Democracy Unchained: Contractualism, Individualism, and Independence in Buchanan's Democratic Theory

Contrary to the claims of some of his critics, James Buchanan was an ardent democrat. I argue that Buchanan's conception of democratic governance organized by a contractually justified constitution is highly distinctive because of his commitment to a strong conception of individualism. For Buchanan, democracy is neither justified instrumentally-by the goods it generates-nor by reference to some antecedent conception of justice. Instead, democracy is the only political option for a society that takes individualism seriously. One implication of this view is that democracies can only be limited by the rules they collectively give themselves in the form of constitutions. I explicate this conception of democracy and address some of its implications, assumptions, and challenges.