Safety and Efficacy of Influenza Vaccination in Patients Receiving Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors. Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

被引:16
作者
Lopez-Olivo, Maria A. [1 ]
Valerio, Valeria [2 ]
Karpes Matusevich, Aliza R. [3 ]
Brizio, Marianela [4 ]
Kwok, Michelle [5 ]
Geng, Yimin [6 ]
Suarez-Almazor, Maria E. [1 ,7 ]
Colmegna, Ines [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Texas MD Anderson Canc Ctr, Dept Hlth Serv Res, Unit 1444, 1515 Holcombe Blvd, Houston, TX 77030 USA
[2] McGill Univ Hlth Ctr RI MUHC, Res Inst, Montreal, PQ, Canada
[3] Univ Texas Hlth Sci Ctr Houston, Sch Publ Hlth, Houston, TX 77030 USA
[4] McGill Univ, Div Expt Med, Montreal, PQ H4A 3J1, Canada
[5] McGill Univ, Dept Clin Immunol & Allergy, Hlth Ctr, Montreal, PQ, Canada
[6] Univ Texas MD Anderson Canc Ctr, Res Med Lib, Houston, TX 77030 USA
[7] Univ Texas MD Anderson Canc Ctr, Dept Gen Internal Med, Houston, TX 77030 USA
关键词
influenza vaccine; systematic review; meta-analysis; immune checkpoint inhibitors; cancer; ADVERSE EVENTS; CANCER-PATIENTS; IMMUNOTHERAPY; THERAPY; OUTCOMES; PD-1;
D O I
10.3390/vaccines10081195
中图分类号
R392 [医学免疫学]; Q939.91 [免疫学];
学科分类号
100102 ;
摘要
The potential increased risk of immune-related adverse events (irAEs) post-influenza vaccine is a concern in patients receiving immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI). We conducted a systematic review with meta-analysis of studies reporting the effects of influenza vaccination in patients with cancer during ICI treatment. We searched five electronic databases until 01/2022. Two authors independently selected studies, appraised their quality, and collected data. The primary outcome was the determination of pooled irAE rates. Secondary outcomes included determination of immunogenicity and influenza infection rates and cancer-related outcomes. Nineteen studies (26 publications, n = 4705) were included; 89.5% were observational. Vaccinated patients reported slighter lower rates of irAEs compared to unvaccinated patients (32% versus 41%, respectively). Seroprotection for influenza type A was 78%-79%, and for type B was 75%. Influenza and irAErelated death rates were similar between groups. The pooled proportion of participants reporting a laboratory-confirmed infection was 2% (95% CI 0% to 6%), and influenza-like illness was 14% (95% CI 2% to 32%). No differences were reported on the rates of laboratory-confirmed infection between vaccinated and unvaccinated patients. Longer progression-free and overall survival was also observed in vaccinated compared with unvaccinated patients. Current evidence suggests that influenza vaccination is safe in patients receiving ICIs, does not increase the risk of irAEs, and may improve survival.
引用
收藏
页数:17
相关论文
共 54 条
[1]   Flu vaccination rate of patients with severe immune-related adverse events. [J].
Allen, Ian Matthew ;
Murciano-Goroff, Yonina Robbie ;
Zubiri, Leyre ;
Li, Qun ;
Hughes, Michael Sang ;
Velimirovic, Marko ;
Chu, Jacqueline N. ;
Durbin, Sienna ;
Klauer, Matthew J. ;
Awadalla, Magid ;
Petrillo, Laura A. ;
Dougan, Michael ;
Letourneau, Alyssa R. ;
Mansour, Michael ;
Neilan, Tomas G. ;
Cohen, Justine Vanessa ;
Bardia, Aditya ;
Reynolds, Kerry Lynn .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2019, 37 (15)
[2]   Influenza vaccination and myocarditis among patients receiving immune checkpoint inhibitors [J].
Awadalla, Magid ;
Golden, Doll Lauren Alexandra ;
Mahmood, Syed S. ;
Alvi, Raza M. ;
Mercaldo, Nathaniel D. ;
Hassan, Malek Z. O. ;
Banerji, Dahlia ;
Rokicki, Adam ;
Mulligan, Connor ;
Murphy, Sean P. T. ;
Jones-O'Connor, Maeve ;
Cohen, Justine V. ;
Heinzerling, Lucie M. ;
Armanious, Merna ;
Sullivan, Ryan J. ;
Damrongwatanasuk, Rongras ;
Chen, Carol L. ;
Gupta, Dipti ;
Kirchberger, Michael C. ;
Moslehi, Javid J. ;
Shah, Sachin P. ;
Ganatra, Sarju ;
Thavendiranathan, Paaladinesh ;
Rizvi, Muhammad A. ;
Sahni, Gagan ;
Lyon, Alexander R. ;
Tocchetti, Carlo G. ;
Mercurio, Valentina ;
Thuny, Franck ;
Ederhy, Stephane ;
Mahmoudi, Michael ;
Lawrence, Donald P. ;
Groarke, John D. ;
Nohria, Anju ;
Fradley, Michael G. ;
Reynolds, Kerry L. ;
Neilan, Tomas G. .
JOURNAL FOR IMMUNOTHERAPY OF CANCER, 2019, 7
[3]   Immunogenicity and safety of influenza vaccination in cancer patients receiving checkpoint inhibitors targeting PD-1 or PD-L1 [J].
Bayle, A. ;
Khettab, M. ;
Lucibello, F. ;
Chamseddine, A. N. ;
Goldschmidt, V. ;
Perret, A. ;
Ropert, S. ;
Scotte, F. ;
Loulergue, P. ;
Mir, O. .
ANNALS OF ONCOLOGY, 2020, 31 (07) :959-961
[4]   Influenza-like illness and SARS-Cov-2 in the multicenter, prospective, observational INVIDIa-2 study (INfluenza Vaccine Indication During therapy with Immune checkpoint inhibitors: A transversal challenge): A FICOG study [J].
Bersanelli, M. ;
Giannarelli, D. ;
Verzoni, E. ;
Buti, S. ;
De Giorgi, U. ;
Clemente, A. ;
Filetti, M. ;
Di Napoli, M. ;
Calvetti, L. ;
Ermacora, P. ;
Catino, A. M. ;
Guaitoli, G. ;
Bonomo, P. ;
Mazzoni, F. ;
Veccia, A. ;
Grosso, F. ;
Maruzzo, M. ;
Rossi, E. ;
Grossi, F. ;
Procopio, G. .
ANNALS OF ONCOLOGY, 2020, 31 :S1209-S1209
[5]  
Bersanelli M., 2020, TUMORI J, V106, P1
[6]   INfluenza Vaccine Indication During therapy with Immune checkpoint inhibitors: a multicenter prospective observational study (INVIDIa-2) [J].
Bersanelli, Melissa ;
Giannarelli, Diana ;
De Giorgi, Ugo ;
Pignata, Sandro ;
Di Maio, Massimo ;
Clemente, Alberto ;
Verzoni, Elena ;
Giusti, Raffaele ;
Di Napoli, Marilena ;
Aprile, Giuseppe ;
Ermacora, Paola ;
Catino, Annamaria ;
Scotti, Vieri ;
Mazzoni, Francesca ;
Guglielmini, Pamela Francesca ;
Veccia, Antonello ;
Maruzzo, Marco ;
Rossi, Ernesto ;
Grossi, Francesco ;
Casadei, Chiara ;
Ficorella, Corrado ;
Montesarchio, Vincenzo ;
Verderame, Francesco ;
Rizzo, Mimma ;
Guaitoli, Giorgia ;
Fratino, Lucia ;
Accettura, Caterina ;
Mencoboni, Manlio ;
Zustovich, Fable ;
Baldessari, Cinzia ;
Cinieri, Saverio ;
Camerini, Andrea ;
Laera, Letizia ;
Soraru, Mariella ;
Zucali, Paolo Andrea ;
Guadalupi, Valentina ;
Leonardi, Francesco ;
Tiseo, Marcello ;
Tognetto, Michele ;
Di Costanzo, Francesco ;
Pinto, Carmine ;
Negrini, Giorgia ;
Russo, Antonio ;
Migliorino, Maria R. ;
Filetti, Marco ;
Buti, Sebastiano .
JOURNAL FOR IMMUNOTHERAPY OF CANCER, 2021, 9 (05)
[7]   Symptomatic COVID-19 in advanced-cancer patients treated with immune-checkpoint inhibitors: prospective analysis from a multicentre observational trial by FICOG [J].
Bersanelli, Melissa ;
Giannarelli, Diana ;
De Giorgi, Ugo ;
Pignata, Sandro ;
Di Maio, Massimo ;
Verzoni, Elena ;
Clemente, Alberto ;
Guadalupi, Valentina ;
Signorelli, Diego ;
Tiseo, Marcello ;
Giusti, Raffaele ;
Filetti, Marco ;
Di Napoli, Marilena ;
Calvetti, Lorenzo ;
Cappetta, Alessandro ;
Ermacora, Paola ;
Zara, Diego ;
Barbieri, Fausto ;
Baldessari, Cinzia ;
Scotti, Vieri ;
Mazzoni, Francesca ;
Veccia, Antonello ;
Guglielmini, Pamela Francesca ;
Maruzzo, Marco ;
Rossi, Ernesto ;
Grossi, Francesco ;
Casadei, Chiara ;
Cortellini, Alessio ;
Verderame, Francesco ;
Montesarchio, Vincenzo ;
Rizzo, Mimma ;
Mencoboni, Manlio ;
Zustovich, Fable ;
Fratino, Lucia ;
Cinieri, Saverio ;
Negrini, Giorgia ;
Banzi, Maria ;
Soraru, Mariella ;
Zucali, Paolo Andrea ;
Lacidogna, Gaetano ;
Russo, Antonio ;
Battelli, Nicola ;
Fornarini, Giuseppe ;
Mucciarini, Claudia ;
Bracarda, Sergio ;
Bonetti, Andrea ;
Pezzuolo, Debora ;
Longo, Lucia ;
Sartori, Donata ;
Iannopollo, Mauro .
THERAPEUTIC ADVANCES IN MEDICAL ONCOLOGY, 2020, 12
[8]   Impact of influenza syndrome and flu vaccine on survival of cancer patients during immunotherapy in the INVIDIa study [J].
Bersanelli, Melissa ;
Buti, Sebastiano ;
Banna, Giuseppe Luigi ;
De Giorgi, Ugo ;
Cortellini, Alessio ;
Rebuzzi, Sara Elena ;
Tiseo, Marcello ;
Fornarini, Giuseppe ;
Mazzoni, Francesca ;
Panni, Stefano ;
De Tursi, Michele ;
Di Marino, Pietro ;
Rossetti, Sabrina ;
Rossi, Ernesto ;
Tomao, Silverio ;
De Luca, Emmanuele ;
Soraru, Mariella ;
Mucciarini, Claudia ;
Atzori, Francesco ;
La Torre, Leonardo ;
Vitale, Maria Giuseppa ;
Martelli, Valentino ;
Sepe, Pierangela ;
Mollica, Veronica ;
Vaccaro, Vanja ;
Schinzari, Giovanni ;
Ficorella, Corrado ;
Massari, Francesco ;
Maestri, Antonio ;
Sabbatini, Roberto ;
Sava, Teodoro ;
Di Maio, Massimo ;
Verzoni, Elena ;
Procopio, Giuseppe ;
Giannarelli, Diana .
IMMUNOTHERAPY, 2020, 12 (02) :151-159
[9]   State of the art about influenza vaccination for advanced cancer patients receiving immune checkpoint inhibitors: When common sense is not enough [J].
Bersanelli, Melissa ;
Buti, Sebastiano ;
De Giorgi, Ugo ;
Di Maio, Massimo ;
Giannarelli, Diana ;
Pignata, Sandro ;
Banna, Giuseppe Luigi .
CRITICAL REVIEWS IN ONCOLOGY HEMATOLOGY, 2019, 139 :87-90
[10]   INfluenza Vaccine Indication During therapy with Immune checkpoint inhibitors: a transversal challenge. The INVIDIa study [J].
Bersanelli, Melissa ;
Giannarelli, Diana ;
Castrignano, Paola ;
Fornarini, Giuseppe ;
Panni, Stefano ;
Mazzoni, Francesca ;
Tiseo, Marcello ;
Rossetti, Sabrina ;
Gambale, Elisabetta ;
Rossi, Ernesto ;
Papa, Anselmo ;
Cortellini, Alessio ;
Lolli, Cristian ;
Ratta, Raffaele ;
Michiara, Maria ;
Milella, Michele ;
De Luca, Emmanuele ;
Soraru, Mariella ;
Mucciarini, Claudia ;
Atzori, Francesco ;
Banna, Giuseppe L. ;
La Torre, Leonardo ;
Vitale, Maria G. ;
Massari, Francesco ;
Rebuzzi, Sara E. ;
Facchini, Gaetano ;
Schinzari, Giovanni ;
Tomao, Silverio ;
Bui, Simona ;
Vaccaro, Vanja ;
Procopio, Giuseppe ;
De Giorgi, Ugo ;
Santoni, Matteo ;
Ficorella, Corrado ;
Sabbatini, Roberto ;
Maestri, Antonio ;
Natoli, Clara ;
De Tursi, Michele ;
Di Maio, Massimo ;
Rapacchi, Elena ;
Pireddu, Annagrazia ;
Sava, Teodoro ;
Lipari, Helga ;
Comito, Francesca ;
Verzoni, Elena ;
Leonardi, Francesco ;
Buti, Sebastiano .
IMMUNOTHERAPY, 2018, 10 (14) :1229-1239