Long-term outcomes of psychological treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:42
作者
Weber, Maxi [1 ]
Schumacher, Sarah [2 ,3 ]
Hannig, Wiebke [4 ]
Barth, Jurgen [5 ]
Lotzin, Annett [6 ]
Schaefer, Ingo [6 ]
Ehring, Thomas [7 ]
Kleim, Birgit [8 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Free Univ Berlin, Div Clin Psychol & Psychotherapy, Berlin, Germany
[2] Free Univ Berlin, Div Clin Psychol Intervent, Berlin, Germany
[3] Philips Univ Marburg, Dept Psychol, Marburg, Germany
[4] Philipps Univ Marburg, Dept Psychol, Clin Psychol & Psychotherapy, Marburg, Germany
[5] Univ Hosp Zurich, Inst Complementary & Integrat Med, Zurich, Switzerland
[6] Univ Med Ctr Hamburg Eppendorf, Dept Psychiat & Psychotherapy, Hamburg, Germany
[7] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Dept Psychol, Munich, Germany
[8] Univ Zurich, Dept Psychol, Zurich, Switzerland
[9] Univ Zurich, Psychiat Univ Hosp Zurich, Dept Psychiat Psychotherapy & Psychosomat, Zurich, Switzerland
关键词
Efficacy; long-term; meta-analysis; posttraumatic stress disorder; psychological treatment; PTSD; COGNITIVE-PROCESSING THERAPY; EYE-MOVEMENT DESENSITIZATION; NARRATIVE EXPOSURE THERAPY; PROLONGED EXPOSURE; RANDOMIZED-TRIAL; PUBLICATION BIAS; BEHAVIORAL THERAPY; ADULT SURVIVORS; PSYCHOTHERAPY; EFFICACY;
D O I
10.1017/S003329172100163X
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Several types of psychological treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are considered well established and effective, but evidence of their long-term efficacy is limited. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to investigate the long-term outcomes across psychological treatments for PTSD. MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, PTSDpubs, PsycINFO, PSYNDEX, and related articles were searched for randomized controlled trials with at least 12 months of follow-up. Twenty-two studies (N = 2638) met inclusion criteria, and 43 comparisons of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) were available at follow-up. Active treatments for PTSD yielded large effect sizes from pretest to follow-up and a small controlled effect size compared with non-directive control groups at follow-up. Trauma-focused treatment (TFT) and non-TFT showed large improvements from pretest to follow-up, and effect sizes did not significantly differ from each other. Active treatments for comorbid depressive symptoms revealed small to medium effect sizes at follow-up, and improved PTSD and depressive symptoms remained stable from treatment end to follow-up. Military personnel, low proportion of female patients, and self-rated PTSD measures were associated with decreased effect sizes for PTSD at follow-up. The findings suggest that CBT for PTSD is efficacious in the long term. Future studies are needed to determine the lasting efficacy of other psychological treatments and to confirm benefits beyond 12-month follow-up.
引用
收藏
页码:1420 / 1430
页数:11
相关论文
共 85 条
[1]   BEHAVIORAL ACTIVATION AND THERAPEUTIC EXPOSURE FOR POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER: A NONINFERIORITY TRIAL OF TREATMENT DELIVERED IN PERSON VERSUS HOME-BASED TELEHEALTH [J].
Acierno, Ron ;
Gros, Daniel F. ;
Ruggiero, Kenneth J. ;
Hernandez-Tejada, B. Melba A. ;
Knapp, Rebecca G. ;
Lejuez, Carl W. ;
Muzzy, Wendy ;
Frueh, Christopher B. ;
Egede, Leonard E. ;
Tuerk, Peter W. .
DEPRESSION AND ANXIETY, 2016, 33 (05) :415-423
[2]  
American Psychological Assocation, 2017, Clinical practice guidelines for the treatment of PTSD
[3]   An Investigation of Depression, Trauma History, and Symptom Severity in Individuals Enrolled in a Treatment Trial for Chronic PTSD [J].
Bedard-Gilligan, Michele ;
Jakob, Jeanne M. Duax ;
Doane, Lisa Stines ;
Jaeger, Jeff ;
Eftekhari, Afsoon ;
Feeny, Norah ;
Zoellner, Lori A. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2015, 71 (07) :725-740
[4]   The relative efficacy of bona fide psychotherapies for treating post-traumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons [J].
Benish, Steven G. ;
Imel, Zac E. ;
Wampold, Bruce E. .
CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY REVIEW, 2008, 28 (05) :746-758
[5]   Psychological therapies for chronic post- traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in adults [J].
Bisson, Jonathan I. ;
Roberts, Neil P. ;
Andrew, Martin ;
Cooper, Rosalind ;
Lewis, Catrin .
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2013, (12)
[6]   One- and two-year prospective follow-up of cognitive behavior therapy or supportive psychotherapy [J].
Blanchard, EB ;
Hickling, EJ ;
Malta, LS ;
Freidenberg, BM ;
Canna, MA ;
Kuhn, E ;
Sykes, MA ;
Galovski, TE .
BEHAVIOUR RESEARCH AND THERAPY, 2004, 42 (07) :745-759
[7]  
Borenstein M., 2021, Introduction to meta-analysis
[8]   Cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety and related disorders: A meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials [J].
Carpenter, Joseph K. ;
Andrews, Leigh A. ;
Witcraft, Sara M. ;
Powers, Mark B. ;
Smits, Jasper A. J. ;
Hofmann, Stefan G. .
DEPRESSION AND ANXIETY, 2018, 35 (06) :502-514
[9]   Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing Versus Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Adult Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis [J].
Chen, Ling ;
Zhang, Guiqing ;
Hu, Min ;
Liang, Xia .
JOURNAL OF NERVOUS AND MENTAL DISEASE, 2015, 203 (06) :443-451
[10]   SOME METHODS FOR STRENGTHENING THE COMMON X2 TESTS [J].
COCHRAN, WG .
BIOMETRICS, 1954, 10 (04) :417-451