Mycobacterium bovis BCG Vaccination Induces Divergent Proinflammatory or Regulatory T Cell Responses in Adults

Mycobacterium bovis bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG), the only currently available vaccine against tuberculosis, induces variable protection in adults. Immune correlates of protection are lacking, and analyses on cytokine-producing T cell subsets in protected versus unprotected cohorts have yielded inconsistent results. We studied the primary T cell response, both proinflammatory and regulatory T cell responses, induced by BCG vaccination in adults. Twelve healthy adult volunteers who were tuberculin skin test (TST) negative, QuantiFERON test (QFT) negative, and BCG naive were vaccinated with BCG and followed up prospectively. BCG vaccination induced an unexpectedly dichotomous immune response in this small, BCG-naive, young-adult cohort: BCG vaccination induced either gamma interferon-positive (IFN-gamma(+)) interleukin 2-positive (IL-2(+)) tumor necrosis factor alpha-positive (TNF-alpha(+)) polyfunctional CD4(+) T cells concurrent with CD4(+) IL-17A(+) and CD8(+) IFN-gamma(+) T cells or, in contrast, virtually absent cytokine responses with induction of CD8(+) regulatory T cells. Significant induction of polyfunctional CD4(+) IFN-gamma(+) IL-2(+) TNF-alpha(+) T cells and IFN-gamma production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) was confined to individuals with strong immunization-induced local skin inflammation and increased serum C-reactive protein (CRP). Conversely, in individuals with mild inflammation, regulatory-like CD8(+) T cells were uniquely induced. Thus, BCG vaccination either induced a broad proinflammatory T cell response with local inflammatory reactogenicity or, in contrast, a predominant CD8(+) regulatory T cell response with mild local inflammation, poor cytokine induction, and absent polyfunctional CD4(+) T cells. Further detailed fine mapping of the heterogeneous host response to BCG vaccination using classical and nonclassical immune markers will enhance our understanding of the mechanisms and determinants that underlie the induction of apparently opposite immune responses and how these impact the ability of BCG to induce protective immunity to TB.