Transcranial magnetic stimulation distinguishes Alzheimer disease from frontotemporal dementia

被引:88
作者
Benussi, Alberto [1 ]
Di Lorenzo, Francesco [2 ]
Dell'Era, Valentina [1 ]
Cosseddu, Maura [1 ]
Alberici, Antonella [1 ]
Caratozzolo, Salvatore [1 ]
Cotelli, Maria Sofia [4 ]
Micheli, Anna [5 ]
Rozzini, Luca [1 ]
Depari, Alessandro [6 ]
Flammini, Alessandra [6 ]
Ponzo, Viviana [2 ]
Martorana, Alessandro [2 ,7 ]
Caltagirone, Carlo [2 ,7 ]
Padovani, Alessandro [1 ]
Koch, Giacomo [2 ,3 ]
Borroni, Barbara [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Brescia, Dept Clin & Expt Sci, Neurol Unit, Brescia, Italy
[2] IRCCS Santa Lucia Fdn, Noninvas Brain Stimulat Unit, Rome, Italy
[3] Policlin Tor Vergata, Stroke Unit, Rome, Italy
[4] Valle Camon Hosp, Neurol Unit, Brescia, Italy
[5] Casa Cura San Francesco, Bergamo, Italy
[6] Univ Brescia, Dipartimento Ingn Informaz, Brescia, Italy
[7] Univ Tor Vergata, Dept Syst Med, Neurol Unit, Rome, Italy
关键词
HUMAN MOTOR CORTEX; INTRACORTICAL INHIBITION; DIAGNOSTIC-CRITERIA; CORTICAL PLASTICITY; PATHOLOGY; PET; PRESENTATIONS; BIOMARKER; CIRCUITS; BRAIN;
D O I
10.1212/WNL.0000000000004232
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective: To determine whether a transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) multiparadigm approach can be used to distinguish Alzheimer disease (AD) from frontotemporal dementia (FTD). Methods: Paired-pulse TMS was used to investigate short-interval intracortical inhibition (SICI) and facilitation (ICF), long-interval intracortical inhibition, and short-latency afferent inhibition (SAI) to measure the activity of different intracortical circuits in patients with AD, patients with FTD, and healthy controls (HC). The primary outcome measures were sensitivity and specificity of TMS measures, derived from receiver operating curve analysis. Results: A total of 175 participants met the inclusion criteria. We diagnosed 79 patients with AD, 64 patients with FTD, and 32 HC. We found that while patients with AD are characterized by a specific impairment of SAI, FTD shows a remarkable dysfunction of SICI-ICF intracortical circuits. With the use of the best indexes, TMS differentiated FTD from AD with a sensitivity of 91.8% and specificity of 88.6%, AD from HC with a sensitivity of 84.8% and specificity of 90.6%, and FTD from HC with a sensitivity of 90.2% and specificity of 78.1%. These results were confirmed in patients with mild disease. Conclusions: TMS is a noninvasive procedure that reliably distinguishes AD from FTD and HC and, if these findings are replicated in larger studies, could represent a useful additional diagnostic tool for clinical practice. Classification of evidence: This study provides Class III evidence that TMS measures can distinguish patients with AD from those with FTD.
引用
收藏
页码:665 / 672
页数:8
相关论文
共 40 条
[1]   Focal cortical presentations of Alzheimer's disease [J].
Alladi, S. ;
Xuereb, J. ;
Bak, T. ;
Nestor, P. ;
Knibb, J. ;
Patterson, K. ;
Hodges, J. R. .
BRAIN, 2007, 130 :2636-2645
[2]  
Benussi A, JIMD REP
[3]   Impaired long-term potentiation-like cortical plasticity in presymptomatic genetic frontotemporal dementia [J].
Benussi, Alberto ;
Cosseddu, Maura ;
Filareto, Ilaria ;
Dell'Era, Valentina ;
Archetti, Silvana ;
Cotelli, Maria Sofia ;
Micheli, Anna ;
Padovani, Alessandro ;
Borroni, Barbara .
ANNALS OF NEUROLOGY, 2016, 80 (03) :472-476
[4]   Assessment of the Incremental Diagnostic Value of Florbetapir F 18 Imaging in Patients With Cognitive Impairment The Incremental Diagnostic Value of Amyloid PET With [18F]-Florbetapir (INDIA-FBP) Study [J].
Boccardi, Marina ;
Altomare, Daniele ;
Ferrari, Clarissa ;
Festari, Cristina ;
Guerra, Ugo Paolo ;
Paghera, Barbara ;
Pizzocaro, Claudio ;
Lussignoli, Giulia ;
Geroldi, Cristina ;
Zanetti, Orazio ;
Cotelli, Maria Sofia ;
Turla, Marinella ;
Borroni, Barbara ;
Rozzini, Luca ;
Mirabile, Dario ;
Defanti, Carlo ;
Gennuso, Michele ;
Prelle, Alessandro ;
Gentile, Simona ;
Morandi, Alessandro ;
Vollaro, Stefano ;
Dalla Volta, Giorgio ;
Bianchetti, Angelo ;
Conti, Marta Zaffira ;
Cappuccio, Melania ;
Carbone, Pasqualina ;
Bellandi, Daniele ;
Abruzzi, Luciano ;
Bettoni, Luigi ;
Villani, Daniele ;
Raimondi, Maria Clara ;
Lanari, Alessia ;
Ciccone, Alfonso ;
Facchi, Emanuela ;
Di Fazio, Ignazio ;
Rozzini, Renzo ;
Boffelli, Stefano ;
Manzoni, Laura ;
Salvi, Giovanni Pietro ;
Cavaliere, Sabina ;
Belotti, Gloria ;
Avanzi, Stefano ;
Pasqualetti, Patrizio ;
Muscio, Cristina ;
Padovani, Alessandro ;
Frisoni, Giovanni B. .
JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2016, 73 (12) :1417-1424
[5]   Csf p-tau181/tau ratio as biomarker for TDP pathology in frontotemporal dementia [J].
Borroni, Barbara ;
Benussi, Alberto ;
Archetti, Silvana ;
Galimberti, Daniela ;
Parnetti, Lucilla ;
Nacmias, Benedetta ;
Sorbi, Sandro ;
Scarpini, Elio ;
Padovani, Alessandro .
AMYOTROPHIC LATERAL SCLEROSIS AND FRONTOTEMPORAL DEGENERATION, 2015, 16 (1-2) :86-91
[6]   Motor Neuron dysfunction in frontotemporal dementia [J].
Burrell, James R. ;
Kiernan, Matthew C. ;
Vucic, Steve ;
Hodges, John R. .
BRAIN, 2011, 134 :2582-2594
[7]  
Clark CM, 2012, LANCET NEUROL, V11, P669, DOI 10.1016/S1474-4422(12)70142-4
[8]   Use of Florbetapir-PET for Imaging β-Amyloid Pathology [J].
Clark, Christopher M. ;
Schneider, Julie A. ;
Bedell, Barry J. ;
Beach, Thomas G. ;
Bilker, Warren B. ;
Mintun, Mark A. ;
Pontecorvo, Michael J. ;
Hefti, Franz ;
Carpenter, Alan P. ;
Flitter, Matthew L. ;
Krautkramer, Michael J. ;
Kung, Hank F. ;
Coleman, R. Edward ;
Doraiswamy, P. Murali ;
Fleisher, Adam S. ;
Sabbagh, Marwan N. ;
Sadowsky, Carl H. ;
Reiman, P. Eric M. ;
Zehntner, Simone P. ;
Skovronsky, Daniel M. .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2011, 305 (03) :275-283
[9]   Cerebrospinal fluid biomarkers in the differential diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease from other cortical dementias [J].
de Souza, Leonardo Cruz ;
Lamari, Foudil ;
Belliard, Serge ;
Jardel, Claude ;
Houillier, Caroline ;
De Paz, Raphael ;
Dubois, Bruno ;
Sarazin, Marie .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2011, 82 (03) :240-246
[10]   In vivo cholinergic circuit evaluation in frontotemporal and Alzheimer dementias [J].
Di Lazzaro, V ;
Pilato, F ;
Dileone, M ;
Saturno, E ;
Oliviero, A ;
Marra, C ;
Daniele, A ;
Ranieri, F ;
Gainotti, G ;
Tonali, PA .
NEUROLOGY, 2006, 66 (07) :1111-1113