Performance of the loblolly pine fusiform rust disease resistance gene (Fr1) in a slashXloblolly pine hybrid family

Unexpectedly high levels of field susceptibility to the fusiform rust fungus observed for slashXloblolly hybrid families in the Cooperative Forest Genetics Research Program Pine Hybrid Trials led to several hypotheses concerning causation of the observed susceptibility. One of these hypotheses involved the failure of major resistance genes to appropriately function in this particular hybrid combination. This current work, involving the loblolly pine resistance gene Fr1 and a fusiform rust inoculum avirulent against Fr1 resistance in a greenhouse trial, delineates the investigation of major gene resistance for a particular slashXloblolly hybrid family. In this trial, the Fr1 resistance allele, derived from the heterozygous (Fr1/fr1) loblolly male parent and transferred to hybrid offspring that should have been segregating 1:1 for resistance, was fully penetrant. Likewise, in the pure-species loblolly control, the Fr1 resistance allele was again fully penetrant, and the performances of our hybrid family and the loblolly control family (both of which segregated for Fr1 resistance) were comparable. These results by inductive reasoning refute the hypothesis that major resistance genes are not appropriately functional in a slashXloblolly hybrid background.