Investigation on the microscopic damage mechanism of fracturing fluids to low-permeability sandstone oil reservoir by nuclear magnetic resonance

Hydraulic fracturing has become an essential stimulation treatment for improving the development efficiency of low-permeability oil reservoirs. However, fracturing fluid inevitably causes reservoir damage. This study proposed a combined method of microscopic and macroscopic experiments to investigate the nature of formation damage of fracturing fluid by quantifying its influence on porosity, permeability, and pore structure. Nuclear magnetic resonance technology combined with core flooding test and parallel sample comparison method was applied to quantitatively evaluate the damage degree and identify the main damage types of hydroxypropyl guar (HPG) fracturing fluid and slickwater fracturing fluid. The microscopic damage mechanisms of these fracturing fluids were analyzed by thin section petrography, X-ray diffraction, rate-controlled mercury intrusion, scanning electron microscopy, and wettability tests. The results show that the total permeability damage degree of HPG fracturing fluid filtrate is 30.43%, of which water sensitivity, water lock, and macromolecule adsorption account for 6.06%, 23.26%, and 1.11%, respectively. Water lock is the major damage factor. Regarding the damage of slickwater fracturing fluid filtrate, water sensitivity causes the severest damage, corresponding to 39.08% of core permeability loss, whereas macromolecule adsorption and water lock contribute 13.21% and 0.97%, respectively. Water sensitivity damage causes reduced porosity, decreased permeability, and narrower pores, resulting from hydration, swelling, dispersion and migration of clay minerals. Water lock damage increases the movable pore volume, decreases the permeability, increases the pore radius, decreases the throat radius, and increases the pore throat ratio, which increases the flow resistance to the oil phase. The magnitude of water lock damage is closely related to the surfactant content and performance, rock wettability, and pore throat radius ratio. Macromolecule adsorption damage leads to a decrease in permeability, a reduction in the number of large pores, an increase in the number of small throats, and an increase in the pore throat radius ratio due to the absorption and retention of macromolecules on the surfaces of the pores and throats. Increasing the flowback volume of slickwater fracturing fluid can recover part of the macromolecule absorption damage. This research can provide a reliable reference for the optimization of fracturing fluid performance, enhancement of the fracturing effect and reservoir protection of low-permeability reservoirs.