The neglected impact of tracking devices on terrestrial arthropods

被引:47
作者
Batsleer, Femke [1 ]
Bonte, Dries [1 ]
Dekeukeleire, Daan [1 ]
Goossens, Steven [1 ]
Poelmans, Ward [1 ]
Van der Cruyssen, Eliane [1 ]
Maes, Dirk [2 ]
Vandegehuchte, Martijn L. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Ghent, Dept Biol, Terr Ecol Unit, Ghent, Belgium
[2] Res Inst Nat & Forest INBO, Species Divers Grp, Brussels, Belgium
来源
METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION | 2020年 / 11卷 / 03期
基金
比利时弗兰德研究基金会;
关键词
Bembix rostrata; harmonic radar; insect; invertebrate; non-target effect; radio telemetry; radio frequency identification; tag; RADAR TAG ATTACHMENT; HARMONIC RADAR; OSMODERMA-EREMITA; HONEY-BEES; DISPERSAL; TELEMETRY; BEHAVIOR; FLIGHT; SIZE; WEIGHT;
D O I
10.1111/2041-210X.13356
中图分类号
Q14 [生态学(生物生态学)];
学科分类号
071012 ; 0713 ;
摘要
Tracking devices have become small enough to be widely applied to arthropods to study their movement. However, possible side effects of these devices on arthropod performance and behaviour are rarely considered. We performed a systematic review of 173 papers about research in which tracking devices-radio frequency identification (RFID), harmonic radar and radio telemetry tags-were attached to terrestrial arthropods. The impact of such tags was quantified in only 12% of the papers, while in 40% the potential impact was completely disregarded. Often-cited rules of thumb for determining appropriate tag weight had either no empirical basis or were misconstrued. Several properties of a tracking device (e.g. weight, balance, size, drag) can affect different aspects of an arthropod's life history (e.g. energy, movement, foraging, mating). The impact can differ among species and environments. Taken together, these tag effects can influence the reliability of obtained movement data and conclusions drawn from them. We argue that the impact of tracking devices on arthropods should be quantified for each (a) study species, (b) tag type, and (c) environmental context. As an example, we include a low-effort impact study of the effect of an RFID tag on a digger wasp. Technological advancements enable studying the movement of arthropods in unprecedented detail. However, we should adopt a more critical attitude towards the use of tracking devices on terrestrial arthropods. The benefits of tracking devices should be balanced against their potential side effects on arthropods and on the reliability of the resulting data.
引用
收藏
页码:350 / 361
页数:12
相关论文
共 75 条
[1]   LOAD CARRYING AND MANEUVERABILITY IN AN INSECTIVOROUS BAT - A TEST OF THE 5-PERCENT RULE OF RADIO-TELEMETRY [J].
ALDRIDGE, HDJN ;
BRIGHAM, RM .
JOURNAL OF MAMMALOGY, 1988, 69 (02) :379-382
[2]  
[Anonymous], 2000, MANUAL WILDLIFE RADI
[3]   Are solitary progressive-provisioning wasps optimal foragers? A study with the digger wasp Bembix merceti (Hymenoptera: Crabronidae) [J].
Asis, J. D. ;
Banos-Picon, L. ;
Tormos, J. ;
Ballesteros, Y. ;
Alonso, M. ;
Gayubo, S. F. .
BEHAVIOUR, 2011, 148 (02) :191-214
[4]   Meta-analysis of transmitter effects on avian behaviour and ecology [J].
Barron, Douglas G. ;
Brawn, Jeffrey D. ;
Weatherhead, Patrick J. .
METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION, 2010, 1 (02) :180-187
[5]   Systematic reviews and maps as tools for applying behavioral ecology to management and policy [J].
Berger-Tal, Oded ;
Greggor, Alison L. ;
Macura, Biljana ;
Adams, Carrie Ann ;
Blumenthal, Arden ;
Bouskila, Amos ;
Candolin, Ulrika ;
Doran, Carolina ;
Fernandez-Juricic, Esteban ;
Gotanda, Kiyoko M. ;
Price, Catherine ;
Putman, Breanna J. ;
Segoli, Michal ;
Snijders, Lysanne ;
Wong, Bob B. M. ;
Blumstein, Daniel T. .
BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY, 2019, 30 (01) :1-8
[6]   A phylogenetically controlled meta-analysis of biologging device effects on birds: Deleterious effects and a call for more standardized reporting of study data [J].
Bodey, Thomas W. ;
Cleasby, Ian R. ;
Bell, Fraser ;
Parr, Nicole ;
Schultz, Anthony ;
Votier, Stephen C. ;
Bearhop, Stuart .
METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION, 2018, 9 (04) :946-955
[7]   The potential of portable harmonic radar technology for the tracking of beneficial insects [J].
Boiteau, G ;
Colpitts, B .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PEST MANAGEMENT, 2004, 50 (03) :233-242
[8]   Evaluation of Tag Entanglement as a Factor in Harmonic Radar Studies of Insect Dispersal [J].
Boiteau, G. ;
Vincent, C. ;
Meloche, F. ;
Leskey, T. C. ;
Colpitts, B. G. .
ENVIRONMENTAL ENTOMOLOGY, 2011, 40 (01) :94-102
[9]   Harmonic Radar: Assessing the Impact of Tag Weight on Walking Activity of Colorado Potato Beetle, Plum Curculio, and Western Corn Rootworm [J].
Boiteau, G. ;
Vincent, C. ;
Meloche, F. ;
Leskey, T. C. .
JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ENTOMOLOGY, 2010, 103 (01) :63-69
[10]   Effectiveness of Glues Used for Harmonic Radar Tag Attachment and Impact on Survival and Behavior of Three Insect Pests [J].
Boiteau, G. ;
Meloche, F. ;
Vincent, C. ;
Leskey, T. C. .
ENVIRONMENTAL ENTOMOLOGY, 2009, 38 (01) :168-175