Trying to discredit the Duplo task with a partial replication: Reply to Paulus and Kammermeier (2018)

被引：3

作者：

Rubio-Fernandez, Paula ^{[1
,2
]}

机构：

[1] MIT, Dept Brain & Cognit Sci, Cambridge, MA 02139 USA

[2] Univ Oslo, Dept Philosophy, Oslo, Norway

来源：

COGNITIVE DEVELOPMENT | 2018年 / 48卷

关键词：

Failed vs. partial replication; Theoretical background; Conceptual replication; Task manipulations; Double standards; Replication crisis; BILINGUALISM; ADVANTAGE;

D O I：

10.1016/j.cogdev.2018.07.006

中图分类号：

B844 [发展心理学（人类心理学）];

学科分类号：

040202 ;

摘要：

Kammermeier and Paulus (2018) report a partial replication of the results of Rubio-Fernandez and Geurts (2013) but present their study as a failed replication. Paulus and Kammermeier (2018) insist on a negative interpretation of their findings, discrediting the Duplo task against their own empirical evidence. Here I argue that Paulus and Kammermeier may try to make an impactful contribution to the field by adding to the growing skepticism towards early Theory of Mind studies, but fail to make any significant contribution to our understanding of young children's Theory of Mind abilities.

引用

页码：286 / 288

页数：3

共 16 条

[1]

Antoniou M., 2018, ANN REV LINGUISTICS

[2]

Bialecka-Pikul M., 2018, 2018 BUD CEU C COGN

[3]

Bialecka-Pikul M., 2018, J EXPT CHILD PSYCHOL

[4] Publication Bias and the Validity of Evidence: What's the Connection? [J].

Bialystok, Ellen ;

Kroll, Judith F. ;

Green, David W. ;

MacWhinney, Brian ;

Craik, Fergus I. M. .

PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2015, 26 (06) :944-946

[5] Bilingualism and the Development of Executive Function: The Role of Attention [J].

Bialystok, Ellen .

CHILD DEVELOPMENT PERSPECTIVES, 2015, 9 (02) :117-121

[6] Cognitive Advantage in Bilingualism: An Example of Publication Bias? [J].

de Bruin, Angela ;

Treccani, Barbara ;

Della Sala, Sergio .

PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2015, 26 (01) :99-107

[7] Are there bilingual advantages on nonlinguistic interference tasks? Implications for the plasticity of executive control processes [J].

Hilchey, Matthew D. ;

Klein, Raymond M. .

PSYCHONOMIC BULLETIN & REVIEW, 2011, 18 (04) :625-658

[8]

Kammermeier M., 2018, COGNITIVE DEV

[9]

Kulke L., 2018, PSYCHOL SCI

[10] There is no coherent evidence for a bilingual advantage in executive processing [J].

Paap, Kenneth R. ;

Greenberg, Zachary I. .

COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY, 2013, 66 (02) :232-258

← 1 2 →