Comparative effectiveness and safety of posterior lumbar interbody fusion, Coflex, Wallis, and X-stop for lumbar degenerative diseases: A systematic review and network meta-analysis

被引:25
作者
Mo, Zhuomao [1 ]
Li, Dong [1 ]
Zhang, Renwen [1 ]
Chang, Minmin [1 ]
Yang, Binbin [1 ]
Tang, Shujie [1 ]
机构
[1] Jinan Univ, Sch Chinese Med, Guangzhou 510632, Guangdong, Peoples R China
关键词
Posterior lumbar interbody fusion; Coflex; Wallis; X-stop; Network meta-analysis; SPINAL STENOSIS; INTERSPINAL IMPLANTS; INTRADISCAL PRESSURE; INSTRUMENTATION; DECOMPRESSION; INSTABILITY; SPACERS;
D O I
10.1016/j.clineuro.2018.06.030
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Posterior lumbar interbody fusion and lumbar interspinous non-fusion technique are common surgical procedures for lumbar degenerative diseases, but the effectiveness and safety of these two techniques are still unclear. We performed this network meta-analysis to evaluate the comparative effectiveness and safety of posterior lumbar interbody fusion and the three commonly used interspinous devices including Coflex, Wallis, and X-stop for lumbar degenerative diseases. Randomized controlled trials and cohort studies comparing among posterior lumbar interbody fusion, Cofiex, Wallis, and X-stop for lumbar degenerative diseases were identified using the databases including PubMed, the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, the China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Chinese Science and Technology Periodical Database, and Wanfang data. A network meta-analysis was performed using R 3.4.3 software. 27 studies with 2241 patients were included. The results of network meta-analysis revealed that no significant differences in Oswestry Disability Index, Visual Analogue Scale, Japanese Orthopedic Association Scores, and posterior disc height were found among posterior lumbar interbody fusion group, Cofiex, Wallis, or X-stop. However, compared with posterior lumbar interbody fusion, the three interspinous process devices presented with significantly more range of motion in surgical segment, but no significant difference was found among these three interspinous process devices. Node-splitting analysis showed no significant inconsistency in our network meta-analysis. We concluded that compared with posterior lumbar interbody fusion, Coflex, Wallis and X-stop had the same effectiveness in relieving pain, improving quality of life, recovering disc space height and lumbar function, but may lower incidence of adjacent segment degeneration.
引用
收藏
页码:74 / 81
页数:8
相关论文
共 47 条
  • [1] Ba Y. W., 2014, CONTRAST CLIN APPL W
  • [2] General methods for monitoring convergence of iterative simulations
    Brooks, SP
    Gelman, A
    [J]. JOURNAL OF COMPUTATIONAL AND GRAPHICAL STATISTICS, 1998, 7 (04) : 434 - 455
  • [3] Interspinous spacers versus posterior lumbar interbody fusion for degenerative lumbar spinal diseases: a meta-analysis of prospective studies
    Cai, Yifeng
    Luo, Jiaquan
    Huang, Junjun
    Lian, Chengjie
    Zhou, Hang
    Yao, Hao
    Su, Peiqiang
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL ORTHOPAEDICS, 2016, 40 (06) : 1135 - 1142
  • [4] Chen ZhaoHui Chen ZhaoHui, 2010, Zhongguo Jiaoxing Waike Zazhi / Orthopedic Journal of China, V18, P629
  • [5] Decompression and Coflex Interlaminar Stabilization Compared With Decompression and Instrumented Spinal Fusion for Spinal Stenosis and Low-Grade Degenerative Spondylolisthesis Two-Year Results From the Prospective, Randomized, Multicenter, Food and Drug Administration Investigational Device Exemption Trial
    Davis, Reginald J.
    Errico, Thomas J.
    Bae, Hyun
    Auerbach, Joshua D.
    [J]. SPINE, 2013, 38 (18) : 1529 - 1539
  • [6] Checking consistency in mixed treatment comparison meta-analysis
    Dias, S.
    Welton, N. J.
    Caldwell, D. M.
    Ades, A. E.
    [J]. STATISTICS IN MEDICINE, 2010, 29 (7-8) : 932 - 944
  • [7] Du Fang-Tao, 2011, Zhongguo Gu Shang, V24, P291
  • [8] Risk factors for adjacent-segment failure following lumbar fixation with rigid instrumentation for degenerative instability
    Etebar, S
    Cahill, DW
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROSURGERY, 1999, 90 (04) : 163 - 169
  • [9] Interspinous spacers in the treatment of degenerative lumbar spinal disease: our experience with DIAM and Aperius devices
    Fabrizi, Antonio P.
    Maina, Raffaella
    Schiabello, Luigi
    [J]. EUROPEAN SPINE JOURNAL, 2011, 20 : 20 - 26
  • [10] Gao D, 2011, CLIN MED CHINA, V27, P631