Evidence-based treatments for depression and anxiety versus treatment-as-usual: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons

被引:91
作者
Wampold, Bruce E. [1 ]
Budge, Stephanie L. [2 ]
Laska, Kevin M.
Del Re, A. C. [3 ,4 ]
Baardseth, Timothy P.
Fluckiger, Christoph [5 ]
Minami, Takuya
Kivlighan, D. Martin, II
Gunn, Wade
机构
[1] Univ Wisconsin, Dept Counseling Psychol, Madison, WI 53706 USA
[2] Univ Louisville, Louisville, KY 40292 USA
[3] VA Palo Alto Hlth Care Syst, Palo Alto, CA USA
[4] Stanford Univ, Sch Med, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
[5] Univ Bern, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland
关键词
Evidence-based treatments; Meta-analysis; Treatment-as-usual; Anxiety; Depression; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED-TRIAL; COGNITIVE-BEHAVIOR THERAPY; INTERPERSONAL PSYCHOTHERAPY; PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENT; MINORITY WOMEN; LOW-INCOME; CARE; DISORDER; EFFICACY; PTSD;
D O I
10.1016/j.cpr.2011.07.012
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Objective: The aim of this study was to examine the relative efficacy of evidence-based treatments (EBTs) versus treatment-as-usual (TAU) in routine care for anxiety and depression in adults. Method: A computerized search of studies that directly compared an EBT with a TAU was conducted. Meta-analytic methods were used to estimate effectiveness of EBTs relative to TAU and to model how various confounding variables impacted the results of this comparative research. Results: A total of 14 studies were included in the final meta-analysis. There was significant heterogeneity in the TAU conditions, which ranged from unknown and/or minimal mental health treatment to psychotherapeutic interventions provided by trained professionals. Although the effect for EBT vs. TAU was significantly greater than zero, the effect for EBT vs. TAUs that were psychotherapeutic interventions was not statistically different from zero. Conclusions: Heterogeneity of TAU conditions in this meta-analysis highlight the importance of clarifying the research questions being asked when investigating and drawing conclusions from EBT-TAU comparisons. Researchers need to clarify if they are comparing an EBT to psychotherapeutic services in routine care or to minimal mental health services. Extant research on EBT versus TAU reveals that there is insufficient evidence to recommend the transportation of EBTs for anxiety and depression to routine care, particularly when the routine care involves psychotherapeutic services. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:1304 / 1312
页数:9
相关论文
共 40 条
[1]   Effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral treatment for panic disorder versus treatment as usual in a managed care setting [J].
Addis, ME ;
Hatgis, C ;
Krasnow, AD ;
Jacob, K ;
Bourne, L ;
Mansfield, A .
JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2004, 72 (04) :625-635
[2]  
[Anonymous], 2009, HDB RES SYNTHESIS ME
[3]  
[Anonymous], 1995, CLIN PSYCHOL-UK, V48, P2
[4]  
[Anonymous], 2010, MAD METAANALYSIS MEA
[5]   Treatment and prevention of depression after surgery for hip fracture in older people: Randomized, controlled trials [J].
Burns, Alistair ;
Banerjee, Sube ;
Morris, Julie ;
Woodward, Yvonne ;
Baldwin, Robert ;
Proctor, Rebekah ;
Tarrier, Nicholas ;
Pendleton, Neil ;
Sutherland, Deborah ;
Andrew, Glynne ;
Horan, Mike .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY, 2007, 55 (01) :75-80
[6]   Defining empirically supported therapies [J].
Chambless, DL ;
Hollon, SD .
JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1998, 66 (01) :7-18
[7]   Psychological treatment outcomes in routine NHS services: a commentary on Stiles et al. (2007) [J].
Clark, D. M. ;
Fairburn, C. G. ;
Wessely, S. .
PSYCHOLOGICAL MEDICINE, 2008, 38 (05) :629-634
[8]   Examining differential effects of psychological treatment of depressive disorder: An application of trajectory analyses [J].
Cuijpers, P ;
van Lier, PAC ;
van Straten, A ;
Donker, M .
JOURNAL OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS, 2005, 89 (1-3) :137-146
[9]   A randomized controlled clinical treatment trial for World Trade Center attack-related PTSD in disaster workers [J].
Difede, JoAnn ;
Malta, Loretta S. ;
Best, Suzanne ;
Henn-Haase, Clare ;
Metzler, Thomas ;
Bryant, Richard ;
Marmar, Charles .
JOURNAL OF NERVOUS AND MENTAL DISEASE, 2007, 195 (10) :861-865
[10]   Treating low-income and minority women with posttraumatic stress disorder - A pilot study comparing prolonged exposure and treatment as usual conducted by community therapists [J].
Feske, Ulrike .
JOURNAL OF INTERPERSONAL VIOLENCE, 2008, 23 (08) :1027-1040