Scaphoid Fractures in Children Do We Need to X-ray? A Retrospective Chart Review of 144 Wrists

Objectives The purpose of this study is to determine the predictive value of clinical suspicion for scaphoid fracture in children aged 4 to 11 years, to look at the efficiency and practicality of current management of children presenting to the emergency department, and to help quantify the burden of the treatment strategy of immobilization for 10 to 14 days on clinical grounds despite negative or equivocal x-rays on presentation. Methods We performed a retrospective chart review study of a consecutive sample of all children aged 4 to 11 years old who presented to a tertiary pediatric emergency department from January 1, 2009, to December 31, 2013, within 24 hours of a wrist injury, with a clinical suspicion sufficient to order a scaphoid x-ray. Our primary outcome of interest was the positive predictive value of clinical suspicion of a scaphoid fracture. Results There were 142 patients (144 wrists) included in the study. Of these, 110 had a normal initial x-ray. Initial x-rays showed evidence of nonscaphoid fractures in 30 wrists and equivocal scaphoid fractures in 4 wrists. Of the 110 wrists with normal initial x-rays, 69 were immobilized and 52 of those had a follow-up x-ray (47 normal, 1 scaphoid fracture, 1 nonscaphoid fracture, and 3 equivocal evidence of a scaphoid fracture). The positive predictive value was found to be 2.1% to 12.5%. Conclusions This study suggests that children aged 4 to 11 years with clinical suspicion for scaphoid fractures do not necessarily need to be x-rayed or immobilized. A larger multicentered prospective clinical trial would confirm this.