positive impact. Just Culture implementation and its degree of impact are associated with somewhat better peer review process, but not with objective measures of hospital performance. Non-Punitive Response to Error has consistently been the lowest scoring category (45% positive) in the AHRQ database. Widespread adoption of Just Culture has not reduced reluctance to report or the culture of blame it targets.