A Community Study of SARS-CoV-2 Detection by RT-PCR in Saliva: A Reliable and Effective Method

被引:7
|
作者
Fronza, Filippo [1 ]
Groff, Nelli [1 ]
Martinelli, Angela [1 ]
Passerini, Beatrice Zita [1 ]
Rensi, Nicolo [1 ]
Cortelletti, Irene [1 ]
Vivori, Nicolo [1 ]
Adami, Valentina [1 ]
Helander, Anna [1 ]
Bridi, Simone [1 ]
Pancher, Michael [1 ]
Greco, Valentina [1 ]
Garritano, Sonia Iolanda [1 ]
Piffer, Elena [1 ]
Stefani, Lara [1 ]
De Sanctis, Veronica [1 ]
Bertorelli, Roberto [1 ]
Pancheri, Serena [2 ]
Collini, Lucia [2 ]
Dassi, Erik [1 ]
Quattrone, Alessandro [1 ]
Capobianchi, Maria Rosaria [3 ]
Icardi, Giancarlo [4 ]
Poli, Guido [5 ]
Caciagli, Patrizio [1 ,2 ]
Ferro, Antonio [2 ]
Pizzato, Massimo [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Trento, Dept Cellular Computat & Integrat Biol, I-38123 Trento, Italy
[2] Azienda Provinciale & Servizi Sanitari, I-38123 Trento, Italy
[3] Natl Inst Infect Dis L Spallanzani, I-00149 Rome, Italy
[4] Univ Genoa, Dept Hlth Sci, I-16132 Genoa, Italy
[5] Univ Vita Salute San Raffaele, I-20132 Milan, Italy
来源
VIRUSES-BASEL | 2022年 / 14卷 / 02期
关键词
COVID-19; saliva testing; molecular diagnosis; SARS-CoV-2; detection; RNA;
D O I
10.3390/v14020313
中图分类号
Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Efficient, wide-scale testing for SARS-CoV-2 is crucial for monitoring the incidence of the infection in the community. The gold standard for COVID-19 diagnosis is the molecular analysis of epithelial secretions from the upper respiratory system captured by nasopharyngeal (NP) or oropharyngeal swabs. Given the ease of collection, saliva has been proposed as a possible substitute to support testing at the population level. Here, we used a novel saliva collection device designed to favour the safe and correct acquisition of the sample, as well as the processivity of the downstream molecular analysis. We tested 1003 nasopharyngeal swabs and paired saliva samples self-collected by individuals recruited at a public drive-through testing facility. An overall moderate concordance (68%) between the two tests was found, with evidence that neither system can diagnose the infection in 100% of the cases. While the two methods performed equally well in symptomatic individuals, their discordance was mainly restricted to samples from convalescent subjects. The saliva test was at least as effective as NP swabs in asymptomatic individuals recruited for contact tracing. Our study describes a testing strategy of self-collected saliva samples, which is reliable for wide-scale COVID-19 screening in the community and is particularly effective for contact tracing.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [11] Does sampling saliva increase detection of SARS-CoV-2 by RT-PCR? Comparing saliva with oro-nasopharyngeal swabs
    Dogan, Ozlem Akgun
    Kose, Betsi
    Agaoglu, Nihat Bugra
    Yildiz, Jale
    Alkurt, Gizem
    Demirkol, Yasemin Kendir
    Irvem, Arzu
    Doganay, Gizem Dinler
    Doganay, Levent
    JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS, 2021, 290
  • [12] Saliva is a reliable and accessible source for the detection of SARS-CoV-2
    Herrera, Luis A.
    Hidalgo-Miranda, Alfredo
    Reynoso-Noveron, Nancy
    Meneses-Garcia, Abelardo A.
    Mendoza-Vargas, Alfredo
    Reyes-Grajeda, Juan P.
    Vadillo-Ortega, Felipe
    Cedro-Tanda, Alberto
    Penaloza, Fernando
    Frias-Jimenez, Emmanuel
    Arriaga-Canon, Cristian
    Ruiz, Rosaura
    Angulo, Ofelia
    Lopez-Villasenor, Imelda
    Amador-Bedolla, Carlos
    Vilar-Compte, Diana
    Cornejo, Patricia
    Cisneros-Villanueva, Mireya
    Hurtado-Cordova, Eduardo
    Cendejas-Orozco, Mariana
    Hernandez-Morales, Jose S.
    Moreno, Bernardo
    Hernandez-Cruz, Irwin A.
    Herrera, Cesar A.
    Garcia, Francisco
    Gonzalez-Woge, Miguel A.
    Munguia-Garza, Paulina
    Luna-Maldonado, Fernando
    Sanchez-Vizcarra, Antonia
    Osnaya, Vincent G.
    Medina-Molotla, Nelly
    Alfaro-Mora, Yair
    Caceres-Gutierrez, Rodrigo E.
    Tolentino-Garcia, Laura
    Rosas-Escobar, Patricia
    Roman-Gonzalez, Sergio A.
    Escobar-Arrazola, Marco A.
    Canseco-Mendez, Julio C.
    Ortiz-Soriano, Diana R.
    Dominguez-Ortiz, Julieta
    Gonzalez-Barrera, Ana D.
    Aparicio-Bautista, Diana, I
    Cruz-Rangel, Armando
    Alarcon-Zendejas, Ana Paula
    Contreras-Espinosa, Laura
    Gonzalez, Rodrigo
    Guerra-Calderas, Lissania
    Meraz-Rodriguez, Marco A.
    Montalvo-Casimiro, Michel
    Montiel-Manriquez, Rogelio
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2021, 105 : 83 - 90
  • [13] Clinical Evaluation of Nasopharyngeal, Oropharyngeal, Nasal Swabs, and Saliva for the Detection of SARS-CoV-2 by Direct RT-PCR
    Kiryanov, Sergei A.
    Levina, Tatiana A.
    Kadochnikova, Vladislava V.
    Konopleva, Maria V.
    Suslov, Anatoly P.
    Trofimov, Dmitry Yu.
    DIAGNOSTICS, 2022, 12 (05)
  • [14] Comparison of FTD SARS-CoV-2 Assay and RealStar RT-PCR kit 1.0 for the detection of SARS-CoV-2
    Di Carlo, Daniele
    Mazzuti, Laura
    Sciandra, Ilaria
    Guerrizio, Giuliana
    Oliveto, Giuseppe
    Cabral, Rodolfo J. Riveros
    Zingaropoli, Maria Antonella
    Turriziani, Ombretta
    JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS, 2021, 298
  • [15] Clinical Performance of Direct RT-PCR Testing of Raw Saliva for Detection of SARS-CoV-2 in Symptomatic and Asymptomatic Individuals
    Castillo-Bravo, Rosa
    Lucca, Noel
    Lai, Linyi
    Marlborough, Killian
    Brychkova, Galina
    Sakhteh, Maryam Shideh
    Lonergan, Charlie
    O'Grady, Justin
    Alikhan, Nabil-Fareed
    Trotter, Alexander J.
    Page, Andrew J.
    Smyth, Breda
    McKeown, Peter C.
    Feenstra, Jelena D. M.
    Ulekleiv, Camilla
    Sorel, Oceane
    Gandhi, Manoj
    Spillane, Charles
    MICROBIOLOGY SPECTRUM, 2022, 10 (06):
  • [16] Assessment of 12 qualitative RT-PCR commercial kits for the detection of SARS-CoV-2
    Altamimi, Asmaa M.
    Obeid, Dalia A.
    Alaifan, Taghreed A.
    Taha, Moroje T.
    Alhothali, Marwa T.
    Alzahrani, Fahad A.
    Albarrag, Ahmad M.
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2021, 93 (05) : 3219 - 3226
  • [17] Assessment of Multiplex Digital Droplet RT-PCR as a Diagnostic Tool for SARS-CoV-2 Detection in Nasopharyngeal Swabs and Saliva Samples
    Cassinari, Kevin
    Alessandri-Gradt, Elodie
    Chambon, Pascal
    Charbonnier, Francoise
    Gracias, Segolene
    Beaussire, Ludivine
    Alexandre, Kevin
    Sarafan-Vasseur, Nasrin
    Houdayer, Claude
    Etienne, Manuel
    Caron, Francois
    Plantier, Jean Christophe
    Frebourg, Thierry
    CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, 2021, 67 (05) : 736 - 741
  • [18] Value of swab types and collection time on SARS-COV-2 detection using RT-PCR assay
    Liu, Min
    Li, Qianyuan
    Zhou, Jun
    Ai, Wen
    Zheng, Xiaoling
    Zeng, Jingjing
    Liu, Yuwen
    Xiang, Xiying
    Guo, Rong
    Li, Xiaoyin
    Wu, Xiandi
    Xu, Haiying
    Jiang, Ling
    Zhang, Huaqin
    Chen, Jing
    Tian, Lili
    Luo, Jun
    Luo, Chunhua
    JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS, 2020, 286
  • [19] Evaluation of two RT-PCR techniques for SARS-CoV-2 RNA detection in serum for microbiological diagnosis
    Martin Ramirez, Alexandra
    Zurita Cruz, Nelly Daniela
    Gutierrez-Cobos, Ainhoa
    Rodriguez Serrano, Diego Anibal
    Gonzalez Alvaro, Isidoro
    Roy Vallejo, Emilia
    Gomez de Frutos, Sara
    Fontan Garcia-Rodrigo, Leticia
    Cardenoso Domingo, Laura
    JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS, 2022, 300
  • [20] Usefulness of SARS-CoV-2 antigen test sample as input for SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR analysis
    Garcia-Salguero, Cristina
    Culebras, Esther
    Merino, Paloma
    Baos, Elvira
    Delgado-Iribarren, Alberto
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2022, 94 (04) : 1693 - 1695