Accuracy of computational pressure-fluid dynamics applied to coronary angiography to derive fractional flow reserve: FLASH FFR

被引:103
作者
Li, Jianping [1 ]
Gong, Yanjun [1 ]
Wang, Weimin [2 ]
Yang, Qing [3 ]
Liu, Bin [4 ]
Lu, Yuan [5 ]
Xu, Yawei [6 ]
Huo, Yunlong [7 ]
Yi, Tieci [1 ]
Liu, Jian [2 ]
Li, Yongle [3 ]
Xu, Shaopeng [3 ]
Zhao, Lei [4 ]
Ali, Ziad A. [8 ,9 ,10 ]
Huo, Yong [1 ]
机构
[1] Peking Univ, Dept Cardiol, Hosp 1, Beijing, Peoples R China
[2] Peking Univ, Dept Cardiol, Peoples Hosp, Beijing, Peoples R China
[3] Tianjin Med Univ, Dept Cardiol, Gen Hosp, Tianjin, Peoples R China
[4] Second Hosp Jilin Univ, Dept Cardiol, Changchun, Jilin, Peoples R China
[5] Xuzhou Med Univ, Affiliated Hosp, Dept Cardiol, Xuzhou, Jiangsu, Peoples R China
[6] Shanghai Tenth Peoples Hosp, Dept Cardiol, Shanghai, Peoples R China
[7] PKU HKUST Shenzhen Hongkong Inst, Shenzhen, Peoples R China
[8] Cardiovasc Res Fdn, Clin Trials Ctr, New York, NY USA
[9] Columbia Univ, Med Ctr, NewYork Presbyterian Hosp, Dept Med, New York, NY USA
[10] St Francis Hosp, Roslyn, NY USA
关键词
FFR; CFD; Angiography; Coronary artery; DIAGNOSTIC-ACCURACY; BLOOD-FLOW; VALIDATION; MANAGEMENT; SEVERITY; STENOSIS; HUMANS; RATIO; WIRE;
D O I
10.1093/cvr/cvz289
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Aims Conventional fractional flow reserve (FFR) is measured invasively using a coronary guidewire equipped with a pressure sensor. A non-invasive derived FFR would eliminate risk of coronary injury, minimize technical limitations, and potentially increase adoption. We aimed to evaluate the diagnostic performance of a computational pressure-flow dynamics derived FFR (caFFR), applied to coronary angiography, compared to invasive FFR. Methods and results The FLASH FFR study was a prospective, multicentre, single-arm study conducted at six centres in China. Eligible patients had native coronary artery target lesions with visually estimated diameter stenosis of 30-90% and diagnosis of stable or unstable angina pectoris. Using computational pressure-fluid dynamics, in conjunction with thrombolysis in myocardial infarction (TIMI) frame count, applied to coronary angiography, caFFR was measured online in realtime and compared blind to conventional invasive FFR by an independent core laboratory. The primary endpoint was the agreement between caFFR and FFR, with a pre-specified performance goal of 84%. Between June and December 2018, matched caFFR and FFR measurements were performed in 328 coronary arteries. Total operational time for caFFR was 4.54 +/- 1.48 min. caFFR was highly correlated to FFR (R = 0.89, P = 0.76) with a mean bias of -0.002 +/- 0.049 (95% limits of agreement -0.098 to 0.093). The diagnostic performance of caFFR vs. FFR was diagnostic accuracy 95.7%, sensitivity 90.4%, specificity 98.6%, positive predictive value 97.2%, negative predictive value 95.0%, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.979. Conclusions Using wire-based FFR as the reference, caFFR has high accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity. caFFR could eliminate the need of a pressure wire, technical error and potentially increase adoption of physiological assessment of coronary artery stenosis severity.
引用
收藏
页码:1349 / 1356
页数:8
相关论文
共 37 条
[1]  
Cohen J., 1988, Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, V2nd ed.
[2]   Diagnostic performance of angiography-derived fractional flow reserve: a systematic review and Bayesian meta-analysis [J].
Collet, Carlos ;
Onuma, Yoshinobu ;
Sonck, Jeroen ;
Asano, Taku ;
Vandeloo, Bert ;
Kornowski, Ran ;
Tu, Shengxian ;
Westra, Jelmer ;
Holm, Niels R. ;
Xu, Bo ;
de Winter, Robbert J. ;
Tijssen, Jan G. ;
Miyazaki, Yosuke ;
Katagiri, Yuki ;
Tenekecioglu, Erhan ;
Modolo, Rodrigo ;
Chichareon, Ply ;
Cosyns, Bernard ;
Schoors, Daniel ;
Roosens, Bram ;
Lochy, Stijn ;
Argacha, Jean-Francois ;
van Rosendael, Alexandre ;
Bax, Jeroen ;
Reiber, Johan H. C. ;
Escaned, Javier ;
De Bruyne, Bernard ;
Wijns, William ;
Serruys, Patrick W. .
EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2018, 39 (35) :3314-+
[3]   Does Routine Pressure Wire Assessment Influence Management Strategy at Coronary Angiography for Diagnosis of Chest Pain? The RIPCORD Study [J].
Curzen, Nick ;
Rana, Omar ;
Nicholas, Zoe ;
Golledge, Peter ;
Zaman, Azfar ;
Oldroyd, Keith ;
Hanratty, Colm ;
Banning, Adrian ;
Wheatcroft, Stephen ;
Hobson, Alex ;
Chitkara, Kam ;
Hildick-Smith, David ;
McKenzie, Dan ;
Calver, Alison ;
Dimitrov, Borislav D. ;
Corbett, Simon .
CIRCULATION-CARDIOVASCULAR INTERVENTIONS, 2014, 7 (02) :248-255
[4]   Use of the Instantaneous Wave-free Ratio or Fractional Flow Reserve in PCI [J].
Davies, J. E. ;
Sen, S. ;
Dehbi, H. -M. ;
Al-Lamee, R. ;
Petraco, R. ;
Nijjer, S. S. ;
Bhindi, R. ;
Lehman, S. J. ;
Walters, D. ;
Sapontis, J. ;
Janssens, L. ;
Vrints, C. J. ;
Khashaba, A. ;
Laine, M. ;
Van Belle, E. ;
Krackhardt, F. ;
Bojara, W. ;
Going, O. ;
Harle, T. ;
Indolfi, C. ;
Niccoli, G. ;
Ribichini, F. ;
Tanaka, N. ;
Yokoi, H. ;
Takashima, H. ;
Kikuta, Y. ;
Erglis, A. ;
Vinhas, H. ;
Silva, P. Canas ;
Baptista, S. B. ;
Alghamdi, A. ;
Hellig, F. ;
Koo, B. -K. ;
Nam, C. -W. ;
Shin, E. -S. ;
Doh, J. -H. ;
Brugaletta, S. ;
Alegria-Barrero, E. ;
Meuwissen, M. ;
Piek, J. J. ;
van Royen, N. ;
Sezer, M. ;
Di Mario, C. ;
Gerber, R. T. ;
Malik, I. S. ;
Sharp, A. S. P. ;
Talwar, S. ;
Tang, K. ;
Samady, H. ;
Altman, J. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2017, 376 (19) :1824-1834
[5]   Fractional Flow Reserve-Guided PCI versus Medical Therapy in Stable Coronary Disease [J].
De Bruyne, Bernard ;
Pijls, Nico H. J. ;
Kalesan, Bindu ;
Barbato, Emanuele ;
Tonino, Pim A. L. ;
Piroth, Zsolt ;
Jagic, Nikola ;
Mobius-Winckler, Sven ;
Rioufol, Gilles ;
Witt, Nils ;
Kala, Petr ;
MacCarthy, Philip ;
Engstrom, Thomas ;
Oldroyd, Keith G. ;
Mavromatis, Kreton ;
Manoharan, Ganesh ;
Verlee, Peter ;
Frobert, Ole ;
Curzen, Nick ;
Johnson, Jane B. ;
Jueni, Peter ;
Fearon, William F. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2012, 367 (11) :991-1001
[6]   CORONARY FLOW RESERVE CALCULATED FROM PRESSURE MEASUREMENTS IN HUMANS - VALIDATION WITH POSITRON EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY [J].
DEBRUYNE, B ;
BAUDHUIN, T ;
MELIN, JA ;
PIJLS, NHJ ;
SYS, SU ;
BOL, A ;
PAULUS, WJ ;
HEYNDRICKX, GR ;
WIJNS, W .
CIRCULATION, 1994, 89 (03) :1013-1022
[7]   Impact of injection rate on the Thrombolysis In Myocardial Infarction (TIMI) trial frame count [J].
Dodge, JT ;
Rizzo, M ;
Nykiel, M ;
Altmann, J ;
Hobkirk, K ;
Brennan, M ;
Gibson, CM .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY, 1998, 81 (10) :1268-+
[8]   1-Year Outcomes of FFRCT-Guided Care in Patients With Suspected Coronary Disease The PLATFORM Study [J].
Douglas, Pamela S. ;
De Bruyne, Bernard ;
Pontone, Gianluca ;
Patel, Manesh R. ;
Norgaard, Bjarne L. ;
Byrne, Robert A. ;
Curzen, Nick ;
Purcell, Ian ;
Gutberlet, Matthias ;
Rioufol, Gilles ;
Hink, Ulrich ;
Schuchlenz, Herwig Walter ;
Feuchtner, Gudrun ;
Gilard, Martine ;
Andreini, Daniele ;
Jensen, Jesper M. ;
Hadamitzky, Martin ;
Chiswell, Karen ;
Cyr, Derek ;
Wilk, Alan ;
Wang, Furong ;
Rogers, Campbell ;
Hlatky, Mark A. .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2016, 68 (05) :435-445
[9]   Accuracy of Fractional Flow Reserve Derived From Coronary Angiography [J].
Fearon, William F. ;
Achenbach, Stephan ;
Engstrom, Thomas ;
Assali, Abid ;
Shlofmitz, Richard ;
Jeremias, Allen ;
Fournier, Stephane ;
Kirtane, Ajay J. ;
Kornowski, Ran ;
Greenberg, Gabriel ;
Jubeh, Rami ;
Kolansky, Daniel M. ;
McAndrew, Thomas ;
Dressler, Ovidiu ;
Maehara, Akiko ;
Matsumura, Mitsuaki ;
Leon, Martin B. ;
De Bruyne, Bernard .
CIRCULATION, 2019, 139 (04) :477-484
[10]   2012 ACCF/AHA/ACP/AATS/PCNA/SCAI/STS Guideline for the Diagnosis and Management of Patients With Stable Ischemic Heart Disease [J].
Fihn, Stephan D. ;
Gardin, Julius M. ;
Abrams, Jonathan ;
Berra, Kathleen ;
Blankenship, James C. ;
Dallas, Apostolos P. ;
Douglas, Pamela S. ;
Foody, JoAnne M. ;
Gerber, Thomas C. ;
Hinderliter, Alan L. ;
King, Spencer B., III ;
Kligfield, Paul D. ;
Krumholz, Harlan M. ;
Kwong, Raymond Y. K. ;
Lim, Michael J. ;
Linderbaum, Jane A. ;
Mack, Michael J. ;
Munger, Mark A. ;
Prager, Richard L. ;
Sabik, Joseph F. ;
Shaw, Leslee J. ;
Sikkema, Joanna D. ;
Smith, Craig R. ;
Smith, Sidney C., Jr. ;
Spertus, John A., Jr. ;
Williams, Sankey V. ;
Anderson, Jeffrey L. ;
Halperin, Jonathan L. ;
Jacobs, Alice K. ;
Smith, Sidney C., Jr. ;
Adams, Cynthia D. ;
Albert, Nancy M. ;
Brindis, Ralph G. ;
Buller, Christopher E. ;
Creager, Mark A. ;
DeMets, David ;
Ettinger, Steven M. ;
Guyton, Robert A. ;
Hochman, Judith S. ;
Hunt, Sharon Ann ;
Kovacs, Richard J. ;
Kushner, Frederick G. ;
Lytle, Bruce W. ;
Nishimura, Rick A. ;
Ohman, E. Magnus ;
Page, Richard L. ;
Riegel, Barbara ;
Stevenson, William G. ;
Tarkington, Lynn G. ;
Yancy, Clyde W. .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2012, 60 (24) :E44-E164