Counterion-Mediated Crossing of the Cyanine Limit in Crystals and Fluid Solution: Bond Length Alternation and Spectral Broadening Unveiled by Quantum Chemistry

Absorption spectra of cyanine(circle plus)center dot Br-circle minus salts show a remarkable solvent dependence in non/polar solvents, exhibiting narrow, sharp band shapes in dichloromethane but broad features in toluene; this change was attributed to ion pair association, stabilizing an asymmetric dipolar structure, similar to the situation in the crystal (Bouit, P.-A., et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2010, 132, 4328). Our density functional theory (DFT)-based quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations of the crystals evidence the crucial role of specific asymmetric anion positioning on the lowering of the symmetry. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations prove the ion pair association in nonpolar solvents. Time-dependent DFT vibronic calculations in toluene show that ion pairing indeed stabilizes an asymmetric dipolar structure in the electronic ground state. This largely broadens the absorption spectrum in very reasonable agreement with experiment, while the principal pattern of vibrational modes is retained. The current findings allow us to establish a unified picture of the symmetry breaking of polymethine dyes in fluid solution.