Are mRNA based transcriptomic signatures ready for diagnosing tuberculosis in the clinic? - A review of evidence and the technological landscape

被引:19
作者
Hamada, Yohhei [1 ]
Penn-Nicholson, Adam [2 ]
Krishnan, Sriram [2 ]
Cirillo, Daniela Maria [3 ]
Matteelli, Alberto [4 ]
Wyss, Romain [2 ]
Denkinger, Claudia M. [2 ,5 ,6 ]
Rangaka, Molebogeng X. [1 ,7 ,8 ]
Ruhwald, Morten [2 ]
Schumacher, Samuel G. [2 ]
机构
[1] UCL, Inst Global Hlth, London, England
[2] FIND, Campus Biotech Bldg B2,Level O,9 Chemin Mines, Geneva, Switzerland
[3] IRCCS San Raffaele Sci Inst, Milan, Italy
[4] Univ Brescia, Collaborating Ctr TB HIV Coinfect & TB Eliminat, Dept Infect & Trop Dis, Brescia, Italy
[5] Heidelberg Univ Hosp, Ctr Infect Dis, Div Trop Med, Heidelberg, Germany
[6] Partner Site Heidelberg Univ Hosp, German Ctr Infect Res, Heidelberg, Germany
[7] Univ Cape Town, Sch Publ Hlth, Rondebosch, South Africa
[8] Univ Cape Town, Clin Infect Dis Res Inst AFRICA, Rondebosch, South Africa
关键词
Point-of-care TB diagnostics; Transcriptomics; mRNA signature; Fold change; ACTIVE PULMONARY TUBERCULOSIS; MINIMUM INFORMATION; SUBCLINICAL DISEASE; POSITRON-EMISSION; BLOOD; EXPRESSION; BIOMARKERS; ACCURACY; RISK; HIV;
D O I
10.1016/j.ebiom.2022.104174
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Advances in discovery and validation of diagnostic, prognostic and treatment-monitoring transcriptomic signatures of tuberculosis (TB) disease could accelerate the goal to end TB. We conducted a review to evaluate whether mRNA transcriptomics technologies are sufficiently mature to develop accurate next-generation TB diagnostic tests. Early studies tended to be limited in sample size, diversity of population groups, sample collection and processing methods, while recent prospective studies have addressed these limitations. Some of the existing signatures could be used for triage; however, high cost and complexity could limit their use. For a confirmatory test, setting an optimal cut-off to maintain specificity across populations and settings is a challenge. mRNA signatures have shown the potential to quantitatively monitor response to treatment. No prognostic signatures can accurately predict progression to active TB over 2 years while short term prediction is possible. The management strategy should be defined for individuals with positive prognostic tests. Copyright (C) 2022 Published by Elsevier B.V.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 68 条
[1]   Diagnosis of Childhood Tuberculosis and Host RNA Expression in Africa [J].
Anderson, Suzanne T. ;
Kaforou, Myrsini ;
Brent, Andrew J. ;
Wright, Victoria J. ;
Banwell, Claire M. ;
Chagaluka, George ;
Crampin, Amelia C. ;
Dockrell, Hazel M. ;
French, Neil ;
Hamilton, Melissa S. ;
Hibberd, Martin L. ;
Kern, Florian ;
Langford, Paul R. ;
Ling, Ling ;
Mlotha, Rachel ;
Ottenhoff, Tom H. M. ;
Pienaar, Sandy ;
Pillay, Vashini ;
Scott, J. Anthony G. ;
Twahir, Hemed ;
Wilkinson, Robert J. ;
Coin, Lachlan J. ;
Heyderman, Robert S. ;
Levin, Michael ;
Eley, Brian .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2014, 370 (18) :1712-1723
[2]  
Banaei Niaz, 2016, J Clin Microbiol, V54, P845, DOI 10.1128/JCM.02803-15
[3]   Multi-country evaluation of RISK6, a 6-gene blood transcriptomic signature, for tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment monitoring [J].
Bayaa, Rim ;
Ndiaye, Mame Diarra Bousso ;
Chedid, Carole ;
Kokhreidze, Eka ;
Tukvadze, Nestani ;
Banu, Sayera ;
Uddin, Mohammad Khaja Mafij ;
Biswas, Samanta ;
Nasrin, Rumana ;
Ranaivomanana, Paulo ;
Raherinandrasana, Antso Hasina ;
Rakotonirina, Julio ;
Rasolofo, Voahangy ;
Delogu, Giovanni ;
De Maio, Flavio ;
Goletti, Delia ;
Endtz, Hubert ;
Ader, Florence ;
Hamze, Monzer ;
Ismail, Mohamad Bachar ;
Pouzol, Stephane ;
Rakotosamimanana, Niaina ;
Hoffmann, Jonathan .
SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2021, 11 (01)
[4]   An interferon-inducible neutrophil-driven blood transcriptional signature in human tuberculosis [J].
Berry, Matthew P. R. ;
Graham, Christine M. ;
McNab, Finlay W. ;
Xu, Zhaohui ;
Bloch, Susannah A. A. ;
Oni, Tolu ;
Wilkinson, Katalin A. ;
Banchereau, Romain ;
Skinner, Jason ;
Wilkinson, Robert J. ;
Quinn, Charles ;
Blankenship, Derek ;
Dhawan, Ranju ;
Cush, John J. ;
Mejias, Asuncion ;
Ramilo, Octavio ;
Kon, Onn M. ;
Pascual, Virginia ;
Banchereau, Jacques ;
Chaussabel, Damien ;
O'Garra, Anne .
NATURE, 2010, 466 (7309) :973-U98
[5]   Detectable Changes in The Blood Transcriptome Are Present after Two Weeks of Antituberculosis Therapy [J].
Bloom, Chloe I. ;
Graham, Christine M. ;
Berry, Matthew P. R. ;
Wilkinson, Katalin A. ;
Oni, Tolu ;
Rozakeas, Fotini ;
Xu, Zhaohui ;
Rossello-Urgell, Jose ;
Chaussabel, Damien ;
Banchereau, Jacques ;
Pascual, Virginia ;
Lipman, Marc ;
Wilkinson, Robert J. ;
O'Garra, Anne .
PLOS ONE, 2012, 7 (10)
[6]   Minimum information about a microarray experiment (MIAME) - toward standards for microarray data [J].
Brazma, A ;
Hingamp, P ;
Quackenbush, J ;
Sherlock, G ;
Spellman, P ;
Stoeckert, C ;
Aach, J ;
Ansorge, W ;
Ball, CA ;
Causton, HC ;
Gaasterland, T ;
Glenisson, P ;
Holstege, FCP ;
Kim, IF ;
Markowitz, V ;
Matese, JC ;
Parkinson, H ;
Robinson, A ;
Sarkans, U ;
Schulze-Kremer, S ;
Stewart, J ;
Taylor, R ;
Vilo, J ;
Vingron, M .
NATURE GENETICS, 2001, 29 (04) :365-371
[7]   The MIQE Guidelines: Minimum Information for Publication of Quantitative Real-Time PCR Experiments [J].
Bustin, Stephen A. ;
Benes, Vladimir ;
Garson, Jeremy A. ;
Hellemans, Jan ;
Huggett, Jim ;
Kubista, Mikael ;
Mueller, Reinhold ;
Nolan, Tania ;
Pfaffl, Michael W. ;
Shipley, Gregory L. ;
Vandesompele, Jo ;
Wittwer, Carl T. .
CLINICAL CHEMISTRY, 2009, 55 (04) :611-622
[8]   Distinct Phases of Blood Gene Expression Pattern Through Tuberculosis Treatment Reflect Modulation of the Humoral Immune Response [J].
Cliff, Jacqueline M. ;
Lee, Ji-Sook ;
Constantinou, Nicholas ;
Cho, Jang-Eun ;
Clark, Taane G. ;
Ronacher, Katharina ;
King, Elizabeth C. ;
Lukey, Pauline T. ;
Duncan, Ken ;
Van Helden, Paul D. ;
Walzl, Gerhard ;
Dockrell, Hazel M. .
JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2013, 207 (01) :18-29
[9]   A real-time PCR signature to discriminate between tuberculosis and other pulmonary diseases [J].
da Costa, Lucas Laux ;
Delcroix, Melaine ;
Costa, Elis R. Dalla ;
Prestes, Isaias V. ;
Milano, Mariana ;
Francis, Steve S. ;
Unis, Gisela ;
Silva, Denise R. ;
Riley, Lee W. ;
Rossetti, Maria L. R. .
TUBERCULOSIS, 2015, 95 (04) :421-425
[10]   Detection of Tuberculosis Recurrence, Diagnosis and Treatment Response by a Blood Transcriptomic Risk Signature in HIV-Infected Persons on Antiretroviral Therapy [J].
Darboe, Fatoumatta ;
Mbandi, Stanley Kimbung ;
Naidoo, Kogieleum ;
Yende-Zuma, Nonhlanhla ;
Lewis, Lara ;
Thompson, Ethan G. ;
Duffy, Fergal J. ;
Fisher, Michelle ;
Filander, Elizabeth ;
van Rooyen, Michele ;
Bilek, Nicole ;
Mabwe, Simbarashe ;
McKinnon, Lyle R. ;
Chegou, Novel ;
Loxton, Andre ;
Walzl, Gerhard ;
Tromp, Gerard ;
Padayatchi, Nesri ;
Govender, Dhineshree ;
Hatherill, Mark ;
Karim, Salim Abdool ;
Zak, Daniel E. ;
Penn-Nicholson, Adam ;
Scriba, Thomas J. ;
Matiwane, Sindile ;
Jaxa, Lungisa ;
Xoyana, Noncedo ;
Schreuder, Constance ;
Botes, Janelle ;
Africa, Hadn ;
Makhethe, Lebohang ;
Steyn, Marcia ;
Nombida, Onke ;
Raphela, Rodney ;
Erasmus, Mzwandile .
FRONTIERS IN MICROBIOLOGY, 2019, 10