Changes in alveolar bone height and width following ridge augmentation using bone graft and membranes

Background: Clinical observation suggests the amount of bone height and width created during guided bone regeneration (GBR) to augment alveolar ridges is not retained during healing. A study was designed to determine: 1) whether the amount of osseous structure 4 months postoperatively after GBR was significantly less than the amount surgically created; and 2) if this change was uniform over the area treated. Methods: Nineteen extraction sites (10 patients) were treated with GBR prior to placing endosseous implants. Allograft (DMFDB) and a bioabsorbable membrane were employed. Standardized measurements were taken of alveolar height and width I) prior to augmentation; 2) after placement of graft and membrane; and 3) following 4 months of healing. Width measurements were taken 3 mm, 5 mm, and 10 mm from the crest at 3 intervals: the mesio-distal midpoint of the edentulous area and 3 mm mesial and distal to the midpoint. Height measurements were recorded at the mesio-distal midpoint and points 3 mm mesial and distal to the midpoint. Results: Loss in width of supplemented bone after 4 months of healing ranged from 52.1% to 58.0% 3 mm from the crest, 47.6% to 67.4% 5 mm from the crest, and 39.1 % to 46.7% 10 mm from the crest. Loss of augmented height averaged 14.7% in the center of the edentulous area but ranged from 60.5% to 76.3% 3 mm mesial and distal to the midpoint. Conclusions: The results indicate significant nonuniform loss of augmented alveolar height and width during GBR healing. The implications of these findings impact preoperative augmentation planning for endosseous implantology.