Can the conformation of flexible hydroxyl groups be constrained by simple NMR crystallography approaches? The case of the quercetin solid forms

Hydrogen atoms in systems with many flexible hydroxyl side-groups are difficult to be exactly located from experimental X-Ray diffraction and/or solid-state NMR data, thus often leading to wrong conclusions with respect to the hydrogen bonding network established in crystal lattice. A simple computational method is proposed in the present work to tackle this problem, which may be readily incorporated in conventional NMR crystallography protocols. The method is based on ranking all possible conformations of the flexible hydroxyls according to their lattice energy in crystalline environments, Its effectiveness is investigated on two distinct solid forms of quercetin, for which only two out of the five hydroxyl side-groups can be well constrained from experimental/theoretical data For this purpose, first-principle quantum-mechanical computations were combined with calculations at the molecular mechanics (MM) level of theory, and previous ss-NMR and X-Ray diffraction data To assess accuracy in ranking the identified conformers, tests have been performed first on ciuercetin clihydrate, for which an X-Ray single-crystal structure is available. The possibility of applying this method in a real NMR crystallography context has been investigated finally on anhydrous quercetin, for which only powder X-Ray crystal structure has been reported so far. (C) 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved