Toxicity testing in the 21st century: progress in the past decade and future perspectives

被引:252
作者
Krewski, D. [1 ,2 ,4 ]
Andersen, M. E. [3 ]
Tyshenko, M. G. [2 ]
Krishnan, K. [2 ,5 ]
Hartung, T. [6 ]
Boekelheide, K. [7 ]
Wambaugh, J. F. [8 ]
Jones, D. [9 ]
Whelan, M. [10 ]
Thomas, R. [8 ]
Yauk, C. [11 ]
Barton-Maclaren, T. [11 ]
Cote, I. [12 ,13 ]
机构
[1] Univ Ottawa, Sch Epidemiol & Publ Hlth, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[2] Risk Sci Int, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[3] Scitovation, Charlotte, NC USA
[4] Univ Ottawa, McLaughlin Ctr Populat Hlth Risk Assessment, Fac Med, Peter Morand Crescent 216A-600, Ottawa, ON K1G 5Z3, Canada
[5] Inst Rech Robert Sauve Sante & Securite Travail, Montreal, PQ, Canada
[6] Johns Hopkins Univ, CAAT, Baltimore, MD USA
[7] Brown Univ, Pathol & Lab Med, Providence, RI 02912 USA
[8] US Environm Protect Agcy, Natl Ctr Computat Toxicol, Res Triangle Pk, NC USA
[9] Emory Univ, Sch Med, Atlanta, GA USA
[10] JRC, European Commiss, Ispra, Italy
[11] Hlth Canada, Healthy Environm & Consumer Safety Branch, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[12] US Environm Protect Agcy, Natl Ctr Environm Assessment, Washington, DC USA
[13] Univ Konstanz, Constance, Germany
基金
加拿大自然科学与工程研究理事会;
关键词
Toxicity testing; New approach methodologies; Computational toxicology; High-throughput in vitro testing; High-throughput exposomics; High-throughput pharmacokinetics; In vitro to in vivo extrapolation; HUMAN HEALTH-RISK; ADVERSE OUTCOME PATHWAYS; TRIAZOLE CONAZOLE FUNGICIDES; THROUGHPUT SCREENING ASSAYS; IN-VIVO EXTRAPOLATION; CELL-CULTURE PRACTICE; HIGH-RESOLUTION METABOLOMICS; GENE-EXPRESSION SIGNATURES; EVIDENCE-BASED TOXICOLOGY; OF-THE-ART;
D O I
10.1007/s00204-019-02613-4
中图分类号
R99 [毒物学(毒理学)];
学科分类号
100405 ;
摘要
Advances in the biological sciences have led to an ongoing paradigm shift in toxicity testing based on expanded application of high-throughput in vitro screening and in silico methods to assess potential health risks of environmental agents. This review examines progress on the vision for toxicity testing elaborated by the US National Research Council (NRC) during the decade that has passed since the 2007 NRC report on Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century (TT21C). Concomitant advances in exposure assessment, including computational approaches and high-throughput exposomics, are also documented. A vision for the next generation of risk science, incorporating risk assessment methodologies suitable for the analysis of new toxicological and exposure data, resulting in human exposure guidelines is described. Case study prototypes indicating how these new approaches to toxicity testing, exposure measurement, and risk assessment are beginning to be applied in practice are presented. Overall, progress on the 20-year transition plan laid out by the US NRC in 2007 has been substantial. Importantly, government agencies within the United States and internationally are beginning to incorporate the new approach methodologies envisaged in the original TT21C vision into regulatory practice. Future perspectives on the continued evolution of toxicity testing to strengthen regulatory risk assessment are provided.
引用
收藏
页码:1 / 58
页数:58
相关论文
共 452 条
[41]   Ab initio chemical safety assessment: A workflow based on exposure considerations and non-animal methods [J].
Berggren E. ;
White A. ;
Ouedraogo G. ;
Paini A. ;
Richarz A.-N. ;
Bois F.Y. ;
Exner T. ;
Leite S. ;
Grunsven L.A.V. ;
Worth A. ;
Mahony C. .
Computational Toxicology, 2017, 4 :31-44
[42]   Chemical Safety Assessment Using Read-Across: Assessing the Use of Novel Testing Methods to Strengthen the Evidence Base for Decision Making [J].
Berggren, Elisabet ;
Amcoff, Patric ;
Benigni, Romualdo ;
Blackburn, Karen ;
Carney, Edward ;
Cronin, Mark ;
Deluyker, Hubert ;
Gautier, Francoise ;
Judson, Richard S. ;
Kass, Georges E. N. ;
Keller, Detlef ;
Knight, Derek ;
Lilienblum, Werner ;
Mahony, Catherine ;
Rusyn, Ivan ;
Schultz, Terry ;
Schwarz, Michael ;
Schueuermann, Gerrit ;
White, Andrew ;
Burton, Julien ;
Lostia, Alfonso M. ;
Munn, Sharon ;
Worth, Andrew .
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PERSPECTIVES, 2015, 123 (12) :1232-1240
[43]   Multicenter study of acetaminophen hepatotoxicity reveals the importance of biological endpoints in genomic analyses [J].
Beyer, Richard P. ;
Fry, Rebecca C. ;
Lasarev, Michael R. ;
McConnachie, Lisa A. ;
Meira, Lisiane B. ;
Palmer, Valerie S. ;
Powell, Christine L. ;
Ross, Pamela K. ;
Bammler, Theo K. ;
Bradford, Blair U. ;
Cranson, Alex B. ;
Cunningham, Michael L. ;
Fannin, Rickie D. ;
Higgins, Gregory M. ;
Hurban, Patrick ;
Kayton, Robert J. ;
Kerr, Kathleen F. ;
Kosyk, Oksana ;
Lobenhofer, Edward K. ;
Sieber, Stella O. ;
Vliet, Portia A. ;
Weis, Brenda K. ;
Wolfinger, Russel ;
Woods, Courtney G. ;
Freedman, Jonathan H. ;
Linney, Elwood ;
Kaufmann, William K. ;
Kavanagh, Terrance J. ;
Paules, Richard S. ;
Rusyn, Ivan ;
Samson, Leona D. ;
Spencer, Peter S. ;
Suk, William ;
Tennant, Raymond J. ;
Zarbl, Helmut .
TOXICOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2007, 99 (01) :326-337
[44]   Concordance of Transcriptional and Apical Benchmark Dose Levels for Conazole-Induced Liver Effects in Mice [J].
Bhat, Virunya S. ;
Hester, Susan D. ;
Nesnow, Stephen ;
Eastmond, David A. .
TOXICOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2013, 136 (01) :205-215
[45]   Modeling drug- and chemical-induced hepatotoxicity with systems biology approaches [J].
Bhattacharya, Sudin ;
Shoda, Lisl K. M. ;
Zhang, Qiang ;
Woods, Courtney G. ;
Howell, Brett A. ;
Siler, Scott Q. ;
Woodhead, Jeffrey L. ;
Yang, Yuching ;
McMullen, Patrick ;
Watkins, Paul B. ;
Andersen, Melvin E. .
FRONTIERS IN PHYSIOLOGY, 2012, 3
[46]   Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: Defining New Risk Assessment Approaches Based on Perturbation of Intracellular Toxicity Pathways [J].
Bhattacharya, Sudin ;
Zhang, Qiang ;
Carmichael, Paul L. ;
Boekelheide, Kim ;
Andersen, Melvin E. .
PLOS ONE, 2011, 6 (06)
[47]   Tissue architecture: the ultimate regulator of breast epithelial function - Commentary [J].
Bissell, MJ ;
Rizki, A ;
Mian, IS .
CURRENT OPINION IN CELL BIOLOGY, 2003, 15 (06) :753-762
[48]   BIOKINETIC MODELING AND IN VITRO-IN VIVO EXTRAPOLATIONS [J].
Blaauboer, Bas J. .
JOURNAL OF TOXICOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH-PART B-CRITICAL REVIEWS, 2010, 13 (2-4) :242-252
[49]   Comparison of Microarrays and RNA-Seq for Gene Expression Analyses of Dose-Response Experiments [J].
Black, Michael B. ;
Parks, Bethany B. ;
Pluta, Linda ;
Chu, Tzu-Ming ;
Allen, Bruce C. ;
Wolfinger, Russell D. ;
Thomas, Russell S. .
TOXICOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2014, 137 (02) :385-403
[50]   Automatic endpoint detection to support the systematic review process [J].
Blake, Catherine ;
Lucic, Ana .
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL INFORMATICS, 2015, 56 :42-56