CT Evaluation by Artificial Intelligence for Atherosclerosis, Stenosis and Vascular Morphology (CLARIFY): A Multi-center, international study

被引:142
作者
Choi, Andrew D. [1 ,4 ]
Marques, Hugo [2 ,3 ]
Kumar, Vishak [1 ]
Griffin, William F. [4 ]
Rahban, Habib [5 ]
Karlsberg, Ronald P. [5 ]
Zeman, Robert K. [4 ]
Katz, Richard J. [1 ]
Earls, James P. [4 ]
机构
[1] George Washington Univ, Sch Med, Div Cardiol, Washington, DC 20037 USA
[2] Ctr Hosp Univ Lisboa Cent, Serv Radiol, Hosp Santa Marta, Lisbon, Portugal
[3] Nova Med Sch, Fac Ciencias Med, Lisbon, Portugal
[4] George Washington Univ, Dept Radiol, Sch Med, Washington, DC 20037 USA
[5] Cardiovasc Res Fdn Southern Calif, Beverly Hills, CA USA
关键词
Cardiac computed tomography; Atherosclerosis; Artificial intelligence; Machine learning; Coronary artery disease; Heart attack; CORONARY-ARTERY-DISEASE; NORTH-AMERICAN SOCIETY; COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY; SCCT GUIDELINES; SOCIAL MEDIA; CHEST-PAIN; ANGIOGRAPHY; PLAQUE; COLLEGE; EVENTS;
D O I
10.1016/j.jcct.2021.05.004
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background: Atherosclerosis evaluation by coronary computed tomography angiography (CCTA) is promising for coronary artery disease (CAD) risk stratification, but time consuming and requires high expertise. Artificial Intelligence (AI) applied to CCTA for comprehensive CAD assessment may overcome these limitations. We hypothesized AI aided analysis allows for rapid, accurate evaluation of vessel morphology and stenosis. Methods: This was a multi-site study of 232 patients undergoing CCTA. Studies were analyzed by FDA-cleared software service that performs AI-driven coronary artery segmentation and labeling, lumen and vessel wall determination, plaque quantification and characterization with comparison to ground truth of consensus by three L3 readers. CCTAs were analyzed for: % maximal diameter stenosis, plaque volume and composition, presence of high-risk plaque and Coronary Artery Disease Reporting & Data System (CAD-RADS) category. Results: AI performance was excellent for accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value as follows: >70% stenosis: 99.7%, 90.9%, 99.8%, 93.3%, 99.9%, respectively; >50% stenosis: 94.8%, 80.0%, 97.0, 80.0%, 97.0%, respectively. Bland-Altman plots depict agreement between expert reader and AI determined maximal diameter stenosis for per-vessel (mean difference-0.8%; 95% CI 13.8% to-15.3%) and per-patient (mean difference-2.3%; 95% CI 15.8% to-20.4%). L3 and AI agreed within one CAD-RADS category in 228/232 (98.3%) exams per-patient and 923/924 (99.9%) vessels on a per-vessel basis. There was a wide range of atherosclerosis in the coronary artery territories assessed by AI when stratified by CAD-RADS distribution . Conclusions: AI-aided approach to CCTA interpretation determines coronary stenosis and CAD-RADS category in close agreement with consensus of L3 expert readers. There was a wide range of atherosclerosis identified through AI.
引用
收藏
页码:470 / 476
页数:7
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]   SCCT guidelines for the performance and acquisition of coronary computed tomographic angiography: A report of the society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography Guidelines Committee Endorsed by the North American Society for Cardiovascular Imaging (NASCI) [J].
Abbara, Suhny ;
Blanke, Philipp ;
Maroules, Christopher D. ;
Cheezum, Michael ;
Choi, Andrew D. ;
Han, B. Kelly ;
Marwan, Mohamed ;
Naoum, Chris ;
Norgaard, Bjarne L. ;
Rubinshtein, Ronen ;
Schoenhagen, Paul ;
Villines, Todd ;
Leipsic, Jonathon .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY, 2016, 10 (06) :435-449
[2]   Prognostic Value of Combined Clinical and Myocardial Perfusion Imaging Data Using Machine Learning [J].
Betancur, Julian ;
Otaki, Yuka ;
Motwani, Manish ;
Fish, Mathews B. ;
Lemley, Mark ;
Dey, Damini ;
Gransar, Heidi ;
Tamarappoo, Balaji ;
Germano, Guido ;
Sharir, Tali ;
Berman, Daniel S. ;
Slomka, Piotr J. .
JACC-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2018, 11 (07) :1000-1009
[3]   On Deep Learning for Medical Image Analysis [J].
Carin, Lawrence ;
Pencina, Michael J. .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2018, 320 (11) :1192-1193
[4]  
Chang HJ, 2018, J AM COLL CARDIOL, V71, P2511, DOI DOI 10.1016/S0735-1097(18)32539-7
[5]   Accelerating the future of cardiac CT: Social media as sine qua non? [J].
Choi, Andrew D. ;
Feuchtner, Gudrun M. ;
Weir-McCall, Jonathan ;
Shaw, Leslee J. ;
Min, James K. ;
Villines, Todd C. .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY, 2020, 14 (05) :382-385
[6]   The global social media response to the 14th annual Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography scientific sessions [J].
Choi, Andrew D. ;
Parwani, Purvi ;
Michos, Erin D. ;
Lee, James ;
Singh, Vasvi ;
Fentanes, Emilio ;
Lopez-Mattei, Juan ;
Gulati, Martha ;
Nasir, Khurram ;
Nieman, Koen ;
Shaw, Leslee J. ;
Blankstein, Ron .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY, 2020, 14 (02) :124-130
[7]   Cardiovascular Imaging Through the Prism of Modern Metrics [J].
Choi, Andrew D. ;
Geske, Jeffrey B. ;
Lopez-Mattei, Juan C. ;
Parwani, Purvi ;
Wang, Dee Dee ;
Winchester, David E. ;
Sengupta, Partho P. ;
Zoghbi, William A. ;
Shaw, Leslee J. ;
Chandrashekhar, Y. S. ;
Blankstein, Ron .
JACC-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2020, 13 (05) :1256-1269
[8]   Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography guidance for use of cardiac computed tomography amidst the COVID-19 pandemic Endorsed by the American College of Cardiology [J].
Choi, Andrew D. ;
Abbara, Suhny ;
Branch, Kelley R. ;
Feuchtner, Gudrun M. ;
Ghoshhajra, Brian ;
Nieman, Koen ;
Pontone, Gianluca ;
Villines, Todd C. ;
Williams, Michelle C. ;
Blankstein, Ron .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY, 2020, 14 (02) :101-104
[9]   CAD-RADS™ Coronary Artery Disease - Reporting and Data System. An expert consensus document of the Society of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography (SCCT), the American College of Radiology (ACR) and the North American Society for Cardiovascular Imaging (NASCI). Endorsed by the American College of Cardiology [J].
Cury, Ricardo C. ;
Abbara, Suhny ;
Achenbach, Stephan ;
Agatston, Arthur ;
Berman, Daniel S. ;
Budoff, Matthew J. ;
Dill, Karin E. ;
Jacobs, Jill E. ;
Maroules, Christopher D. ;
Rubin, Geoffrey D. ;
Rybicki, Frank J. ;
Schoepf, U. Joseph ;
Shaw, Leslee J. ;
Stillman, Arthur E. ;
White, Charles S. ;
Woodard, Pamela K. ;
Leipsic, Jonathon A. .
JOURNAL OF CARDIOVASCULAR COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY, 2016, 10 (04) :269-281
[10]   Artificial Intelligence in Cardiovascular Imaging JACC State-of-the-Art Review [J].
Dey, Damini ;
Slomka, Piotr J. ;
Leeson, Paul ;
Comaniciu, Dorin ;
Shrestha, Sirish ;
Sengupta, Partho P. ;
Marwick, Thomas H. .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2019, 73 (11) :1317-1335