Bring a map when exploring the ERP data processing multiverse: A commentary on Clayson et al. 2021

被引：8

作者：

Feuerriegel, Daniel ^{[1
,2
]}

Bode, Stefan ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Melbourne, Melbourne Sch Psychol Sci, Melbourne, Australia

[2] Univ Melbourne, Melbourne Sch Psychol Sci, Redmond Barry Bldg, Melbourne 3010, Australia

来源：

NEUROIMAGE | 2022年 / 259卷

关键词：

Electroencephalography; EEG; Event -related potentials; ERPs; Error -related negativity; Error positivity; Multiverse analyses; ERROR-RELATED NEGATIVITY; DECISIONS;

D O I：

10.1016/j.neuroimage.2022.119443

中图分类号：

Q189 [神经科学];

学科分类号：

071006 ;

摘要：

Clayson et al. (2021) describe an innovative multiverse analysis to evaluate effects of data processing choices on event-related potential (ERP) measures. Based on their results, they provide data processing recommendations for studies measuring the error-related negativity and error positivity components. We argue that, although their data-driven approach is useful for identifying how data processing choices influence ERP results, it is not sufficient for devising optimal data processing pipelines. As an example, we focus on the inappropriate use of pre-response ERP baselines in their analyses, which leads to biased error positivity amplitude measures. Results of multiverse analyses should be supplemented with further investigation into why differences in ERP results occur across data processing choices before devising general recommendations.

引用

页数：5

共 19 条

[1] How much baseline correction do we need in ERP research? Extended GLM model can replace baseline correction while lifting its limits [J].

Alday, Phillip M. .

PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGY, 2019, 56 (12)

[2] Predicting errors from patterns of event-related potentials preceding an overt response [J].

Bode, Stefan ;

Stahl, Jutta .

BIOLOGICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2014, 103 :357-369

[3] The data-processing multiverse of event-related potentials (ERPs): A roadmap for the optimization and standardization of ERP processing and reduction pipelines [J].

Clayson, Peter E. ;

Baldwin, Scott A. ;

Rocha, Harold A. ;

Larson, Michael J. .

NEUROIMAGE, 2021, 245

[4] EFFECTS OF CROSSMODAL DIVIDED ATTENTION ON LATE ERP COMPONENTS .2. ERROR PROCESSING IN CHOICE REACTION TASKS [J].

FALKENSTEIN, M ;

HOHNSBEIN, J ;

HOORMANN, J ;

BLANKE, L .

ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY AND CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 1991, 78 (06) :447-455

[5]

Feuerriegel DC, 2021, bioRxiv, DOI [10.1101/2021.11.22.469610, 10.1101/2021.11.22.469610, DOI 10.1101/2021.11.22.469610]

[6] Tracking dynamic adjustments to decision making and performance monitoring processes in conflict tasks [J].

Feuerriegel, Daniel ;

Jiwa, Matthew ;

Turner, William F. ;

Andrejevic, Milan ;

Hester, Robert ;

Bode, Stefan .

NEUROIMAGE, 2021, 238

[7] A NEURAL SYSTEM FOR ERROR-DETECTION AND COMPENSATION [J].

GEHRING, WJ ;

GOSS, B ;

COLES, MGH ;

MEYER, DE ;

DONCHIN, E .

PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 1993, 4 (06) :385-390

[8] ERP CORE: An open resource for human event-related potential research [J].

Kappenman, Emily S. ;

Farrens, Jaclyn L. ;

Zhang, Wendy ;

Stewart, Andrew X. ;

Luck, Steven J. .

NEUROIMAGE, 2021, 225

[9] Methodological Choices in Event-Related Potential (ERP) Research and Their Impact on Internal Consistency Reliability and Individual Differences: An Examination of the Error-Related Negativity (ERN) and Anxiety [J].

Klawohn, Julia ;

Meyer, Alexandria ;

Weinberg, Anna ;

Hajcak, Greg .

JOURNAL OF ABNORMAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2020, 129 (01) :29-37

[10]

Luck SJ, 2014, INTRODUCTION TO THE EVENT-RELATED POTENTIAL TECHNIQUE, 2ND EDITION, P1

← 1 2 →