Deep penetrating naevus: clinicopathological study of 31 cases with further delineation of histological features allowing distinction from other pigmented benign melanocytic lesions and melanoma

Aims: To examine a series of deep penetrating naevus (DPN) and discuss the differential diagnosis of pigmented, deep penetrating melanocytic lesions and their biological potential. DPN has been described as a variant of common acquired intradermal melanocytic naevus. DPN remains poorly recognized by pathologists, partly attributable to its relatively rare occurrence. Methods and results: Thirty-one cases of deeply pigmented lesions were studied. The patients included 17 females and 14 males with an age range between 3 and 56 years (mean 25.8, median 23). The common clinical sites were face (n = 10) back (n = 6) and lower extremity (n = 7). The clinical diagnoses included various benign melanocytic naevi, and malignant melanoma, as well as non-melanocytic lesions. Histologically, all cases presented as wedge-shaped lesions composed of fusiform cells but also epithelioid melanocytes, with pale cytoplasm and oval nuclei. Pigment was identified in melanophages but also within lesional melanocytic cells. Nine cases contained mitotic figures. Nine cases showed the coexistence of 'ordinary' common acquired naevocytes, and seven lesions showed overlapping features with either ordinary blue naevus or Spitz naevus. In 13 lesions there was at least one feature that may cause concern as to the biological nature of the tumour. These include asymmetry, cytological atypia, inflammation, or an 'expansile' advancing margin. Each tumour was treated by simple excision; one lesion recurred after 1 year. No tumour metastasized. Conclusions: DPN is a distinct variant of melanocytic naevus. In some cases the histological features overlap with other benign melanocytic lesions. Criteria for recognizing malignant examples remain unclear, but cytological atypia and low mitotic activity do not necessarily portend a sinister outcome.